Carlos Delgado, HOF?

[Frow]

Delgado was head and shoulders above Jason Kendall.

They play completely different positions and have different values based upon that position.

Also if you read my post I was posting people who had 100+ on their Hall Of Fame monitor which his is 2 points lower than Delgado's and his HOFstandards are 6 points lower.

 

[elmalo]

They play completely different positions and have different values based upon that position.

Also if you read my post I was posting people who had 100+ on their Hall Of Fame monitor which his is 2 points lower than Delgado's and his HOFstandards are 6 points lower.

I realize that they played different positions. He is still head and shoulders above Kendall. If Kendall was a great catcher it would be different, but he wasnt.

 

[Frow]

After comparing their numbers side to side, outside of the power numbers I wouldn't say he's head and shoulders above him. Granted I know chicks dig the long ball, but really not a bad apples and oranges comparison. Speed guy vs power guy and surprisingly the catcher is the speed guy..lol

 

[elmalo]

After comparing their numbers side to side, outside of the power numbers I wouldn't say he's head and shoulders above him. Granted I know chicks dig the long ball, but really not a bad apples and oranges comparison. Speed guy vs power guy and surprisingly the catcher is the speed guy..lol

Yes, and those power numbers are what put him head and shoulders above him,