Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Will Selig deny Melky's batting title?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Austin

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
5,708
Reaction score
44
Location
Dallas, Texas
Melky Cabrera could win the batting title if McCutchen doesn't overtake him.
But should he be allowed to win it, if he tested positive and admitted he cheated?

Here's Selig's response from ESPN.com:

NEW YORK -- Major League Baseball appears unlikely to interfere if Melky Cabrera wins the NL batting title while serving his 50-game suspension for a positive drug test.

The San Francisco Giants outfielder began Wednesday with a league-leading .346 average, seven points ahead of Pittsburgh's Andrew McCutchen.

Cabrera has 501 plate appearances, one fewer than the required amount if the Giants play 162 games. Under section 10.22(a) of the Official Baseball Rules, he would win the batting title if an extra hitless at-bat is added to his average and it remains higher than that of any other qualifying player.

"We'll see how it all plays out," baseball commissioner Bud Selig said Wednesday after taping an episode of "CenterStage" for the YES Network. "We generally don't interfere in that process. We'll take a look at it at the end of the year."

Cabrera, the All-Star game MVP, was suspended Aug. 15 for a positive test for testosterone and is missing the final 45 games of the regular season.

During the YES interview, scheduled to air for the first time Sept. 27, Selig was asked whether records set during the Steroids Era should be revisited.

"You can't change records because once you get into that it would never stop," Selig said. "It would create more problems than it would solve."
 
Last edited:

nborton

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
3,033
Reaction score
0
Location
Winston-Salem, NC
This is a weird one for me. On one hand he got caught cheating which you would think nullifies anything he achieved. Sort of like getting caught cheating in a game of anything makes you lose. However, the punishment for steroids is a suspension. Not a suspension plus voiding of stats. Because in some ways his stats are not able to be voided without affecting the outcome of games.

If I was commissioner I would make it a clause in the future that says you keep your stats, but can't win any awards.
 

Yadier2004

New member
Joined
Aug 27, 2012
Messages
78
Reaction score
0
Location
Missouri
NO way he should be aloud to win any awards! Also these suspensions need to be 1 year (162 games) for first positive test, second positive test should me life time suspension! Of course with NO awards!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com
 

wolfmanalfredo

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
8,606
Reaction score
5
Location
Minnesota
This is a weird one for me. On one hand he got caught cheating which you would think nullifies anything he achieved. Sort of like getting caught cheating in a game of anything makes you lose. However, the punishment for steroids is a suspension. Not a suspension plus voiding of stats. Because in some ways his stats are not able to be voided without affecting the outcome of games.

If I was commissioner I would make it a clause in the future that says you keep your stats, but can't win any awards.

I am in agreement with this. Its hard to nuillify the stats without going back and removing stats from games and possibily affecting outcomes. I also agree that there should be a clause that effectively states that your stats remain unchanged, but you ultimitaley forfeit any and all awards that could have possibly been earned in a suspension season.
 

wolfmanalfredo

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
8,606
Reaction score
5
Location
Minnesota
NO way he should be aloud to win any awards! Also these suspensions need to be 1 year (162 games) for first positive test, second positive test should me life time suspension! Of course with NO awards!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com

I feel like that is a little harsh. The way they have it set up now is adequate. You get 50 games, and your reputation shot for the rest of your career and lifetime in a sense. 100 games for 2nd offense essentially shuts you out for an entire season. 3rd is bannishment if I'm not mistaken, and that seems to be o.k. with me personally.
 

uniquebaseballcards

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
6,783
Reaction score
0
Without bringing emotion into the discussion, its impossible to delete stats because nobody knows for sure when the player started using. Taking away the offender's stats would also mean you'd have to adjust all other stats associated with it - the ERAs of pitchers who pitched against him, team wins/losses when the player was playing, etc.; it just never ends. Awards like the batting title are based on stats, so it doesn't make sense to take away the award if the stats aren't being taken away. Besides the runner-up may not want to win the award that way anyway.

Season awards like batting titles and HOF election are two separate things as HOF voting isn't only based on stats and the player gets elected - a different process altogether.

In the end, baseball "kind of emulates life"... so its not surprising this kind of thing happens in baseball because we all know it happens in life.
 

sportscardtheory

Active member
Joined
Aug 16, 2008
Messages
8,461
Reaction score
2
Location
Buffalo, New York
NO way he should be aloud to win any awards! Also these suspensions need to be 1 year (162 games) for first positive test, second positive test should me life time suspension! Of course with NO awards!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com

Stats aren't awards.
 

Yadier2004

New member
Joined
Aug 27, 2012
Messages
78
Reaction score
0
Location
Missouri
I didn't say stats are awards! But if his batting average is the highest its an award which shouldn't be aloud if your caught cheating!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com
 

wolfmanalfredo

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
8,606
Reaction score
5
Location
Minnesota
I didn't say stats are awards! But if his batting average is the highest its an award which shouldn't be aloud if your caught cheating!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com

Until they make new rules on the subject, it is allowed unfortunately
 

Crewfan82

New member
Joined
Apr 21, 2009
Messages
1,243
Reaction score
0
Good thing there is no triple crown hopeful in the NL. That would open a can of worms.
 

sportscardtheory

Active member
Joined
Aug 16, 2008
Messages
8,461
Reaction score
2
Location
Buffalo, New York
I didn't say stats are awards! But if his batting average is the highest its an award which shouldn't be aloud if your caught cheating!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com

They can't arbitrarily take players' stats away due to failed drug tests in 2012. Otherwise they would have to do the same for EVERY player who has ever failed a drug test, which would really make a mess. Stats are not awards, so they can't simply make them disappear. They happened.
 

elmalo

New member
Joined
Feb 19, 2010
Messages
5,216
Reaction score
0
I didn't say stats are awards! But if his batting average is the highest its an award which shouldn't be aloud if your caught cheating!

Sent from my MB865 using Sports Cards by Freedom Card Board.com
But it isnt an award.
 

elmalo

New member
Joined
Feb 19, 2010
Messages
5,216
Reaction score
0
The first question should be, can Selig deny Melky the batting title?
 

Austin

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
5,708
Reaction score
44
Location
Dallas, Texas
I bet Selig is praying for McCutchen's bat to get hot these last weeks so he doesn't have to worry about it.
 

Members online

Latest posts

Top