49ers Fans: Who do you want to be the QB?

[DRav87]

Pretty simple, 49ers fans who do you want to be the QB?

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

After that showing yesterday I think Smith deserves to at least start the next game going forward to see what he can do! If Smith chokes next week or is as bad as Hill was this week (Hill couldn't get the offense in the game, he just couldn't get it going & there's really no other explanation as to Smith coming in & jumpstarting the offense in the final quarter of the game other than him being the better QB for that offense, if not at least for that matchup) then I could understand the thought process of benching Smith as they did Hill, though bringing in Hill as the replacement this time if Smith sputter's! Couldn't hurt & IMO Smith earned this start! Just my opinion, Dave.

 

[sffanmike25]

Might as well let Alex have another week or two in there and see if he can give this offense a kick-start. Not exactly enthusiastic about either QB option, but figure why not go with the hot hand for now. He'll get a nice test in Indy this coming week.

 

[CollectorsCorner]

 

[sffanmike25]

The NFL TD reception leader.

 

[lisu]

I still have a nice Alex Smith collection, so hoping he does well. I also have a Smith jersey, so hoping I can wear it to a game soon!

 

[Daltonb1219]

I vote Nate Davis

 

[lisu]

I vote Nate Davis

Not this year. Maybe in a couple of years. The best way to ruin a QB is throw him in behind a crappy OL. LOL.

 

[Daltonb1219]

I vote Nate Davis

Not this year. Maybe in a couple of years. The best way to ruin a QB is throw him in behind a crappy OL. LOL.

Very true.

 

[EricInCT]

The same situation is happening tonight.....Jason Campbell who can't throw the ball down field to save his life, I think he has 70 yards at the half at less than 50% completion and consistently misses his target........but he is in the game and I guarantee you he won't be pulled........so why was Hill? I still can't figure it out especially coming off a bye.


This team won't win more than 4 games the rest of the way with Smith.....the losing starts in a bloodbath at Indy this weekend.....where I see 14 for 33 and 217 yards with 1 TD and 3 INTs......those are generous numbers.

Singletary will definitely be fired by the end of the year and a monkey will take his place.

Maybe Hill is banging his wife?

I just checked....100 yards for Campbell with 1 INT 2 fumbles and 2 sacks.

 

[DRav87]

I still have a nice Alex Smith collection, so hoping he does well. I also have a Smith jersey, so hoping I can wear it to a game soon!

Yeah I got a Smith jersey as well and I would like to wear it. :lol:

 

[lisu]

The same situation is happening tonight.....Jason Campbell who can't throw the ball down field to save his life, I think he has 70 yards at the half at less than 50% completion and consistently misses his target........but he is in the game and I guarantee you he won't be pulled........so why was Hill? I still can't figure it out especially coming off a bye.


This team won't win more than 4 games the rest of the way with Smith.....the losing starts in a bloodbath at Indy this weekend.....where I see 14 for 33 and 217 yards with 1 TD and 3 INTs......those are generous numbers.

Singletary will definitely be fired by the end of the year and a monkey will take his place.

Maybe Hill is banging his wife?

I just checked....100 yards for Campbell with 1 INT 2 fumbles and 2 sacks.

The problem is there is no 1st round draft pick on the bench behind Campbell. The Niners are trying to salvage their season, and Hill also had a poor game against the Falcons. I have a wait and see attitude towards this weekend's game. Alex Smith has all the physical talents to succeed - he just needs to use them.

 

[Card Magnet]

I like this move. The 49ers obviously need a kick in the ass, and Alex Smith is the thing to do it.

Alex Smith was a stud in college. I know that doesn't always translate into the NFL, but it does show that the guy has some ability. Look at somebody like Tony Romo. He was at one point behind Drew Henson on the depth chart. He developed during his bench time, and is now a solid starter (although he does have his horrific moments).

Alex Smith had 3 TDs that game compared to Hill's 0, although Smith threw one pick.
Alex Smith averaged over 9 yards per completion, where Hill has under 7 yards/completion on the season.
Alex Smith had a 68.2% completion percentage, compared to Hill's 56.1 season average.

Alex Smith is the better choice. Singletary will not be fired.

The Skins have Todd Collins at backup. He's not a guy you want to have as your full blown starter at this point. If Colt Brennan were not on IR, they would pull Campbell at some point to either try and get something working, groom a future QB, or test what they really got with the college phenom (if not a mix of those).

 

[EricInCT]

I like this move. The 49ers obviously need a kick in the ass, and Alex Smith is the thing to do it.

Alex Smith was a stud in college. I know that doesn't always translate into the NFL, but it does show that the guy has some ability. Look at somebody like Tony Romo. He was at one point behind Drew Henson on the depth chart. He developed during his bench time, and is now a solid starter (although he does have his horrific moments).

Alex Smith had 3 TDs that game compared to Hill's 0, although Smith threw one pick.
Alex Smith averaged over 9 yards per completion, where Hill has under 7 yards/completion on the season.
Alex Smith had a 68.2% completion percentage, compared to Hill's 56.1 season average.

Alex Smith is the better choice. Singletary will not be fired.

The Skins have Todd Collins at backup. He's not a guy you want to have as your full blown starter at this point. If Colt Brennan were not on IR, they would pull Campbell at some point to either try and get something working, groom a future QB, or test what they really got with the college phenom (if not a mix of those).

What happened to Colt?

I think Campbell was sacked a zillion times last night....every time I looked up I saw him being crushed.

Alex Smith will start against the Colts on Sunday. Ironically one of his first starts in the NFL was against the Colts and he had 4 INTs......it is better that Hill sits this week......Maybe he will come in and rally them to 21 points in the second half once Smith breaks his leg on the 5th sack.

Actually Smith won't be sacked much, he will break his leg going after the guy who INT the ball :lol:

I may have to put a wager on this game, I have to check the line. Under 14 is a gift.

 

[EricInCT]

I like this move. The 49ers obviously need a kick in the ass, and Alex Smith is the thing to do it.

Alex Smith was a stud in college. I know that doesn't always translate into the NFL, but it does show that the guy has some ability. Look at somebody like Tony Romo. He was at one point behind Drew Henson on the depth chart. He developed during his bench time, and is now a solid starter (although he does have his horrific moments).

Alex Smith had 3 TDs that game compared to Hill's 0, although Smith threw one pick.
Alex Smith averaged over 9 yards per completion, where Hill has under 7 yards/completion on the season.
Alex Smith had a 68.2% completion percentage, compared to Hill's 56.1 season average.

Alex Smith is the better choice. Singletary will not be fired.

The Skins have Todd Collins at backup. He's not a guy you want to have as your full blown starter at this point. If Colt Brennan were not on IR, they would pull Campbell at some point to either try and get something working, groom a future QB, or test what they really got with the college phenom (if not a mix of those).

How are you comparing season stats to someone who played a half versus someone who played 5 games? ::facepalm::

Here is a stat if you really want to look at hard numbers:

1st and 10 from their own 38 yard line and 51 seconds left going for it obviously on 4th down:

Spike it on first down.

Short Pass incomplete.

Scramble for 5 yards ( GREAT move!)

4th down get called for a delay of game penalty, no play.

5th down throw your first INT of the season.

LOL, I would really want this bust leading my team.....Singletary will be fired when they started 3-0 and lose 7 or 8 of their final 10 games.

 

[lisu]

How are you comparing season stats to someone who played a half versus someone who played 5 games? ::facepalm::

Here is a stat if you really want to look at hard numbers:

1st and 10 from their own 38 yard line and 51 seconds left going for it obviously on 4th down:

Spike it on first down.

Short Pass incomplete.

Scramble for 5 yards ( GREAT move!)

4th down get called for a delay of game penalty, no play.

5th down throw your first INT of the season.

LOL, I would really want this bust leading my team.....Singletary will be fired when they started 3-0 and lose 7 or 8 of their final 10 games.

Really? There was obviously some miscommunication on that last series between the sideline and the QB. Sometimes you do have to scramble when your line isn't blocking well. Hill would have been sacked for a loss. Let's see what happens when he has had a full week to prepare to be the starter.

 

[Card Magnet]

I like this move. The 49ers obviously need a kick in the ass, and Alex Smith is the thing to do it.

Alex Smith was a stud in college. I know that doesn't always translate into the NFL, but it does show that the guy has some ability. Look at somebody like Tony Romo. He was at one point behind Drew Henson on the depth chart. He developed during his bench time, and is now a solid starter (although he does have his horrific moments).

Alex Smith had 3 TDs that game compared to Hill's 0, although Smith threw one pick.
Alex Smith averaged over 9 yards per completion, where Hill has under 7 yards/completion on the season.
Alex Smith had a 68.2% completion percentage, compared to Hill's 56.1 season average.

Alex Smith is the better choice. Singletary will not be fired.

The Skins have Todd Collins at backup. He's not a guy you want to have as your full blown starter at this point. If Colt Brennan were not on IR, they would pull Campbell at some point to either try and get something working, groom a future QB, or test what they really got with the college phenom (if not a mix of those).

How are you comparing season stats to someone who played a half versus someone who played 5 games? ::facepalm::

Here is a stat if you really want to look at hard numbers:

1st and 10 from their own 38 yard line and 51 seconds left going for it obviously on 4th down:

Spike it on first down.

Short Pass incomplete.

Scramble for 5 yards ( GREAT move!)

4th down get called for a delay of game penalty, no play.

5th down throw your first INT of the season.

LOL, I would really want this bust leading my team.....Singletary will be fired when they started 3-0 and lose 7 or 8 of their final 10 games.

Alex Smith vs Texans - 15/22 (68.2%) for 206 yds (9.4 avg), 3 TDs, 1 INT, 0 Sacks
Shaun Hill vs Texans - 6/11 (54.5%) for 45 yds (4.1 avg), 0 TDs, 0 INT, 2 sacks

As far as comparing Smith in his partial game to Hill all season... Hill put up close to his average completion percentage in his partial game as he was doing all season.

An average is an accepted prediction of how somebody will do because that is what they normally do. While it does fluctuate based on matchups, it's still acceptable to say you can expect a player's numbers to be in the general range of his average.

Smith had 3 TDs in a partial game, which is only 2 shy of what Hill has done all season. Yes, some things went wrong but the guy is a bit rusty. He's gotta get back into the groove of managing the play clock and calling plays. I can't blame him for scrambling, would you rather he take a sack?

Singletary will not be fired at the end of this season. He is the best thing to have happened to the 9ers in a long time.

The 49ers will have at least 3 easy matchups throughout the rest of the season (Rams, Lions, Titans). They have a chance with some other teams like Seattle and Jacksonville.

 

[Card Magnet]

1 out of 15 FCBers agree - Shaun Hill is the right choice! And Eric is damn proud to say it! :lol:

1/15...looks like a Shaun Hill passing log.

 

[DRav87]

1 out of 15 FCBers agree - Shaun Hill is the right choice! And Eric is damn proud to say it! :lol:

1/15...looks like a Shaun Hill passing log.

I still don't understand why Eric loves Shaun Hill so much.

 

[mstng99tim]

[quote="Card Magnet":1n4prq3j]1 out of 15 FCBers agree - Shaun Hill is the right choice! And Eric is damn proud to say it! :lol:

1/15...looks like a Shaun Hill passing log.

I still don't understand why Eric loves Shaun Hill so much.[/quote:1n4prq3j]

He probably invested in him. :lol: