5th Prospect Ceiling Poll - Catcher

[Jaypers]

Time for another poll, this time for catchers. Obviously Wieters would be the top guy, but who would you vote for behind him? Please feel free to explain your votes if you like.

 

[Wes]

DON'T BET AGAINST BUSTER!

 

[EricInCT]

Time for another poll, this time for catchers. Obviously Wieters would be the top guy, but who would you vote for behind him? Please feel free to explain your votes if you like.

Arencibia.

 

[Jaypers]

Time for another poll, this time for catchers. Obviously Wieters would be the top guy, but who would you vote for behind him? Please feel free to explain your votes if you like.

Arencibia.

Hallsgator? Is that you?

 

[EricInCT]

Time for another poll, this time for catchers. Obviously Wieters would be the top guy, but who would you vote for behind him? Please feel free to explain your votes if you like.

Arencibia.

Hallsgator? Is that you?

Ha, hey that gator guy is cool........I would definitely say Santana over Posey.

 

[darocker80]

I think its not even a comparison. in additon, buster can play any other position and is very atheltic and his bat is mlb ready. just needs to tone up calling the games and he'll be in the bay by sept.

 

[sheetskout]

I would take Skipworth over either. He is more likely to stick at Catcher than Posey or Santana.

 

[95vr4]

Ceiling wise?

Santana hands down.

 

[darocker80]

I would take Skipworth over either. He is more likely to stick at Catcher than Posey or Santana.

where do you think posey will end up? He played SS all his life (pretty sure and made the switch to catcher as a sophmore) So you think he'll end up in the infield?

 

[darocker80]

btw, posey has a Hr in spring training, woot! haha

 

[rico08]

Again, if we're going on ceiling--not quickness to the majors--then Santana is the man.

 

[darocker80]

Again, if we're going on ceiling--not quickness to the majors--then Santana is the man.

i agree santana does have a huge ceiling, but i also think posey has just as big of a ceiling. look at his college stats and then won the golden spikes award (previously won by david price and tim lincecum).

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

My vote on ceiling goes to Santana (although I know many on this board have Posey B.Chrome stash's so I'm betting he wins the voting contest).

 

[Brett Keith]

I think its not even a comparison. in additon, buster can play any other position and is very atheltic and his bat is mlb ready. just needs to tone up calling the games and he'll be in the bay by sept.

How is it not even a comparison? I think this is the closest poll yet. How does Buster's ability to play any other position impact his ceiling?

 

[darocker80]

I think its not even a comparison. in additon, buster can play any other position and is very atheltic and his bat is mlb ready. just needs to tone up calling the games and he'll be in the bay by sept.

How is it not even a comparison? I think this is the closest poll yet. How does Buster's ability to play any other position impact his ceiling?

sorry i misenterpreted the question, if its ceiling i am saying its clsoe sorry

 

[Jaypers]

How is it not even a comparison? I think this is the closest poll yet.

::atting self on back::: My job is done here. Keep them votes coming.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

Montero?

 

[Jaypers]

Montero?

I considered putting him in, but many are saying he's likely to shift to 1B.

 

[darocker80]

Montero?

I considered putting him in, but many are saying he's likely to shift to 1B.

romine should be catcher, no?

 

[Jaypers]

Montero?

I considered putting him in, but many are saying he's likely to shift to 1B.

romine should be catcher, no?

Yes, he's more likely to stay there.