A baseball/ football trade Im considering scan of quad added

[Weatherwarrior]

I was wondering if some fellow board members could lend me some advice on what they think about this potential deal

I get:
(Football)
Matt Ryan/ Joe Flacco/ Chad Henne/ Brian Brohm SP Threads Multi Marks Auto 5/5

Matt Ryan UD Draft Auto
and possibly Matt Ryan/ Harry Douglas SP Threads Dual Auto

For:
Porcello EEE Blue aspirations Auto (in Sig)
Sterling Montero Jsy Auto
Tyson Brummett Gold Status auto/5
Matt Wieters Razor Signature Auto parallel /25


Not Looking to get bashed here but I value peoples opinions I really like the quad and the only two cards of real value are the orcello and wieters that I have $200 cv in

Lmk what you think guys and I appreciate the look

 

[blanning71]

Re: A baseball/ football trade I am considering

well, with the Ryan stuff, he has a good career ahead of him and with Flacco doing as well as he did this year, you could score big if you decided to move that stuff later on down the road. Obviously, the prospects stuff is a gamble. These guys haven't set foot in a MLB game yet.

I would take side A on the premise that these guys have one full year in the pros and they did fairly well aside from Henne and Brohm.

 

[Weatherwarrior]

Re: A baseball/ football trade I am considering

that is how I felt blanning71 and the quad #5/5 is nice


And Henne could be the dolphins starter soon after Chad Leaves.

 

[[email protected]]

I don't like the trade. With baseball season around the corner, you have "potential" to get a little more, and then buy the football when it cools down due to the offseason. I really don't like the quad auto look either..

 

[KOBEARODLT]

the only thing i dont like about the quad is henne and brohm...they really have no potential of being any good or even staying in the nfl, i mean how many qb's have you seen from each draft that have actually panned out...lucky if there is one per draft, if you really want a nice card of ryan and flacco than get a sick dual of them, jmo though!

 

[Weatherwarrior]

I don't like the trade. With baseball season around the corner, you have "potential" to get a little more, and then buy the football when it cools down due to the offseason. I really don't like the quad auto look either..

Thanks Next I feel like I am torn! I am a huge ryan/ falcons fan I just am unsure at this point.

 

[[email protected]]

I don't like the trade. With baseball season around the corner, you have "potential" to get a little more, and then buy the football when it cools down due to the offseason. I really don't like the quad auto look either..

Thanks Next I feel like I am torn! I am a huge ryan/ falcons fan I just am unsure at this point.

I agree w/ what Kobeguy said, I would just look for some sweet Ryan cards. If you like him, then why would you want some other scrub junking up his card?..lol

 

[kentuckyderby]

load up on single autos of guys you like and don't let other sigs ruin it

For example, USA David Price autos cards = yes
USA dual Price with Gunderson = iffy

 

[flightposite]

I'm siding with the what you have already side of this argument. Though Matt Ryan is going to have a great career, the cards you are getting are going to be the ones that do not hold great value as they aren't even close to his best. Not to mention they aren't rookie cards, they are just signed inserts. There are already quite a few different quad autos on the market of those qbs, with even more, better ones coming.

You have, on the other hand, rare rookies (Elites) that I think will only appreciate with time.

If I was going to trade the baseball you have for football, I would actually just sell the baseball and put it towards and Exquiste/National Treasures/SP Authentic Matt Ryan.

I know the football card industry and that is my two cents.

 

[Weatherwarrior]

I don't like the trade. With baseball season around the corner, you have "potential" to get a little more, and then buy the football when it cools down due to the offseason. I really don't like the quad auto look either..

Thanks Next I feel like I am torn! I am a huge ryan/ falcons fan I just am unsure at this point.

I agree w/ what Kobeguy said, I would just look for some sweet Ryan cards. If you like him, then why would you want some other scrub junking up his card?..lol

you guys are right I was hypnotized by the 5/5 it would be a sick dual though!

Thanks for the input flight I may just snag the UD draft auto from him and maybe the Ryan Douglas dual for some smaller stuff!