Andrew McCutchen Named MLB ROY by Baseball America

[subject to change]

One that hasn't been posted yet (apologies for the dust):

That's one I've never seen before. What year/set is it from?

 

[carlitoson]

That's one I've never seen before. What year/set is it from?

2005 Bowman Heritage (51 Topps Heritage Red Backs)

 

[Jays_Cards]

Stats almost identical? Yeah except that 40 point diffence in average! The fact that Coughlin had more ABs makes that MORE impressive! I find it funny the guys that stick up for McCutchen are the guys that have thousands of dollars wrapped up in his crappy cards! Coughlin is much better, and so are Hanson and Happ!

Ignorance must truly be bliss...

 

[shephech]

Stats almost identical? Yeah except that 40 point diffence in average! The fact that Coughlin had more ABs makes that MORE impressive! I find it funny the guys that stick up for McCutchen are the guys that have thousands of dollars wrapped up in his crappy cards! Coughlin is much better, and so are Hanson and Happ!

Ignorance must truly be bliss...

Cutch is very good.... But I gotta agree with everything he said.

Shep :ugeek:

 

[Jays_Cards]

Stats almost identical? Yeah except that 40 point diffence in average! The fact that Coughlin had more ABs makes that MORE impressive! I find it funny the guys that stick up for McCutchen are the guys that have thousands of dollars wrapped up in his crappy cards! Coughlin is much better, and so are Hanson and Happ!

Ignorance must truly be bliss...

Cutch is very good.... But I gotta agree with everything he said.

Shep :ugeek:

Coghlan had a good year, but the stats clearly favor McCutchen. As far as "agreeing" with everything he said. Calling anyone's cards "crappy" is pretty derogatory..Especially when you have a bunch of cards worth $3 in your sig......

 

[shephech]

Well minus that part..... but I must say that Cutch will probably get more love here though.... as many have invested in him, and it was a good idea.

Shep :ugeek:

 

[EricInCT]

Cutch should win the real roy award too. It is a lot easier for a pitcher to do well, then a hitter. Especially a hitter with no lineup around him. Cutch had at least 2 walkoffs maybe he had a 3rd I can't remember?

LMAO

 

[EricInCT]

And to think he wasn't even the best rookie on his TEAM!


Hope he gets some nice hardware from Baseball America, because Hanson will win the real award.

Just cause you keep repeating yourself, it doesn't mean it will HAPPen. JA will win the NL award...and rightfully so.

Happ ain't winning crap, he can't even be trusted in the post season to pitch.

Hanson would have already started 4 games in the post season if the braves were still in it.