Medeiros doesn't shock me one bit, I don't think this kid has the stuff to be a major league pitcher. I don't understand why he went first round, I would have had him in the 3rd to 5th round. Gatewood is a surprise, I would have thought he was top 5 at least.
Welcome to our community
Be apart of something great, join today!
BA's Organizational Top 10 Prospects List Official Thread
- Thread starter Jaypers
- Start date
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
r2d2
Active member
No Heredia on Pirates =(
- Thread starter
- #44
I haven't gotten my N.L. West issue yet, but the DBacks' list just went up on the site.
ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS
TOP 10 PROSPECTS
1. Archie Bradley, rhp
2. Braden Shipley, rhp
3. Aaron Blair, rhp
4. Yasmany Tomas, of/3b
5. Touki Toussaint, rhp
6. Jake Lamb, 3b
7. Brandon Drury, 3b/2b
8. Pete O’Brien, c/1b
9. Domingo Leyba, 2b/ss
10. Nick Ahmed, ss
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average Jake Lamb
Best Power Hitter Yasmany Tomas
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Sergio Alcantara
Fastest Baserunner Matt McPhearson
Best Athlete Socrates Brito
Best Fastball Enrique Burgos
Best Curveball Braden Shipley
Best Slider Will Locante
Best Changeup Braden Shipley
Best Control Aaron Blair
Best Defensive Catcher Michael Perez
Best Defensive Infielder Nick Ahmed
Best Infield Arm Sergio Alcantara
Best Defensive Outfielder Evan Marzilli
Best Outfield Arm Socrates Brito
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Pete O’Brien
First Base Paul Goldschmidt
Second Base Brandon Drury
Third Base Jake Lamb
Shortstop Chris Owings
Left Field Mark Trumbo
Center Field A.J. *******
Right Field Yasmany Tomas
No. 1 Starter Pat Corbin
No. 2 Starter Archie Bradley
No. 3 Starter Braden Shipley
No. 4 Starter Aaron Blair
No. 5 Starter Touki Toussaint
Closer Addison Reed
ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS
TOP 10 PROSPECTS
1. Archie Bradley, rhp
2. Braden Shipley, rhp
3. Aaron Blair, rhp
4. Yasmany Tomas, of/3b
5. Touki Toussaint, rhp
6. Jake Lamb, 3b
7. Brandon Drury, 3b/2b
8. Pete O’Brien, c/1b
9. Domingo Leyba, 2b/ss
10. Nick Ahmed, ss
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average Jake Lamb
Best Power Hitter Yasmany Tomas
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Sergio Alcantara
Fastest Baserunner Matt McPhearson
Best Athlete Socrates Brito
Best Fastball Enrique Burgos
Best Curveball Braden Shipley
Best Slider Will Locante
Best Changeup Braden Shipley
Best Control Aaron Blair
Best Defensive Catcher Michael Perez
Best Defensive Infielder Nick Ahmed
Best Infield Arm Sergio Alcantara
Best Defensive Outfielder Evan Marzilli
Best Outfield Arm Socrates Brito
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Pete O’Brien
First Base Paul Goldschmidt
Second Base Brandon Drury
Third Base Jake Lamb
Shortstop Chris Owings
Left Field Mark Trumbo
Center Field A.J. *******
Right Field Yasmany Tomas
No. 1 Starter Pat Corbin
No. 2 Starter Archie Bradley
No. 3 Starter Braden Shipley
No. 4 Starter Aaron Blair
No. 5 Starter Touki Toussaint
Closer Addison Reed
- Thread starter
- #45
The Tampa Bay Times just posted a story about their offseason. Also included was Baseball America's revised Top 30 Rays prospects -
1. OF Stephen Souza
2. SS Daniel Robertson
3. SS Willy Adames
4. RHP Alex Colome
5. C Justin O'Conner
6. SS Adrian Rondon
7. RHP Nathan Karns
8. OF Mikie Mahtook
9. 2B Ryan Brett
10. RHP Brent Honeywell
11. LHP Blake Snell
12. INF Andrew Velazquez
13. 1B Casey Gillaspie
14. RHP Taylor Guerrieri
15. SS Jake Hager
16. OF Justin Williams
17. C Nick Ciuffo
18. RHP Jose Dominguez
19. 3B Tyler Goeddel
20. 3B Richie Shaffer
21. 1B Jake Bauers
22. INF Tim Beckham
23. LHP Enny Romero
24. SS Hak-Ju Lee
25. 2B Kean Wong
26. C Luke Maile
27. RHP Burch Smith
28. RHP Ryne Stanek
29. RHP German Marquez
30. 1B Patrick Leonard
Rays say moves try to balance future, present | Tampa Bay Times
1. OF Stephen Souza
2. SS Daniel Robertson
3. SS Willy Adames
4. RHP Alex Colome
5. C Justin O'Conner
6. SS Adrian Rondon
7. RHP Nathan Karns
8. OF Mikie Mahtook
9. 2B Ryan Brett
10. RHP Brent Honeywell
11. LHP Blake Snell
12. INF Andrew Velazquez
13. 1B Casey Gillaspie
14. RHP Taylor Guerrieri
15. SS Jake Hager
16. OF Justin Williams
17. C Nick Ciuffo
18. RHP Jose Dominguez
19. 3B Tyler Goeddel
20. 3B Richie Shaffer
21. 1B Jake Bauers
22. INF Tim Beckham
23. LHP Enny Romero
24. SS Hak-Ju Lee
25. 2B Kean Wong
26. C Luke Maile
27. RHP Burch Smith
28. RHP Ryne Stanek
29. RHP German Marquez
30. 1B Patrick Leonard
Rays say moves try to balance future, present | Tampa Bay Times
bmp1971
Active member
Does this push Barreto up to number one for the A's now? I'm guessing they all just get bumped up one spot with the removal of Robertson, but then who is the number ten guy for Oakland?
Also, with Travis going to Toronto, do the Tigers and Blue Jays have updated lists?
I'd love to see the top 30 for each team.
- Thread starter
- #47
Yes, Barreto is now the A's #1 now.
I recommend you pre-order the Handbook to see their other revised lists. Ships late this month.
Last edited:
bmp1971
Active member
shayscards79
New member
LOL at Justin Williams being #16 . Good ****, it'll keep prices low.
- Thread starter
- #50
COLORADO ROCKIES
1. David Dahl, of
2. Jon Gray, rhp
3. Kyle Freeland, lhp
4. Eddie Butler, rhp
5. Ryan McMahon, 3b
6. Tom Murphy, c
7. Forrest Wall, 2b
8. Antonio Senzatela, rhp
9. Rosell Herrera, ss/2b
10. Raimel Tapia, of
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average David Dahl
Best Power Hitter Ryan McMahon
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Michael Tauchman
Fastest Baserunner Omar Carrizales
Best Athlete David Dahl
Best Fastball Kyle Freeland
Best Curveball Scott Oberg
Best Slider Kyle Freeland
Best Changeup Nelson Gonzalez
Best Control Tyler Anderson
Best Defensive Catcher Dustin Garneau
Best Defensive Infielder Emerson Jimenez
Best Infield Arm Emerson Jimenez
Best Defensive Outfielder David Dahl
Best Outfield Arm Jared Simon
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Tom Murphy
First Base Ryan McMahon
Second Base D.J. LeMahieu
Third Base Nolan Arenado
Shortstop Troy Tulowitzki
Left Field Corey Dickerson
Center Field David Dahl
Right Field Charlie Blackmon
No. 1 Starter Jon Gray
No. 2 Starter Kyle Freeland
No. 3 Starter Eddie Butler
No. 4 Starter Tyler Matzek
No. 5 Starter Antonio Senzatela
Closer Rex Brothers
1. David Dahl, of
2. Jon Gray, rhp
3. Kyle Freeland, lhp
4. Eddie Butler, rhp
5. Ryan McMahon, 3b
6. Tom Murphy, c
7. Forrest Wall, 2b
8. Antonio Senzatela, rhp
9. Rosell Herrera, ss/2b
10. Raimel Tapia, of
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average David Dahl
Best Power Hitter Ryan McMahon
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Michael Tauchman
Fastest Baserunner Omar Carrizales
Best Athlete David Dahl
Best Fastball Kyle Freeland
Best Curveball Scott Oberg
Best Slider Kyle Freeland
Best Changeup Nelson Gonzalez
Best Control Tyler Anderson
Best Defensive Catcher Dustin Garneau
Best Defensive Infielder Emerson Jimenez
Best Infield Arm Emerson Jimenez
Best Defensive Outfielder David Dahl
Best Outfield Arm Jared Simon
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Tom Murphy
First Base Ryan McMahon
Second Base D.J. LeMahieu
Third Base Nolan Arenado
Shortstop Troy Tulowitzki
Left Field Corey Dickerson
Center Field David Dahl
Right Field Charlie Blackmon
No. 1 Starter Jon Gray
No. 2 Starter Kyle Freeland
No. 3 Starter Eddie Butler
No. 4 Starter Tyler Matzek
No. 5 Starter Antonio Senzatela
Closer Rex Brothers
maxe0213
New member
Freeland higher than Butler? I would think Herrera would be higher too.
bmp1971
Active member
With Tyler Anderson's results, you'd think he would have cracked the top 10, no? He had an outstanding year at AA: 1.98 ERA in 23 starts, 118 IP.
Trevor Story must be in the top 15, right?
Trevor Story must be in the top 15, right?
- Thread starter
- #53
LOS ANGELES DODGERS
TOP 10 PROSPECTS
1. Corey Seager, ss
2. Joc Pederson, of
3. Julio Urias, lhp
4. Grant Holmes, rhp
5. Alex Verdugo, of
6. Jose De Leon, rhp
7. Chris Anderson, rhp
8. Scott Schebler, of
9. Chris Reed, lhp
10. Julian Leon, c
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average Corey Seager
Best Power Hitter Joc Pederson
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Austin Barnes
Fastest Baserunner James Baldwin III
Best Athlete James Baldwin III
Best Fastball Jacob Rhame
Best Curveball Julio Urias
Best Slider Jose De Leon
Best Changeup Julio Urias
Best Control Yimi Garcia
Best Defensive Catcher Spencer Navin
Best Defensive Infielder Erisbel Arruebarrena
Best Infield Arm Erisbel Arruebarrena
Best Defensive Outfielder Joc Pederson
Best Outfield Arm Johan Mieses
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Julian Leon
First Base Adrian Gonzalez
Second Base Howie Kendrick
Third Base Corey Seager
Shortstop Erisbel Arruebarrena
Left Field Alex Verdugo
Center Field Joc Pederson
Right Field Yasiel Puig
No. 1 Starter Clayton Kershaw
No. 2 Starter Zack Greinke
No. 3 Starter Julio Urias
No. 4 Starter Hyun-Jin Ryu
No. 5 Starter Grant Holmes
Closer Kenley Jansen
TOP 10 PROSPECTS
1. Corey Seager, ss
2. Joc Pederson, of
3. Julio Urias, lhp
4. Grant Holmes, rhp
5. Alex Verdugo, of
6. Jose De Leon, rhp
7. Chris Anderson, rhp
8. Scott Schebler, of
9. Chris Reed, lhp
10. Julian Leon, c
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average Corey Seager
Best Power Hitter Joc Pederson
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Austin Barnes
Fastest Baserunner James Baldwin III
Best Athlete James Baldwin III
Best Fastball Jacob Rhame
Best Curveball Julio Urias
Best Slider Jose De Leon
Best Changeup Julio Urias
Best Control Yimi Garcia
Best Defensive Catcher Spencer Navin
Best Defensive Infielder Erisbel Arruebarrena
Best Infield Arm Erisbel Arruebarrena
Best Defensive Outfielder Joc Pederson
Best Outfield Arm Johan Mieses
2018 LINEUP
Catcher Julian Leon
First Base Adrian Gonzalez
Second Base Howie Kendrick
Third Base Corey Seager
Shortstop Erisbel Arruebarrena
Left Field Alex Verdugo
Center Field Joc Pederson
Right Field Yasiel Puig
No. 1 Starter Clayton Kershaw
No. 2 Starter Zack Greinke
No. 3 Starter Julio Urias
No. 4 Starter Hyun-Jin Ryu
No. 5 Starter Grant Holmes
Closer Kenley Jansen
- Thread starter
- #54
Got my N.L. West issue, and here are the final two teams' lists.
SAN DIEGO PADRES
1. MATT WISLER, RHP
2. TREA TURNER, SS
3. HUNTER RENFROE, OF
4. AUSTIN HEDGES, C
5. CORY SPANGENBERG, 2B/OF
6. RYMER LIRIANO, OF
7. FERNANDO PEREZ, 2B/3B
8. MICHAEL GETTYS, OF
9. JOSE RONDON, SS
10. CASEY KELLY, RHP
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter For Average – Cory Spangenberg
Best Power Hitter – Hunter Renfroe
Best Strike-Zone Discipline – Trea Turner
Fastest Baserunner – Rico Noel
Best Athlete – Trea Turner
Best Fastball – Ryan Butler
Best Curveball – Casey Kelly
Best Slider – Matt Wisler
Best Changeup – Justin Hanc_ock
Best Control – Ronald Herrera
Best Defensive Catcher – Austin Hedges
Best Defensive Infielder – Trea Turner
Best Infield Arm – Carlos Belen
Best Defensive Outfielder – Hunter Renfroe
Best Outfield Arm – Michael Gettys
2018 LINEUP –
Catcher – Austin Hedges
First Base – Yonder Alonso
Second Base – Cory Spangenberg
Third Base – Jedd Gyorko
Shortstop – Trea Turner
Left Field – Matt Kemp
Centerfield – Wil Myers
Right Field – Hunter Renfroe
No. 1 Starter – Andrew Cashner
No. 2 Starter – Tyson Ross
No. 3 Starter – Matt Wisler
No. 4 Starter – Casey Kelly
No. 5 Starter – Elliot Morris
Closer – Kevin Quackenbush
SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS
1. ANDREW SUSAC, C
2. TYLER BEEDE, RHP
3. KYLE CRICK, RHP
4. KEURY MELLA, RHP
5. CLAYTON BLACKBURN, RHP
6. ADALBERTO MEJIA, LHP
7. TY BLACH, LHP
8. HUNTER STRICKLAND, RHP
9. MATT DUFFY, SS
10. CHRISTIAN ARROYO, SS/2B
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter For Average – Christian Arroyo
Best Power Hitter – Adam Duvall
Best Strike-Zone Discipline – Matt Duffy
Fastest Baserunner – Daniel Carbonell
Best Athlete – Gary Brown
Best Fastball – Ray Black
Best Curveball – Derek Law
Best Slider – Kyle Crick
Best Changeup – Clayton Blackburn
Best Control – Clayton Blackburn
Best Defensive Catcher – Ty Ross
Best Defensive Infielder – Ehire Adrianza
Best Infield Arm – Chris Dominguez
Best Defensive Outfielder – Gary Brown
Best Outfield Arm – Daniel Carbonell
2018 LINEUP –
Catcher – Buster Posey
First Base – Brandon Belt
Second Base – Joe Panik
Third Base – Christian Arroyo
Shortstop – Brandon Crawford
Left Field – Mac Williamson
Centerfield – Daniel Carbonell
Right Field – Hunter Pence
No. 1 Starter – Madison Bumgarner
No. 2 Starter – Matt Cain
No. 3 Starter – Tyler Beede
No. 4 Starter – Jake Peavy
No. 5 Starter – Kyle Crick
Closer – Hunter Strickland
SAN DIEGO PADRES
1. MATT WISLER, RHP
2. TREA TURNER, SS
3. HUNTER RENFROE, OF
4. AUSTIN HEDGES, C
5. CORY SPANGENBERG, 2B/OF
6. RYMER LIRIANO, OF
7. FERNANDO PEREZ, 2B/3B
8. MICHAEL GETTYS, OF
9. JOSE RONDON, SS
10. CASEY KELLY, RHP
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter For Average – Cory Spangenberg
Best Power Hitter – Hunter Renfroe
Best Strike-Zone Discipline – Trea Turner
Fastest Baserunner – Rico Noel
Best Athlete – Trea Turner
Best Fastball – Ryan Butler
Best Curveball – Casey Kelly
Best Slider – Matt Wisler
Best Changeup – Justin Hanc_ock
Best Control – Ronald Herrera
Best Defensive Catcher – Austin Hedges
Best Defensive Infielder – Trea Turner
Best Infield Arm – Carlos Belen
Best Defensive Outfielder – Hunter Renfroe
Best Outfield Arm – Michael Gettys
2018 LINEUP –
Catcher – Austin Hedges
First Base – Yonder Alonso
Second Base – Cory Spangenberg
Third Base – Jedd Gyorko
Shortstop – Trea Turner
Left Field – Matt Kemp
Centerfield – Wil Myers
Right Field – Hunter Renfroe
No. 1 Starter – Andrew Cashner
No. 2 Starter – Tyson Ross
No. 3 Starter – Matt Wisler
No. 4 Starter – Casey Kelly
No. 5 Starter – Elliot Morris
Closer – Kevin Quackenbush
SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS
1. ANDREW SUSAC, C
2. TYLER BEEDE, RHP
3. KYLE CRICK, RHP
4. KEURY MELLA, RHP
5. CLAYTON BLACKBURN, RHP
6. ADALBERTO MEJIA, LHP
7. TY BLACH, LHP
8. HUNTER STRICKLAND, RHP
9. MATT DUFFY, SS
10. CHRISTIAN ARROYO, SS/2B
BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter For Average – Christian Arroyo
Best Power Hitter – Adam Duvall
Best Strike-Zone Discipline – Matt Duffy
Fastest Baserunner – Daniel Carbonell
Best Athlete – Gary Brown
Best Fastball – Ray Black
Best Curveball – Derek Law
Best Slider – Kyle Crick
Best Changeup – Clayton Blackburn
Best Control – Clayton Blackburn
Best Defensive Catcher – Ty Ross
Best Defensive Infielder – Ehire Adrianza
Best Infield Arm – Chris Dominguez
Best Defensive Outfielder – Gary Brown
Best Outfield Arm – Daniel Carbonell
2018 LINEUP –
Catcher – Buster Posey
First Base – Brandon Belt
Second Base – Joe Panik
Third Base – Christian Arroyo
Shortstop – Brandon Crawford
Left Field – Mac Williamson
Centerfield – Daniel Carbonell
Right Field – Hunter Pence
No. 1 Starter – Madison Bumgarner
No. 2 Starter – Matt Cain
No. 3 Starter – Tyler Beede
No. 4 Starter – Jake Peavy
No. 5 Starter – Kyle Crick
Closer – Hunter Strickland
