Best Scanning Method: Need Opinions...

[jacobbocce72]

I've been fiddling with my scanner and have tried all three settings it has to offer.

So, let me know which one you like best. All three have there strong points. Opinions are greatly appreciated, as i may be re-scanning my bagwell pc with whichever looks the best.

All were scanned with the top up during the day. (Top up at night would make them look better, but, well... it's not night). Scanner used was a Canoscan LiDE 90. Please rank them, or pick your favorite off the scan alone, not cropping, card condition, etc.

So...

A

B

C

Attached a poll as well.

thanks,
Jacob

 

[RL24]

I picked A, but it's kinda hard to tell which scan looks best (in this case) without seeing the actual card. Which scan looks most like the card? C looks pretty good, but I thought A looked more like an actual in hand Pristine card.

 

[MacK]

B is too bright. I like C.

 

[jacobbocce72]

I picked A, but it's kinda hard to tell which scan looks best (in this case) without seeing the actual card. Which scan looks most like the card? C looks pretty good, but I thought A looked more like an actual in hand Pristine card.

i'll throw a few more out of something we all know and love here in a sec...

 

[ccolwell]

None. Put the card in the scanner during the night and turn the light off to make it completely dark. Leave the lid of the scanner wide open and scan the card.

 

[f2tornado]

A shows the jersey fabric better. C has better color.

 

[jacobbocce72]

all have been replaced with a more familar card to most...

Also, here is a scan of lights off at night with the top up on setting C:

 

[trolea1234]

I picked B on the Bagwell card, but since you changed the card, I like C the best