Better catcher out of these two players

[laroche17]

Russell Martin or Brian Mccann?
I say Mccann hes a wayyy better hitter and i just think he is better than russell martin but i know this question draws alot of debate so i wanna hear some thoughts.

 

[MacK]

I knew it'd be this comparison.

I prefer McCann.

 

[hofautos]

if mccann recovers from his eye problem...fingers crossed

 

[rico08]

McCann is the superior hitting catcher but Martin is the better defensive catcher.