better deal A or B

[ajbraves25]

Side A

Andrew McCutchen Aflac Chrome Refractor auto
Randy Moss 98 Contenders rookie auto with a strong auto
another $25-40 SV card

Side B

Braun 05 Chrome Draft auto
Lincecum 07 Chrome auto
Hanley Ramirez 03 Chrome auto
Markakis 03 Chrome auto BGS 9 w/10 auto
Longoria 08 UD Timelines auto SP/95

Thanks

~AJ

 

[darocker80]

For me, i'd much rather have B. Replace lincecum with an equal sv card and i'll stick take side B.

 

[CollectorsCorner]

Moss with a strong auto is hard to find and I have a little bias

 

[ajbraves25]

there is the Moss in question. I think the auto is strong, but I could be wrong. I have seen a few that are alot worse than this one

~AJ

 

[CollectorsCorner]

stronger than most but not the best I would probably switch my vote to B

 

[NYCrulesU]

B. All day.

 

[ajbraves25]

do you guys think the Cutch can get hot and sell higher this season? If he has a strong start or has his ship sailed? With being his 1st full season.

~AJ

 

[craiger122003]

Side B without a doubt

 

[imac220]

B

Not a hesitation

 

[IndyManning18]

Whatever deal you're happy with is the better deal!

 

[RiceLynnEvans75]

I'm probably biased because I collect his cards and it could also be that he's played on a bad team for awhile now, but Markakis has to be one of the more underrated/overlooked players in the game today.

 

[bodiaz]

B, not close.

 

[bodiaz]

I'm probably biased because I collect his cards and it could also be that he's played on a bad team for awhile now, but Markakis has to be one of the more underrated/overlooked players in the game today.

Markakis=Bobby Higginson. Both played for bad team, both had good arms in RF, decent power, both beloved by the home team, neither that great imo.

 

[hive17]

Side B.

At this point, you could be sitting on (I know, I know, but the numbers are there) 3-4 future HoF'ers autographed rookie cards. Side B has THE hottest names in baseball.

After I saw the way the Football HoF has been treating WR's, I just don't think that Moss card can even hold much of its value in the future. I could easily be wrong and would like to be, but that's my opinion.

 

[RiceLynnEvans75]

I'm probably biased because I collect his cards and it could also be that he's played on a bad team for awhile now, but Markakis has to be one of the more underrated/overlooked players in the game today.

Markakis=Bobby Higginson. Both played for bad team, both had good arms in RF, decent power, both beloved by the home team, neither that great imo.

Not saying he's great, I just think he's underrated/overlooked is all.

 

[jbone17]

I'm probably biased because I collect his cards and it could also be that he's played on a bad team for awhile now, but Markakis has to be one of the more underrated/overlooked players in the game today.

Markakis=Bobby Higginson. Both played for bad team, both had good arms in RF, decent power, both beloved by the home team, neither that great imo.

Give me a break.....Seriously, side B by far.

 

[ajbraves25]

Well it's fairly one sided. I am the current owner of the Chrome auto side (B). I do however have an offer on the Moss Contenders if I were to do that deal.

I would get:
$50 paypal
Tommy Hanson 09 Chrome auto
Pujols 2004 Fleer History of the Draft auto
Jason Heyward 09 Chrome Auto BGS 9.5 w/10 auto

but I'm still not sure if I want to give up all those Chromies yet. Although getting that stuff for the Moss sorta makes the deal look a bit better

~AJ