close the thread please.

[thefasterblade]

Re: NL ROY canidates ~

McCutchen also plays superior defense at a harder position.

If you didn't have Parra cards, you wouldn't make this argument.

 

[EricInCT]

Re: NL ROY canidates ~

McCutchen also plays superior defense at a harder position.

If you didn't have Parra cards, you wouldn't make this argument.

If you say so. I didn't even bring Parra up initially, haven't looked at his stats in at least a week and then with Upton getting hurt I think you can see his potential.

This is all a moot point, it will go to a pitcher anyway on a contender.

 

[thefasterblade]

This thread is an embarrassment.

 

[EricInCT]

This thread is an embarrassment.

If you say so it must be.

 

[thefasterblade]

This thread is an embarrassment.

If you say so it must be.

+1

 

[abncollectsautos]

I think Mccutchen would have to go really crazy the rest of the season to have a shot. I think it will go to a pitcher. Though I am really a huge Hanson fan, i think Happ has been the best pitcher on the best team in his division. I think Happ with Wells a very, very close second. Just my opinion.

 

[EricInCT]

I think Mccutchen would have to go really crazy the rest of the season to have a shot. I think it will go to a pitcher. Though I am really a huge Hanson fan, i think Happ has been the best pitcher on the best team in his division. I think Happ with Wells a very, very close second. Just my opinion.

That is exactly what I said too.

 

[bigpops65]

It is between Happ and Cutch.

 

[abncollectsautos]

I think Mccutchen would have to go really crazy the rest of the season to have a shot. I think it will go to a pitcher. Though I am really a huge Hanson fan, i think Happ has been the best pitcher on the best team in his division. I think Happ with Wells a very, very close second. Just my opinion.

That is exactly what I said too.

I am not agreeing with anyone, I am just stating what I think. Do not want to get caught up in the arguing within the thread.

 

[Mighty Bombjack]

Re: NL ROY canidates ~

McCutchen also plays superior defense at a harder position.

If you are going to use this argument, then I want to throw Dewter Fowler's name out there. Lead-off guy who has played excellent centerfield all season for a playoff contender.

I'm such a homer!

It's moot anyway; these guys have no chance, as the pitchers are going to get the votes. Having listened to last night's game on the radio, my vote goes to Happ.

 

[thefasterblade]

Well, McCutchen has also out hit Fowler and seems like the more impressive player off this season. The defense is just another plus over Parra.

 

[Mighty Bombjack]

Well, McCutchen has also out hit Fowler and seems like the more impressive player off this season. The defense is just another plus over Parra.

He has, that's true. He would deserve the award among the offensive players, I just want Fowler's yearlong contribution to be recognized!

It's like in 2007. Now, Ryan Braun deserved the ROY award, especially in retrospect. But Tulo is one helluva player, and he may have been the Rockies' MVP that season (Holliday or no Holliday). I wanted people to recognize his contributions to a playoff-bound team (but now this is sounding like the yearly MVP voting controversies).

 

[Rudzud]

Cutch, Hanson, and Happ...three guys that I picked up as soon as they got called up. Three guys that really solidified first place for me.