Dream Team: Your starting 9 of all time.

[scotty216brs]

CF. Ty Cobb
2B. Rogers Hornsby
LF. Ted Williams
RF. Babe Ruth
1B. Lou Gehrig
SS. Honus Wagner
3B. George Brett
C. Yogi Berra
P. Lefty Grove

 

[Nate Colbert 17]

2B Eddie Collins
3B Judy Johnson
RF Tony Gwynn
CF Oscar Charleston
1B Nate Colbert
LF Joe Medwick
C Ted "Double Duty" Radcliffe
SS Honus Wagner
P Amos Rusie

 

[MaineMule]

CF- Ty Cobb
2B- Rogers Hornsby
LF- Ted Williams
RF- Babe Ruth
1B- Lou Gehrig
C- Josh Gibson
3B- Mike Schmidt
SS- Honus Wagner
P- Walter Johnson

 

[AmishDave]

Now my dream team may be brutal, it's comprised of players I love or loved watching. The second grouping will be the 'historical' team.

C - Ivan Rodriguez
1B - Derrek Lee
2B - Danny Uggla
3B - Scott Rolen
SS - Omar Vizquel
LF - Clifford Floyd
CF - Mark Kotsay
RF - Bob Abreu
P - Joshua Michael Johnson

 

[383astro]

He was awesome. But he did have old Eddie Mathews swinging behind him.

Actually Mathews only hit after Aaron from 54-55. Starting in 56, Aaron hit 4th and Mathews 3rd ( for the majority of games). they batted Mathews in front of Aaron almost every game they played in together from 1956 to 1963. Starting in 64 Mathews production went on the decline and they batted him anywhere from 2-7.

 

[Laxcat]

Wasn't aware. It was just one of the thing I always heard. It made sense to me. Never checked the stats though.

 

[383astro]

Hugh Duffy
Ed Delahanty
Billy Hamilton (not the reds prospect)
Ty Cobb
Rickey Henderson
Sam Crawford
Hughie Jennings
Willie Keeler
Babe Ruth can hit them in when they all get on base

he can pitch too, doesnt matter where anyone else plays with that lineup

 

[Laxcat]

Hugh Duffy
Ed Delahanty
Billy Hamilton (not the reds prospect)
Ty Cobb
Rickey Henderson
Sam Crawford
Hughie Jennings
Willie Keeler
Babe Ruth can hit them in when they all get on base

he can pitch too, doesnt matter where anyone else plays with that lineup

Delahanty is one of the oddest sports stories ever. Can you imagine if that happened to someone of his caliber today?

 

[jbhofmann]

My favorites 9

2B Bip Roberts
SS Barry Larkin
CF Griffey (Mariners)
LF Eric Davis
1B Will Clark
3B Aaron Boone
RF Bo Jackson
C Benito Santiago
P Jose Rijo

 

[Laxcat]

My favorites 9

2B Bip Roberts
SS Barry Larkin
CF Griffey (Mariners)
LF Eric Davis
1B Will Clark
3B Aaron Boone
RF Bo Jackson
C Benito Santiago
P Jose Rijo

I can tell you are a Reds fan. If I made an Astros one everyone would laugh.

 

[Super Mario]

I can tell you are a Reds fan. If I made an Astros one everyone would laugh.

I really considered putting Aaron Boone on my list at 3B instead of Rolen.

 

[Hendersonfan]

1. LF - Rickey. I know Teddy Ballgame was a better hitter, but my team needs a leadoff batter and Rickey is it.
2. 2B - Morgan
3. CF - Mantle
4. C - Gibson
5. RF - Hank
6. 1B - Gehrig
7. SS - Wagner
8. 3B - Brooks
9. SP - Big Train
RP - Mariano
If DH is allowed, add Ruth into the cleanup spot and shift everyone else down one.