emmitt smith vs barry sanders $$

[daveyou]

2 of the great rb's that ever played the game

in your opinion, which of their autos were, are and will be worth more?

not that i ever go by beckett guide but so far, smith as a small advantage in terms of "booking" higher than sanders of said auto card

i haven't really done much research but is that the accurate info that smith does outsell sanders?

i just know that it seems as if there are more smith autos out than sanders

dave

 

[Ryo1549]

Emmitt Smith generally sells more than barry Sanders if we're talking the same caliber of card.

 

[CollectorsCorner]

Barry seems to sign everything

 

[Viking4Alpha]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

 

[Ryo1549]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

Winner.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

Winner.

I agree, I think he nailed every reason (also Emmitt has his own sportscard shop & has had it for quite sometime now, which is a big reason he is "in the know" with how his over-signing effect's future value's & flooding, etc....I think this has been a big reason as to why Emmitt has been somewhat particular with his signing practice).

 

[dfr52]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

Winner.

I agree, excellent points.

 

[daveyou]

thanks for the info, especially about sanders signing more than smith. i honestly did not know that and always thought it was the other way

dave

 

[Willywanker]

barry has 668 certified autos while emmitt has 451.
Barry just has way too much as was mentioned above.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

barry has 668 certified autos while emmitt has 451.
Barry just has way too much as was mentioned above.

Well if it's not that he has way too many auto's, I wonder what it is that's causing the difference in pricing (if I were a Detroit fan, I think I woulda let that info slide :lol: )

 

[tide12champrings]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

 

[Viking4Alpha]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

 

[tide12champrings]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

Time for what? Emmitt was a great rb but considering the team around him, come on.

 

[Viking4Alpha]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

Time for what? Emmitt was a great rb but considering the team around him, come on.

His backup who filled in for him back in the day when Emmitt was holding out would like to disagree with you. :lol:

 

[tide12champrings]

A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

Time for what? Emmitt was a great rb but considering the team around him, come on.

His backup who filled in for him back in the day when Emmitt was holding out would like to disagree with you. :lol:

ahh...whatever. Everyone has there own opinion. If only Barry would've played for more than 10 seasons.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

[quote="Snyper":32n9eqdn]A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

Time for what? Emmitt was a great rb but considering the team around him, come on.

His backup who filled in for him back in the day when Emmitt was holding out would like to disagree with you. :lol:

ahh...whatever. Everyone has there own opinion. If only Barry would've played for more than 10 seasons.[/quote:32n9eqdn]

Yeah I agree, it's piss-poor that he quit on his team instead of leaving it all out on the field! :lol:

 

[dfr52]

[quote="Snyper":14fh0rtp]A few things to consider-

1) Emmitt signs about half as much as Barry does. (Although Emmitt has been in more UD lately. Barry still signs waaaaaaaay more.)

2) You can call this opinion (and I understand although I'll betcha mine is the majority) but Emmitt's auto is light years better than Barry's auto as far as penmanship goes.

3) Whether the Emmitt haters like it or not, the man does have the rushing title. And oh yeah, 3 Super Bowl rings

4) Two words: Cowboys fans.

I could've rushed for 16,000 yards behind that O-line.

Was only a matter of time..

Time for what? Emmitt was a great rb but considering the team around him, come on.

His backup who filled in for him back in the day when Emmitt was holding out would like to disagree with you. :lol:

ahh...whatever. Everyone has there own opinion. If only Barry would've played for more than 10 seasons.[/quote:14fh0rtp]

His production would of dropped like nearly every other back that hits 30.

 

[Gellman]

Emmitt signs half as much because he charges more than his sigs are worth. His prices are ridiculous.