Fantasy trade question: McFadden or Moreno/Crabtree/Wells

[jdacunha]

I have the #2 overall pick in a dynasty league. My team is as follows:

Palmer, Orton
LT, Slaton, Jacobs, Bradshaw, Sproles
Colston, Braylon Edwards, Breaston, Mark Clayton
T Gonzo, Fasano
Kaeding, Prater
Eagles, Phins

I was offered D McFadden for the #2 overall and my 2nd rd pick in 2010. At #2 I would draft Moreno if he is there, or Crabtree/Well (haven't decided between the 2). I feel that McFadden is the most talented of the 4 players and would give my team very good RB depth for now and the future.

Should I make the deal?

 

[CollectorsCorner]

looking at your team I would get crabtree

 

[jdacunha]

looking at your team I would get crabtree

i am really not a fan of crabtree and i always take a RB over WR.

 

[TonyButlerStopSuckin]

I agree the McFadden is better than anyone you could draft, I would make the trade in hopes of then moving 1 of your RBs for a solid WR. Even if LT continues to slow down you will have 3 top RBs in McFadden, Slaton and Jacobs who are all young and then 2 more that could hit big if they go somewhere else. While your WR arent terrible, after Colston I wouldnt be thrilled with them.

Also, how many RBs and WRs do you have to play??

 

[jdacunha]

I agree the McFadden is better than anyone you could draft, I would make the trade in hopes of then moving 1 of your RBs for a solid WR. Even if LT continues to slow down you will have 3 top RBs in McFadden, Slaton and Jacobs who are all young and then 2 more that could hit big if they go somewhere else. While your WR arent terrible, after Colston I wouldnt be thrilled with them.

Also, how many RBs and WRs do you have to play??

We start 2 RBs, 3 WRs

Braylon is a stud. I know he had a bad year last year, but he is one of the most talented WRs in football.

What worries me with McFadden is Michael Bush. He could possibly take time away from DM.


I did win the SB last year. I traded Derrick Ward, Plaxico Burress and Willis McGahee for multiple picks which I used to trade up for the #2 overall.

 

[Ryo1549]

I'd keep MCfaddy

 

[jeramietowle]

I would do the trade and take Crabtree. Mcfadden is going to do a lot with the team has around him. I think Crabtree will have a very good year.

 

[jdacunha]

I'd keep MCfaddy

i think you misunderstod. I want to trade for DM, I have the 2nd overall pick.

 

[jdacunha]

anyone else?

 

[wheeler281]

stay away from Mcfadden IMO

 

[jdacunha]

stay away from Mcfadden IMO

WHY? HE IS A BEAST!

 

[wheeler281]

History of injuries all the way back to highschool. When is he a beast? His senior year in college was about it