Fantasy Trade Question

[Roberto_Clemente_21]

Basic 12 Team Yahoo League.
Team 1 gets:
Kinsler, Stanton, and Buchholz

Team 2 gets:
Fielder, H. Kendrick, and Gio Gonzalez

Which team wins?

 

[Sean_C]

Team 1 wins I think.

 

[Russ S.]

2.

 

[Coachman35]

team 2...in my opinion

 

[ballerskrip]

Truthfully, pretty damn even. I think you have more upside with #1, but team 2 is the safer bet.

skrip

 

[biggreen15]

i would go with team 2

 

[ajbraves25]

Side A gets you more power and steals and maybe a very tiny edge pitching. Side B definitely has the batting avg edge. I like Gio a lot this year, but Buchholz team may be better.

 

[Roberto_Clemente_21]

I was the team that received Fielder. Here is what my original team looked like:

C Napoli
1B Goldschmidt
2B Kinsler
3B Michael Young
SS Tulowitzki
OF Stanton
OF Morse
OF Maybin
UTIL Aybar
UTIL Fowler
Bench Delmon Young
SP Hanson
SP Josh Johnson
SP Buchholz
SP Lewis
SP Jurrjens
SP Danks
SP Niese
SP Nolasco
RP Papelbon
RP Bailey
RP Walden
RP Guerra

I made a trade that sent Papelbon, Morse, and Aybar and I received McCutchen, Freeman, and Volquez.

After the Fielder trade my roster now looks like:

C Napoli
1B Fielder
2B Kendrick
3B Michael Young
SS Tulowitzki
OF McCutchen
OF Maybin
OF Fowler
UTIL Freeman
UTIL Goldschmidt
Bench Delmon Young
SP Hanson
SP Josh Johnson
SP Lewis
SP Danks
SP Gio Gonzalez
SP Jurrjens
SP Niese
SP Volquez
SP Peavy
RP Bailey
RP Guerra
RP Walden