Fantasy Trade?

[MAC16]

who gets the better end?

Team A has:
Tony Romo
Ryan Grant
Frank Gore
DeAngelo Williams
Brandon Marshall
Chris Chambers
Heath Miller
Packers
Ryan Longwell

Bench:
Reggie Bush
James Jones
Brian Westbrook
Nate Burlesson
Knowshon Moreno
Jeremy Maclin
Lavernaeus Coles

Team B:
Tom Brady
Joseph Addai
Jason Snelling
Cadillac Williams
Roy Williams
Sidney Rice
Greg Olsen
Eagles
Nick Folk

Bench:
Drew Brees
Percy Harvin
John Carlson
Baylon Edwards
Broncos
Larry Johnson
Matt Hesselback

Team A gets:
Drew Brees or Tom Brady

Team B gets:
Brandon Marshall
Knowshon Moreno
Reggie Bush
Tony Romo

what do you guys think?
Team B has brady and brees and could get some value for them rather than nothing and having to sit one and get no points for him.
while getting i think a starter in moreno and marshall that will make his lineup.
let me know what you guys think?

 

[kentuckyderby]

For a top-notch QB, shouldn't the one owner offer more than a solid WR, 2 RBs who ride his bench anyway, and a QB who will sit on the bench anyway?



If one of the other 3RBs is in the deal instead, maybe the owner with Brees and Brady would consider
Give it a shot

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

Wow, you guy's start 3 RB's (is there 8 teams in the league or something)? Just curious as 3 starting rb's wouldn't leave much wiggle room in the draft for a 10 team league so i figured it must be an 8er...Which I've never played in anything under 10 teams as everyone's lineup looks like a Pro-Bowl roster, but I'm sure it is still challenging since everyone's team's consist of such high grade player's (you don't have to scrape the bottom of the barrell of the waiver-wire or worry about looking for that "diamond in the rough" who should break out)!

 

[kentuckyderby]

Wow, you guy's start 3 RB's (is there 8 teams in the league or something)? Just curious as 3 starting rb's wouldn't leave much wiggle room in the draft for a 10 team league so i figured it must be an 8er...Which I've never played in anything under 10 teams as everyone's lineup looks like a Pro-Bowl roster, but I'm sure it is still challenging since everyone's team's consist of such high grade player's (you don't have to scrape the bottom of the barrell of the waiver-wire or worry about looking for that "diamond in the rough" who should break out)!

one = RB/WR slot

10 teams

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

In all honesty team B definitely needs a boost at RB more than team A needs a replacement at QB (IMO at least). There is a HUGE "BUT" in this offer though for team B...If team B looks like they can make the playoffs with the lineup they already have- meaning will thier current record allow them to get into the playoff's or are they struggling to get in?-(& depending on when your league plays it's Championship game-Wk15, Wk16, or Wk17 of the regular season? As this could be a deciding factor as to whether Brees or Brady will even be playing as once they grasp a playoff spot I see them getting benched for health insurance for thier playoff's) then team B needs to rethink if they really want to trade away Brady, as Brees will likely be sitting as soon as the Saints grasp thier playoff home-field advantage, & them being unbeaten doesn't help team B's likelihood of Brees being active on thier squad in the later/playoff week's!

But if you're looking to upgrade at your QB position then you might have to man-up & offer one of your 3 starting rb's (as you need to consider the difference in points you'll be gaining if you add Brees/Brady while subtracting Romo from your starting offense-I'd go for Brady considering that Brees will be benched in the final weeks- & then consider the differring points you'll give away by offerring up one of your starting 3 while replacing them with Knowshon), as it may not be such a bad bet to offer away one of your top 3 in return for an upgrade at QB considering Knowshon may be able to replicate or get close enough to the pts of the starter you would be losing. If you do offer away a starter you need to look at SOS (strength of schedule) & all the other "future" component's that you look at when deciphering/estimating a player's future fantasy value...SOS & looks/touches being the pretty big deciding factor's!

Anyhow, as I wrote above, I'd go for Brady (due to the possibility that you'd only have Brees production temporarily before he is benched) & you need to look over your starting 3 & decide whom is replaceable with Knowshon down the stretch by looking at SOS, touche's/target's, are they sharing the backfeild or are they the centerpiece of said offense, the likelihood of injury, the likelihood of thier team not going anywhere (already being out of the chase) & giving another back more carries to see what they've got while resting thier starter, or the opposite (the team being set with a playoff spot & resting thier starters)....Once you cover all the base's & feel secure in your decision then send over a trade offer & don't look back (well, be willing to fluctuate but never go against your gut just to make a trade...you'll regret it in the long run)!

Good Luck & lmk who or if you end up making a trade!
Happy Thanksgiving, Dave.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

Wow, you guy's start 3 RB's (is there 8 teams in the league or something)? Just curious as 3 starting rb's wouldn't leave much wiggle room in the draft for a 10 team league so i figured it must be an 8er...Which I've never played in anything under 10 teams as everyone's lineup looks like a Pro-Bowl roster, but I'm sure it is still challenging since everyone's team's consist of such high grade player's (you don't have to scrape the bottom of the barrell of the waiver-wire or worry about looking for that "diamond in the rough" who should break out)!

one = RB/WR slot

10 teams

Oh, you're in the league KDerb? What does your squad look like? Are you winning or a cellar dweller?

 

[MAC16]

my and ky are both 5-6 we are currently tied for 5th.. both struggling to get in.

 

[onionring9]

Team B is dead in the water with and without that trade.

If I were Team B, I'd shop both Brees and Brady to two different teams. You really need to replace Snelling (he's a temp until Turner gets back), Cadillac and Roy Williams.

With this team I'd do one of these:
Brees or Brady for Marshall/Gore or Williams
then go to another team and sell your other QB for a decent QB and a better RB. If the RB is good enough of an upgrade, package the other QB with Cadillac or Snelling.

 

[kentuckyderby]

Team B is dead in the water with and without that trade.

If I were Team B, I'd shop both Brees and Brady to two different teams. You really need to replace Snelling (he's a temp until Turner gets back), Cadillac and Roy Williams.

With this team I'd do one of these:
Brees or Brady for Marshall/Gore or Williams
then go to another team and sell your other QB for a decent QB and a better RB. If the RB is good enough of an upgrade, package the other QB with Cadillac or Snelling.

above mentioned deal wasn't marshall with williams or gore
it was marshall with moreno and bush

 

[onionring9]

Team B is dead in the water with and without that trade.

If I were Team B, I'd shop both Brees and Brady to two different teams. You really need to replace Snelling (he's a temp until Turner gets back), Cadillac and Roy Williams.

With this team I'd do one of these:
Brees or Brady for Marshall/Gore or Williams
then go to another team and sell your other QB for a decent QB and a better RB. If the RB is good enough of an upgrade, package the other QB with Cadillac or Snelling.

above mentioned deal wasn't marshall with williams or gore
it was marshall with moreno and bush

Yeah, I should have said you should counter with that. moreno/marshall/bush is a bad deal.

 

[MAC16]

Team B is dead in the water with and without that trade.

If I were Team B, I'd shop both Brees and Brady to two different teams. You really need to replace Snelling (he's a temp until Turner gets back), Cadillac and Roy Williams.

With this team I'd do one of these:
Brees or Brady for Marshall/Gore or Williams
then go to another team and sell your other QB for a decent QB and a better RB. If the RB is good enough of an upgrade, package the other QB with Cadillac or Snelling.

above mentioned deal wasn't marshall with williams or gore
it was marshall with moreno and bush

Yeah, I should have said you should counter with that. moreno/marshall/bush is a bad deal.

i wasnt going to trade gore, williams, grant

i am content with my team now i dont think brady or brees are worth grant and marshall when i have romo who is pretty consistant.