FCB Group Sub - March Submission - Post Lists Here

[MartinFFcollector]

Looks like these are mine. Thanks!!
7180033 2011 Finest Rookie Dual Relic Autographs Gold Refractors Dee Gordon 9.5
7180039 2011 Topps Heritage Minors Real One Autographs Green Tint Joc Pederson 8.5
7180040 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Brian Johnson 9.5
7180041 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Deven Marrero 9.5
7180042 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Gold Refractors Branden Kline 9.0
7180043 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Gold Refractors Tyler Naquin 9.0
7180049 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Michael Wacha 9.0

 

[rbadger]

Looks like these are mine...wish the Mattingly would have gone to PSA...

7179997	Baseball	1984 Topps	Don Mattingly RC	8.5	View
7180017	Baseball	2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Refractors	Deven Marrero	9.5	View
7180019	Baseball	2005 Bowman Chrome Refractors	Mike Morse AU	9	View
7180020	Baseball	2006 Bowman Chrome Prospects	Justin Upton AU	9	View
7180021	Baseball	2006 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks	Clayton Kershaw AU	9	View
7180022	Baseball	2010 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Blue Refractors	Taijuan Walker	9.5	View
7180024	Baseball	2011 Bowman Prospects	Bryce Harper AU	9.5	View
7180027	Baseball	2011 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autographs Refractors	Matt Moore	9	View
7180031	Baseball	2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects X-Fractors	Matt Moore	9.5	View
7180032	Baseball	2011 Bowman Chrome Throwbacks Refractors	Manny Banuelos	9	View

 

[marterburn]

Not bad; 5/8! Interested in what was wrong with those USA autos...

marterburn 7180361 Baseball 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Franchise Futures Signatures Drew Vettleson/690 9.5 View
marterburn 7180362 Baseball 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Franchise Futures Signatures Drew Vettleson/690 0 View
marterburn 7180363 Baseball 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Franchise Futures Signatures Drew Vettleson/690 9.5 View
marterburn 7180366 Baseball 2010 Bowman Sterling Prospect Autographs Christian Yelich 9.5 View
marterburn 7180367 Baseball 2010 Bowman Sterling Prospect Autographs Christian Yelich 9.5 View
marterburn 7180462 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Dual Autographs Refractors Deven Marrero/Matt Reynolds 9.5 View
marterburn 7180467 Baseball 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Deven Marrero 0 View
marterburn 7180471 Baseball 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Marcus Stroman 0 View

 

[masonphillip]

This was the one card that blew me away the most.

thelesquad

7179996

Baseball

1983 Topps

Ryne Sandberg RC

9.5

Just never imagined seeing a 29 year old card grade out like that.

 

[sunojorel]

What in the hell happened to this card of mine?

sunojorel 7180004 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects Green X-Fractors Bryce Harper 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180005 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Gold Canary Diamond Jose Fernandez 4 View
sunojorel 7180009 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects Refractors Dustin Ackley 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180010 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best X-Fractors Stephen Strasburg 9 View
sunojorel 7180011 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects X-Fractors Shelby Miller 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180012 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects X-Fractors Matt Moore 9.5 View

I can't wait to see how this card looks..

 

[trolea1234]

I just hope bundy is still hot or hotter when I get them back

 

[chocsports2000]

Very happy with my grades, thanks Phil!

chocsports2000 7180241 Basketball 1992-93 Upper Deck All-Division Michael Jordan 0 View
chocsports2000 7180242 Basketball 1996-97 Topps Chrome Refractors Dennis Scott 0 View
chocsports2000 7180243 Basketball 1997-98 Topps Rock Stars Refractors Michael Jordan 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180244 Basketball 1997-98 Finest Refractors John Stockton S 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180245 Basketball 1997-98 Topps Generations Refractors Michael Jordan 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180246 Basketball 1998-99 Topps Roundball Royalty Refractors Michael Jordan 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180254 Basketball 1996-97 Upper Deck Jordan's Viewpoints Michael Jordan 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180256 Basketball 2002-03 Fleer Premium Triple Threats Kobe Bryant 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180259 Basketball 2002-03 Topps Pristine Refractors Caron Butler C 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180262 Basketball 2006-07 Finest Refractors Black Rudy Gay 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180268 Basketball 2006-07 Topps Chrome 1996-97 Variations Refractors LaMarcus Aldridge 0 View
chocsports2000 7180272 Basketball 2007-08 Topps Chrome 1957-58 Variations Refractors LeBron James 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180274 Basketball 2008-09 Fleer Derrick Rose RC 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180278 Basketball 2009-10 Topps Chrome James Harden RC 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180279 Basketball 2009-10 Topps Chrome James Harden RC 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180280 Basketball 2009-10 Topps Chrome James Harden RC 9.5 View
chocsports2000 7180282 Basketball 2009-10 Topps Chrome Refractors Gerald Henderson 9.5 View

 

[jet0002]

This dual autograph card had the autograph grade out as "0". Is that just because it was a dual?
jet0002 7180013 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Dual Autographs Purple Refractors David Dahl 9.5 View

 

[jbhofmann]

What in the hell happened to this card of mine?

sunojorel 7180004 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects Green X-Fractors Bryce Harper 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180005 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Gold Canary Diamond Jose Fernandez 4 View
sunojorel 7180009 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects Refractors Dustin Ackley 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180010 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best X-Fractors Stephen Strasburg 9 View
sunojorel 7180011 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects X-Fractors Shelby Miller 9.5 View
sunojorel 7180012 Baseball 2011 Bowman Bowman's Best Prospects X-Fractors Matt Moore 9.5 View

I can't wait to see how this card looks..

Almost a lock that there is a crease in the surface.

 

[bballcardkid]

bballcardkid 7180018 Baseball 2000 Royal Rookies Futures Autographs Miguel Cabrera 9 View
bballcardkid 7180023 Baseball 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Signature Aspirations Gary Sanchez 9.5 View
bballcardkid 7180025 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs George Springer 9.5 View
bballcardkid 7180035 Baseball 2011 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autographs Gerrit Cole/297 * 9.5 View
bballcardkid 7180036 Baseball 2011 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autographs Dylan Bundy/245 * 9 View
bballcardkid 7180037 Baseball 2011 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autographs Dylan Bundy/245 * 9.5 View
bballcardkid 7180038 Baseball 2011 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autographs Dylan Bundy/245 * 9.5 View
bballcardkid 7180083 Hockey 2011-12 Upper Deck Canvas Ryan Nugent-Hopkins YG 8.5 View

Happy with the grades, especially the Miguel Cabrera Auto. I'll probably resub the Bundy 9. Those surface grades on the UD Canvas Hockey cards are KILLING me, I have no clue what they are knocking me for on the surface. The surface is supposed to be pitted.

 

[slewfoot]

Awesome! 10/10 and I got a 10!

slewfoot 7180368 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Gold Refractors Jacob Turner 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180376 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects Gold Refractors Jacob Turner 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180432 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blue Refractors Jake Hager 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180434 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blue Refractors Taylor Guerrieri 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180440 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Refractors Bubba Starling 10 View
slewfoot 7180447 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Throwbacks Refractors Bryce Harper 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180452 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Prospect Autographs Black Refractors Sonny Gray 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180455 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Prospects Gold Refractors Brandon Nimmo 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180457 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Gold Refractors Mark Trumbo 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180460 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Refractors Eric Hosmer 9.5

 

[bear0555]

Cool. 50% is about as bad as it gets for me but I guess I'm happy with the Zunino.

bear0555 7180000 Baseball 2008 Bowman AFLAC Michael Zunino 9.5 View
bear0555 7180002 Baseball 2010 Bowman Chrome 18U USA Baseball Autographs Orange Refractors Blake Swihart 9 View
bear0555 7180006 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Trevor Bauer 9 View
bear0555 7180015 Baseball 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Blue Refractors Mark Appel 9 View
bear0555 7180016 Baseball 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Blue Refractors Brian Johnson 9.5 View
bear0555 7180017 Baseball 2011 Topps Chrome USA Baseball Autographs Refractors Deven Marrero 9.5 View

 

[jpruitt2]

How are you able to determine who sent in what on these?

jpruitt2 7180427 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9 View
jpruitt2 7180428 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9 View
jpruitt2 7180429 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

masonphillip 7180217 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180218 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180219 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180220 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180221 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180222 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

jbhofmann 7180008 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

 

[jpruitt2]

I am curious to know how this card wasn't at least a 9. That might be the cleanest card I have ever submitted.


jpruitt2 7180355 Baseball 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Orange Refractors Angel Villalona AU 0 View





Also, I guess this was mine:

7180346 Baseball 1961 Topps Brooks Robinson AS 0 View

This was supposed to be a part of the PSA submission that fell through. It wasn't meant to be sent to BGS.

 

[masonphillip]

How are you able to determine who sent in what on these?

jpruitt2 7180427 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9 View
jpruitt2 7180428 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9 View
jpruitt2 7180429 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

masonphillip 7180217 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180218 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180219 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180220 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180221 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View
masonphillip 7180222 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

jbhofmann 7180008 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blake Swihart 9.5 View

BGS does a really good job of keeping subbers cards together. So in the case of the Swiharts, I submitted 5, all MG 9.5 (so the 9s couldn't be mine at all), so the 5 that are together are mine, the 3 that are together are yours and the single one hanging out there is jbhoffmans. Additionally, the 5 were by other cards of mine. Over time this has worked time and time again.

 

[masonphillip]

Awesome! 10/10 and I got a 10!

slewfoot 7180368 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Gold Refractors Jacob Turner 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180376 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects Gold Refractors Jacob Turner 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180432 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blue Refractors Jake Hager 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180434 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Blue Refractors Taylor Guerrieri 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180440 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospect Autographs Refractors Bubba Starling 10 View
slewfoot 7180447 Baseball 2011 Bowman Chrome Throwbacks Refractors Bryce Harper 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180452 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Prospect Autographs Black Refractors Sonny Gray 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180455 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Prospects Gold Refractors Brandon Nimmo 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180457 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Gold Refractors Mark Trumbo 9.5 View
slewfoot 7180460 Baseball 2011 Bowman Sterling Refractors Eric Hosmer 9.5

You killed it my friend, that Bubba is a monster.

check this out [phil]150788210135[/phil]

 

[jpruitt2]

BGS does a really good job of keeping subbers cards together. So in the case of the Swiharts, I submitted 5, all MG 9.5 (so the 9s couldn't be mine at all), so the 5 that are together are mine, the 3 that are together are yours and the single one hanging out there is jbhoffmans. Additionally, the 5 were by other cards of mine. Over time this has worked time and time again.

This doesn't appear to always be the case. The 1961 Topps Brooks Robinson was mine and clearly isn't with the rest of my cards. I'm not so much upset with the grades as I am the possiblilty that any of those cards could have been mixed up b/c there are no clear identifiers on them.


I thank you as a Administrator for running the submission's for the board, but I do find it dissapointing that you are not willing to follow the Terms of Service that is listed for these submissions.

Freedom Card Board.com is proud to be the home of the best BGS group sub in the business. We offer the opportunity to submit cards to Beckett Grading Services to all of our members. When submitting please honor the following guidelines:

10. Cards without unique identifiers such as a 3M sticker number or serial number will be accepted on a first come first serve basis. If someone submits such a card, others who want to submit the same card will have to wait until the next submission.

If I would have realized this would have been the case I would have taken the Swihart base auto's out of my submission even though I was the first to list them in the submission thread.

 

[masonphillip]

This doesn't appear to always be the case. The 1961 Topps Brooks Robinson was mine and clearly isn't with the rest of my cards. I'm not so much upset with the grades as I am the possiblilty that any of those cards could have been mixed up b/c there are no clear identifiers on them.


I thank you as a Administrator for running the submission's for the board, but I do find it dissapointing that you are not willing to follow the Terms of Service that is listed for these submissions.




If I would have realized this would have been the case I would have taken the Swihart base auto's out of my submission even though I was the first to list them in the submission thread.

Again - if any of mine would have not hit 9.5, they would have come back 0, instead of 9, so that rules all of those out. The reason that a Robinson would be in a different part of the list is because it was in a different part of the stack as I put it in much later when the PSA wasn't happening. If you send 3 Chrome Autos of one guy, they are going to stay together. I can say with 100% confidence those are yours.

 

[jpruitt2]

Again - if any of mine would have not hit 9.5, they would have come back 0, instead of 9, so that rules all of those out. The reason that a Robinson would be in a different part of the list is because it was in a different part of the stack as I put it in much later when the PSA wasn't happening. If you send 3 Chrome Autos of one guy, they are going to stay together. I can say with 100% confidence those are yours.

So, the TOS should just be thrown out the window from this point forward? As I have already stated, I'm not that upset with the grades. That isn't my problem here. There is always a possibility that something could happen when there are no identifiers on the cards.

The TOS should be followed if we are going to have them. That is the only way to assure this doesn't happen.

 

[masonphillip]

So, the TOS should just be thrown out the window from this point forward? As I have already stated, I'm not that upset with the grades. That isn't my problem here. There is always a possibility that something could happen when there are no identifiers on the cards.

The TOS should be followed if we are going to have them. That is the only way to assure this doesn't happen.

The TOS was written and developed prior to us having a way to identify these cards to a subber, I forgot to go back and modify it, my apologies.

but the bottom line is, your cards are correct.