Grading question, experts and novices welcome ~

[EricInCT]

Ok here is the question: Do you see a difference in the centering (front or back) I just don't see it and am wondering if it is worth re-subbing.

 

[cgilmo]

grading is subjective, much like BA hot lists.

The process is up to the eye, and is far from mathematic in any way.

Different graders look at the qualities of a card differently.

 

[EricInCT]

grading is subjective, much like BA hot lists.

The process is up to the eye, and is far from mathematic in any way.

Different graders look at the qualities of a card differently.

I wholeheartedly agree with the above statement. My question is do you see a difference in centering between the three cards and is it worth re-subbing?

 

[kdailey4315]

Ironically I think the 9.5 is the least centered of them all.

 

[cgilmo]

grading is subjective, much like BA hot lists.

The process is up to the eye, and is far from mathematic in any way.

Different graders look at the qualities of a card differently.

I wholeheartedly agree with the above statement. My question is do you see a difference in centering between the three cards and is it worth re-subbing?

anything marketable that is .5 away from gem is worth resubbing

 

[EricInCT]

Ironically I think the 9.5 is the least centered of them all.

lol, I was just thinking that myself ~ not the best card but some day may demand a premium being his best auto'ed card.

 

[boomo]

to bad its travis snider :mrgreen:

 

[Card Magnet]

The order from top to bottom is left card, middle card, right card.

You can kind of tell the centering a little better now by following the cyan line up.

 

[EricInCT]

The order from top to bottom is left card, middle card, right card.

You can kind of tell the centering a little better now by following the cyan line up.

thank you for your insight....Would you resubmit just one or both?

 

[Card Magnet]

The order from top to bottom is left card, middle card, right card.

You can kind of tell the centering a little better now by following the cyan line up.

thank you for your insight....Would you resubmit just one or both?

I would try both again. They are so close that I couldn't tell you which was which if I didn't know the order. The centering seems to be about the same vertically as well.

 

[EricInCT]

[quote="Card Magnet":1pw2jr8z]The order from top to bottom is left card, middle card, right card.

You can kind of tell the centering a little better now by following the cyan line up.

thank you for your insight....Would you resubmit just one or both?

I would try both again. They are so close that I couldn't tell you which was which if I didn't know the order. The centering seems to be about the same vertically as well.[/quote:1pw2jr8z]

You have been thanked! What program do you use for the cut and pasting of the pics?

 

[Card Magnet]

[quote="Card Magnet":22at50fg]The order from top to bottom is left card, middle card, right card.

You can kind of tell the centering a little better now by following the cyan line up.

thank you for your insight....Would you resubmit just one or both?

I would try both again. They are so close that I couldn't tell you which was which if I didn't know the order. The centering seems to be about the same vertically as well.

You have been thanked! What program do you use for the cut and pasting of the pics?[/quote:22at50fg]
Jasc Paint Shop Pro...but you could use regular old Paint I think.

 

[kdailey4315]

Would you just resub them or will you crack and resubmit?

 

[EricInCT]

Would you just resub them or will you crack and resubmit?

I cracked them after I scanned the three....along with a .5 away hanson blue ref....need it for my sig lol.