Great Mail Day.. LOOK.. you will like it..

[Guest]

well, i got the autographs in today. to get you up to speed, i got the sheet for $210. the seller did not the CY Young was on there..

i will send the sheet with the Young to get authenticated. PSA/DNA is going to charge $150 for the authentication.

What do you think?

 

[jbone17]

Nice sheet dude. It looks to good to be true to be honest with you, but I hope it works out in your favor!

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

I would have them slab it, and not put a sticker on it.

Regardless, the piece looks dead-on and it's too bad that the Cy Young spans most of the other "big" autographs making it virtually "un-cuttable."

 

[allstars]

Careful you don't overestimate the piece, the condition of the autos & the piece itself is poor. Nice find though.

 

[Guest]

Careful you don't overestimate the piece, the condition of the autos & the piece itself is poor. Nice find though.

what would you sel this piece for?

 

[Pine Tar]

Are some of those signed in pencil???

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

Are some of those signed in pencil???

All but Dizzy appear to be signed in pencil.

 

[Guest]

they are all in pencil except the Dean.. i just cut the sheet....

 

[NYCrulesU]

If you ever do slice and dice it I would be interested in the Paul Waner signature.

 

[Jastermereel]

If the Young wasn't so obstructed it's probably (assuming it's authentic) a $1000 item.

 

[Guest]

i put the sheet with the Cy Young on eBay to get the PSA/DNA Quick Opibion, i just got the result......



LIKELY GENUINE

 

[Guest]

now that i have the QO... would you still slab it, or just sell it with the QO?

 

[Daltonb1219]

very cool

 

[Jeff D]

now that i have the QO... would you still slab it, or just sell it with the QO?

With just the quick opinion I don't see you getting much more then $500-600 for it at best.

In a slab or with a full LOA from JSA or PSA/DNA you're probably looking at $800-1100 on ebay, depending in part on your feedback being reasonable.

JMO

 

[Guest]

yeah, i was thinking about that.. my feedback is a 1

i need to build feedback to get the most.. what do you think is a good feedback amount?

 

[Jeff D]

yeah, i was thinking about that.. my feedback is a 1

i need to build feedback to get the most.. what do you think is a good feedback amount?

I think you may be better off trying to find someone that will sell it for you (possibly for a small cut).
New sellers always scare people, especially grizzled folks that may be interested in an Olde Tyme cut.

You could also try consigning it to an auction house and they can submit it for authentication for you. It may (likely) realize a higher price than ebay, but they'll take a cut as well, and you won't see your money as quickly.