Guys.. need some quick advice...

[Lally1]

I was offered $135 paypal for this lot, grant it, it is from my Casilla PC. But I have been veering away from collecting him for a while, but wouldnt mind keeping his cards. Would you guys sell this lot at the price? Thanks for the help guys.

1. 2007 Exquisite Endorsements Alexi Casilla Auto /50

2. 2007 Exquisite Futures Alexi Casilla Auto /5

3. 2007 Exquisite Rookie Biography Alexi Casilla Auto /5

4. 2007 Exquisite Common Ground Signatures Alexi Casilla, Tony Abreu Auto /25

5. 2007 Exquisite Imagery Alexi Casilla Auto /25

6. 2007 Exquisite Game Dated Debut Alexi Casilla Auto /20

7. 2007 Exquisite First Signs Alexi Casilla Auto /20

8. 2007 Exquisite The Next Generation Alexi Casilla /15

9. 2007 Exquisite Reflections Alexi Casilla, Joaquin Arias Dual Auto /10

10. 2007 Exquisite Reflections Alexi Casilla, Glen Perkins Dual Auto /20

11. 2007 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Alexi Casilla Auto /299

12. 2007 UD Future Stars Rookie Game Dated Debut Alexi Casilla Auto /10

13. 2007 SP Authentic Alexi Casilla BTL Letter "R" Auto /75

14. 2007 SP Authentic Alexi Casilla BTL Letter "S" Auto /50

15. 2007 SP Authentic Alexi Casilla BTL Letter "I" Auto /75

 

[cubfan131]

How much do you have into it? If it's a lot less then what the offer is I'd keep the cards. If you are close to breaking even and you don't want to collect him anymore make the deal.

 

[Lally1]

How much do you have into it? If it's a lot less then what the offer is I'd keep the cards. If you are close to breaking even and you don't want to collect him anymore make the deal.

Probably in the 75 range or so.

 

[rookie380]

I dont think I would, some of the cards are very low numbered, that means you may not ever see them again.

 

[Rickzcards]

If you're making money on it then sell while the getting's good. Go Twins!

 

[uniquebaseballcards]

I see 15 autos there if I'm counting correctly, many of which are low numbered, and there are some other nice cards. I'd suggest only selling if you really needed the cash.

 

[Lally1]

Thanks for the quick advice guys. I decided to hold them

 

[BunchOBull]

Good decision I'd say. Seems like a lot of work in there, despite the low price. I don't know if you can put a dollar amount on that.

 

[jay1065]

I have been veering away from collecting him for a while, but wouldnt mind keeping his cards.

Always a tough call, isn't it? Personally, I would keep them. Seems like a great group of cards.

However, if you do sell, counter-offer the $135 with $150. At least you will come away comfortably in the black. You can always use the profit to pick up a few Casillas if you wish.


EDIT: Good call on keeping them.