Heyward vs Stanton vs Montero

[All The Hype]

Who's your top pick?

 

[bballcardkid]

I'm biased :mrgreen:

 

[Hallsgator]

Heyward!

 

[Brett Keith]

I'll pick Heyward, as he's the best right now, but I still think there's a good chance Stanton turns out to be the best overall, likely not by much though.

 

[shephech]

I'll pick Heyward, as he's the best right now, but I still think there's a good chance Stanton turns out to be the best overall, likely not by much though.

I am with you on that +1.

Shep :ugeek:

 

[soccerman034]

A reasonable top 5
by: soccerman034

1.) Heyward
2.) Stanton
3.) Montero
4.) Smoak
5.) Posey

Fin.

 

[All The Hype]

A reasonable top 5
by: soccerman034

1.) Heyward
2.) Stanton
3.) Montero
4.) Smoak
5.) Posey

Fin.

Smoak was high on another list and I just don't think he belongs in the top 5. If we're talking about all prospects and not just hitters, I think Bumgarner is easily a top 5 prospect and would take Smoak's place.

Smoak is good, but not top 5 good. At least not to me.

 

[scotty21690]

Heyward!

 

[pepsiporch]

Nobody comes close to Heyward right now .

The Poll should be who will have a better career

Justin Upton or Jason Heyward

 

[bballcardkid]

Nobody comes close to Heyward right now .

The Poll should be who will have a better career

Justin Upton or Jason Heyward

Offensively, it is a lot closer than you may think

Heyward's season:

103/314 .328 AVG 16 HR 24 2B 41 BB 44 K .408 OBP .576 SLG .984 OPS

Montero's season:

117/347 .337 AVG 17 HR 25 2B 28 BB 47 K .389 OBP .562 SLG .951 OPS

Also, Montero apparently didn't like playing in Trenton even though the park multipliers cancel out.

Home: 22 games 19/82 .232AVG 2HR .354SLG .630OPS
Away: 22 games 34/85 .400AVG 7HR .718SLG 1.175OPS

 

[brianga26]

biased too..
but Stanton. Man beast.. and I think he will be long term a better (higher end) prospect versus Heyward

 

[jbone17]

My top three goes like this:

1. Heyward: Of course. :lol:

2. Montero: He strikes out a lot less than Stanton and his power has come along.

3. Stanton: He is only three because of his K's. He will be the best out of all of these in two years time, maybe less.

 

[Messier2]

Short term...Heyward and Montero are best bets. But long term, Stanton is going to be a star.