HIGH END TRADE HELP WITH PICS!!!

[Billy Packer]

I like side A

The Koufax is awesome but the Jeter auto looks a little faded and splotchy and the Mays auto is horrible......just my opinion.

use to own the jeter and its fine just the pic just can't decided lol. Its like the only thing new i would be getting is the koufax and ozzie the others would be multi.

Remove all the rest of the others from the trade......it is basically Pujols for Koufax. Like I said previously, the Mays is atrocious and I'm sure you can get an on-card Ozzie and be much happier......Jeter autos are plentiful......and that's a nice Reggie on-card. I think that is the decision to make.......Koufax for Pujols. Koufax has very few autos and that on-card is absolutely amazing! But......what if Pujols has 6 more seasons like the previous 8 he's already had? In the "steroid era" he'll go down as one of the best to ever lace them up. How will you feel in 8-10 years when you think back and say....."Man, that Pujols card I had was sweet.....I should have never traded it....."

That's what I'm talkin' about. IMHO, you'd be giving up two of the three best cards in the deal. There are much better Mays' to be had relatively reasonably and the same can be said for the Jeter. The unliscenced Ozzie does nothing for me whatsoever.

It really comes down to how much you value the Koufax. Even though his autos are relatively scarce, the keyword in today's market is "relatively." A quick check on the bay shows plenty of Koufax autos out there. He doesn't sign as much as other retired guys but he can still be had. I'd hang on to your Pujols. It seems like a much rarer commodity.

 

[shanks25]

I like side A

The Koufax is awesome but the Jeter auto looks a little faded and splotchy and the Mays auto is horrible......just my opinion.

use to own the jeter and its fine just the pic just can't decided lol. Its like the only thing new i would be getting is the koufax and ozzie the others would be multi.

Remove all the rest of the others from the trade......it is basically Pujols for Koufax. Like I said previously, the Mays is atrocious and I'm sure you can get an on-card Ozzie and be much happier......Jeter autos are plentiful......and that's a nice Reggie on-card. I think that is the decision to make.......Koufax for Pujols. Koufax has very few autos and that on-card is absolutely amazing! But......what if Pujols has 6 more seasons like the previous 8 he's already had? In the "steroid era" he'll go down as one of the best to ever lace them up. How will you feel in 8-10 years when you think back and say....."Man, that Pujols card I had was sweet.....I should have never traded it....."

How do you remove card from the equation? We arent talking about garbage cards that are throw ins. You're talking about cards that would sell well and have value. Its funny that you discount the sticker auto's on one side to justify trading for a sticker auto...

Settle down, philly....

I'm not discounting anything. he asked for an opinion and that's what I gave him......my OPINION. It is my OPINION that the Mays is horrible and that he could get a much nicer Ozzie on-card auto....

It is my OPINION that Jeters are a dime a dozen as far as availability goes.....

It is my OPINION that the on-card Jackson is better than stickers on the other side....

It is my OPINION that the Pujols and Koufax are the cream of the crop of this trade and the rest are fluff and fillers....

No more, no less......just my opinion. He doesn't have consider my opinion or even read it.........he asked for an opinion and I gave him one.....

 

[DaleMurphyCollector]

Side B without a second thought. You can EASILY replace a Pujojs auto nowadays, whereas a Koufax is tougher. I know you're "parcial" to the Pujols (what the f*ck does that even mean anyways???), but you can get another Pujols for WAY less than $400.

 

[wideright]

Is this an offer you initiated? Doesn't sound like it, but if it is I think you are better off keeping A and just looking for a nice Koufax auto that you REALLY want. I wouldn't settle and get a few dupes of guys you already have and give up the Pujols. That's a keeper card there.

 

[Dpanthers14]

Thanks guys for your opinions but yes he initiated it. This is the other pujols I would be keeping.