Is $275 too much for a Stanton 2008 Bowman 9.5 -10 Auto

[glewis22]

I asked a dude on ebay what he wanted for his 2008 Bowman Chrome Michael Stanton 9.5 w 10 Auto.......he has it at $325 and I sent in an offer of $125 and it was declined. I asked him how much he wanted to get for it and he replies back $275 - is it just me or is this really high. Perhaps I can barter him down a bit - but did he have another 2 HR game that I missed (besides the one after his injury).

What is fair market price for this card right now? Is the price so high because of the potential? Im at odds here.

 

[All The Hype]

I asked a dude on ebay what he wanted for his 2008 Bowman Chrome Michael Stanton 9.5 w 10 Auto.......he has it at $325 and I sent in an offer of $125 and it was declined. I asked him how much he wanted to get for it and he replies back $275 - is it just me or is this really high. Perhaps I can barter him down a bit - but did he have another 2 HR game that I missed (besides the one after his injury).

What is fair market price for this card right now? Is the price so high because of the potential? Im at odds here.

Perhaps for this particular seller that would be the explanation. That's not how market price works though. With base autos getting about $100, a BGS 9.5 with 10 auto (a relatively rare grade for that card) is worth no more than $175, and probably closer to $140-$160.

$275 is that seller's dream at this point in time, his card is worth nowhere near that much right now.

 

[nosterbor]

I asked a dude on ebay what he wanted for his 2008 Bowman Chrome Michael Stanton 9.5 w 10 Auto.......he has it at $325 and I sent in an offer of $125 and it was declined. I asked him how much he wanted to get for it and he replies back $275 - is it just me or is this really high. Perhaps I can barter him down a bit - but did he have another 2 HR game that I missed (besides the one after his injury).

What is fair market price for this card right now? Is the price so high because of the potential? Im at odds here.

what has Mike Stanton done???? why would anyone pay $325 for that card when you could have this for twice the cost
http://cgi.ebay.com/2001-Topps-Finest-A ... 53e6d2fe25
where is the logic in prospecting???? (besides the one after his injury). PA>>>>LEASE!

 

[jcmint]

Just sold one for 180.00 I believe thats the highest that card has seen in a bit.

 

[shayscards79]

what has Mike Stanton done???? why would anyone pay $325 for that card when you could have this for twice the cost
http://cgi.ebay.com/2001-Topps-Finest-A ... 53e6d2fe25
where is the logic in prospecting???? (besides the one after his injury). PA>>>>LEASE!

Well there's logic and then there is delusion. You would hope no one would pay near that much for that card.

 

[uniquebaseballcards]

where is the logic in prospecting????

To make money and get out ASAP!

 

[ThoseBackPages]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

 

[nosterbor]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

 

[beefycheddar]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

Umm, Eric collects. He said he didn't care about the money he spent on it. Please refrain from bashing people's collecting habits. No one comes on and bashes collectors of Juan Gonzalez, so why should you bash people who buy prospects. I personally work with on a daily basis in the summer a ton of prospects. A bunch probably will never make it, but if I buy their cards for what ever prices I don't care if they make it. It is what I collect.

 

[bballcardkid]

I asked a dude on ebay what he wanted for his 2008 Bowman Chrome Michael Stanton 9.5 w 10 Auto.......he has it at $325 and I sent in an offer of $125 and it was declined. I asked him how much he wanted to get for it and he replies back $275 - is it just me or is this really high. Perhaps I can barter him down a bit - but did he have another 2 HR game that I missed (besides the one after his injury).

What is fair market price for this card right now? Is the price so high because of the potential? Im at odds here.

With base autos getting about $100, a BGS 9.5 with 10 auto (a relatively rare grade for that card) is worth no more than $175, and probably closer to $140-$160.

They won't be at that price for long. Just another classic case of recent completed auctions being misleading. These are just a couple bombs away from an insane price hike.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

so what DO you blow $50 on?

No, i have no plans on selling it, it's in my collection with all the other FineNine RC's that i collect, including your boy Juan Gone, do you happen to have a PSA 9 Reverse Negative available? i have some PayPal i'd like to BLOW

 

[All The Hype]

I asked a dude on ebay what he wanted for his 2008 Bowman Chrome Michael Stanton 9.5 w 10 Auto.......he has it at $325 and I sent in an offer of $125 and it was declined. I asked him how much he wanted to get for it and he replies back $275 - is it just me or is this really high. Perhaps I can barter him down a bit - but did he have another 2 HR game that I missed (besides the one after his injury).

What is fair market price for this card right now? Is the price so high because of the potential? Im at odds here.

With base autos getting about $100, a BGS 9.5 with 10 auto (a relatively rare grade for that card) is worth no more than $175, and probably closer to $140-$160.

They won't be at that price for long. Just another classic case of recent completed auctions being misleading. These are just a couple bombs away from an insane price hike.

You're probably right, I stopped following his BC Autos when they hit triple digits before he was in the Majors. IMO his Topps Chrome Autos are one of the best investments available right now though..I think I have three or four plus a refractor copy, all of which I think could easily double this year if not more.

 

[sheetskout]

($275 is too much for any players auto)

 

[George_Calfas]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

Umm, Eric collects. He said he didn't care about the money he spent on it. Please refrain from bashing people's collecting habits. No one comes on and bashes collectors of Juan Gonzalez, so why should you bash people who buy prospects. I personally work with on a daily basis in the summer a ton of prospects. A bunch probably will never make it, but if I buy their cards for what ever prices I don't care if they make it. It is what I collect.

You are the only MOD that actually MODS EVERYONES POSTS!!!!!!!!!!! LOL. That dude is right!

Trolls need this treatment.....Oh and great sig :benson:

 

[Krom]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

Umm, Eric collects. He said he didn't care about the money he spent on it. Please refrain from bashing people's collecting habits. No one comes on and bashes collectors of Juan Gonzalez, so why should you bash people who buy prospects. I personally work with on a daily basis in the summer a ton of prospects. A bunch probably will never make it, but if I buy their cards for what ever prices I don't care if they make it. It is what I collect.

You are the only MOD that actually MODS EVERYONES POSTS!!!!!!!!!!! LOL. That dude is right!

Trolls need this treatment.....Oh and great sig :benson:

Better watch what you say or he will come find you.

 

[nosterbor]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

so what DO you blow $50 on?

No, i have no plans on selling it, it's in my collection with all the other FineNine RC's that i collect, including your boy Juan Gone, do you happen to have a PSA 9 Reverse Negative available? i have some PayPal i'd like to BLOW

A 9 & 10 not available sorry.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

so what DO you blow $50 on?

No, i have no plans on selling it, it's in my collection with all the other FineNine RC's that i collect, including your boy Juan Gone, do you happen to have a PSA 9 Reverse Negative available? i have some PayPal i'd like to BLOW

A 9 & 10 not available sorry.

Sadly i know, as ive wanted one since i started collecting graded rookie cards back in 2005

 

[nosterbor]

if you want it, buy it. dont worry about the price, unless you are not collecting, but investing

i paid $50 for this:

it was a lot at the time (Winter 2009), but i wanted one, and there you go.

i do not BLOW 50 bucks just to want a card of a nobody. who do you think you are fooling? so are you going to sell it and make a cool $100. or are you going the hold it and loose $45 and look at it again it 10 years and think. WOW that was selling for 150 at one time. comeon man. hey i have some jose canseco rookies i can sell you . don't worry about the price, you do collect don't you?

so what DO you blow $50 on?

No, i have no plans on selling it, it's in my collection with all the other FineNine RC's that i collect, including your boy Juan Gone, do you happen to have a PSA 9 Reverse Negative available? i have some PayPal i'd like to BLOW

A 9 & 10 not available sorry.

Sadly i know, as ive wanted one since i started collecting graded rookie cards back in 2005

if i see one come up i will pm you the link.