KLaw's Top 100 Prospects List For 2012

[superwhat]

Harper does not weight 245 and is not 6 2 the last time I saw him.

Looks like he uses the weight/height they has at the beginning of the season to show you what they did with their numbers.

He has Mason Williams at 6-0 150 and he's at 6-2 175 now.

Where did you see that Mason is 6'2 now, I don't think he was 6'2 when I saw him in Auburn, i'm 5'11 and he was barely taller than me.

Saw it on a couple of places online;

On scout.com and according to this milb doc, he was 6-1 a year ago;
http://www.milb.com/documents/2011/03/2 ... _31-36.pdf

here 6-2
http://www.scoutingbook.com/players/p2863

Could just be a misprint duplicated by many, hence my post original post, but it looks like he was really 6-1 not 6-0 as some people have said.

 

[aarne13]

I was fired up to get this list, even signed up for a month of insider to get it (I also use it for the month leading up to my auction), but seriously, this list is utter garbage and total BS.

Travis dArnaud #6!!!?????!!!!???

Devin Mesaraco #8!!!!!?????!!!!!

Im not even through with the top 10 and Im already livid.

Hak Ju Lee #12...................I refuse to read the rest, this is utter trash.

How can you make such strong conclusions about any prospect list? Just because you don't think d'Arnaud or Mesoraco will have the sixth or eight best career out of the guys on this list doesn't mean it can't happen.

The truth is these guys are not #6 and #8 PERIOD. No other scouts have them anywhere near this high on their lists. Thats 1 of about 10 reasons.

Y U mad Bro?

D'Arnaud and Mesoraco both play premium positions. D'Arnaud had a monster season last year in his first year in AA, not to mention that he was the league MVP. Unless JPA kicks arse this year, D'Arnaud should take over next year.
I expected more Jays on the list but that's fine with me. The list is good. It's hard to argue with most of the picks. I'm not sure if there is much difference between players after #30.