Most overrated and underrated 09 BDP Autos!

[Messier2]

Who ya got?

My two:

Overrated (overpriced): Randal Grichuk

Underrated (underpriced): Chad James

 

[bballcardkid]

Overrated: Jared Mitchell

Underrated: I'm not sure if there is one.

 

[excel_B]

Overrated (overpriced): Bobby Borchering

Underrated (underpriced): Chad James

 

[pigskincardboard]

There just aren't that many autographs...

I think Tim Wheeler and Brett Jackson are the same person with very different prices.

 

[Kardkollector46]

Over: Mitchell
Under: James

 

[moxacaine]

Over: Mitchell
Under: James

 

[justwar]

Tough to call any one overrated when they all sell for less than $20 a base, considering what we've seen the last few years. But ill go...

Overrated: Matzek
Underrated: Mier

 

[bballcardkid]

Tough to call any one overrated when they all sell for less than $20 a base, considering what we've seen the last few years. But ill go...

Overrated: Matzek
Underrated: Mier

I'd say Matzek is the closest to being underrated for me since he's the only guy I've picked up from the set.

 

[trademhigh]

Over: Grichuk
Under: Mier

 

[justwar]

Tough to call any one overrated when they all sell for less than $20 a base, considering what we've seen the last few years. But ill go...

Overrated: Matzek
Underrated: Mier

I'd say Matzek is the closest to being underrated for me since he's the only guy I've picked up from the set.

I just don't like pitching prospect in general, rockies pitchers specifically, and his additude is still a question for me. Give me a less naturally talented, hard working, leader-type any day of the week. That being said Ill still grab a few of his cards.

 

[Jurgy25]

Overrated- Grichuk (but also feel that Matzek is a bit overrated.)
Underrated- Mier or James

 

[andyduke86]

Over: Grichuk
Under: Mier

what he said.

 

[blanning71]

Most overrated:The guys I don't collect that takes the attention away from my stash
Most Underrated: My guys that I think people should spend millions on from me.

 

[Wes]

I fail to see how Matzek is overrated when his stuff is selling for half the price of say Bumgarner who is a comparable prospect given his superior track record but perhaps lesser stuff.

 

[ballerskrip]

overrated - Mier
underrated - Zack Wheeler

 

[sheetskout]

I fail to see how Matzek is overrated when his stuff is selling for half the price of say Bumgarner who is a comparable prospect given his superior track record but perhaps lesser stuff.

I have to say that I agree. And I have not invested in Matzek at all but I think he's a tremendous prospect.

 

[darocker80]

Overrated- Grichuk (but also feel that Matzek is a bit overrated.)
Underrated- Mier or James

Agreed.

I was going to say Leake but his prices have hit a small spike since the last time i checked the prices.

I would say Zack wheeler, but his X and Blues sell for decent money.