Panini Replacements for Tom Brady 1/1 Patch Auto. What do you think?

[Boylen33]

My friend and I had the Patriots in a break of 2011 Panini Absolute. We pulled a redemption for a Tom Brady 1/1 Patch Auto. After waiting for over a year and several attempts to get a decent replacement, we contacted Panini one more time to inquire about a replacement. They offered these and we accepted. What do you think? Was it a good deal? The triple is not #ed. The Durant is /5. The Griffin is /99. The luck is /349.

 

[longbomberz]

I'd have rather had the Brady as I'm sure you would have as well, but those are some quality replacements in my opinion.

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

What do you value the Brady at? IE: Was it just a patch, or Reebok patch, etc.

You basically were given 4 cards that total $725 or so in combined value. So if you're valuing the Brady at $500, it seems like a fair trade at roughly 150% of value for a multi-card deal.

 

[Boylen33]

What do you value the Brady at? IE: Was it just a patch, or Reebok patch, etc.

You basically were given 4 cards that total $725 or so in combined value. So if you're valuing the Brady at $500, it seems like a fair trade at roughly 150% of value for a multi-card deal.

Don't know what patch the Brady would have been. But I would have valued it at around $500-$600, compared to similar Brady 1/1's. We are happy with the replacements, but probably would have rather had the Brady.

 

[SouthSideSluggers]

I think you made out quite well...especially with the players and the cards...you only have a few years left of Brady playing but at least 10 years each of Luck and RGIII.

 

[goldenegg1]

Nice replacements

 

[CollectorsCorner]

Personally I would have wanted the Brady, but you probably came out a little better money wise if you sold right now.

 

[lisu]

Definitely a fair replacement. Nice cards!

 

[hive17]

4 cards is easier to split between friends, rather than just merc'ing the Brady on eBay and taking the money.

 

[James52411]

Panini did right by you.

 

[notjomommasclint]

I don't like basketball but I think you did well.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

well done imo

 

[Bruin7]

I'd be happy; I think the replacements were extremely fair.

Allen

 

[Slette]

I'll agree with everyone else - the Brady 1/1 would have been really nice, but as far as replacements go, Panini definitely took care of you.

 

[eyedinh]

That's pretty above and beyond as a replacement IMO. Well done!

 

[gt2590]

I agree with all those who think you did well...

 

[jtrinaldi]

Whats the current SV on each of your replacements?

 

[bcubs]

Good job by Panini on these replacements. You did well.

 

[mikekarlovec]

Looks like you did good.

 

[jhand13]

I think those replacements are great!