Product of the Year...09 Magic Football?

[schmidtfan20]

If this product had on card autos would it be product of the year so far? Is it still product of the year
with its amazing autograph checklist? Does the college football angle turn you off?

Kevin

 

[cwells46]

I like magic, but the pure amount of complete crap for autos kills it for product of the year.....Great concept tho especially with the SP's

 

[deceptikon1978]

I like magic, but the pure amount of complete crap for autos kills it for product of the year.....Great concept tho especially with the SP's

Agreed. We broke a case here and it was horrendous.

Love the college theme and design but not for product of the year.

 

[Daltonb1219]

I really want a couple autos out of this set i really like the college team an the other type of card i really want a few cards

 

[tenclubber]

When I first heard about this product, I was REALLY excited. But after seeing some breaks I decided not to buy any. I am just picking up the Purdue guys that I can get my hands on. This is a great concept as I really like the college throwbacks. It just sucks that all of the Purdue guys autos are SPs! :lol:

 

[matchpenalty]

Has Magic boxes held their prices since it came out. I like Philadelphia better than Magic.

 

[Daltonb1219]

Has Magic boxes held their prices since it came out. I like Philadelphia better than Magic.

philadelphias gu cards are horrendous an they are from 08 ::facepalm::

 

[matchpenalty]

Has Magic boxes held their prices since it came out. I like Philadelphia better than Magic.

philadelphias gu cards are horrendous an they are from 08 ::facepalm::

all game used cards are horrendous

 

[FearTheFork]

I really like the product since I collect college. I wouldn't buy a box though, it is more of a buy the singles type of product.

 

[Gellman]

Magic was junk. I hated the college, hated the design, hated everything about it.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

Magic was junk. I hated the college, hated the design, hated everything about it.

+1 Did not like it in the least! :?

 

[schmidtfan20]

yeah there were some bad autos, but isn't that the way it always is? You have to believe that products
that cost a few bucks a pack and have high end autos of HOF'ers are a rare occurance these days. Don't products
like Elite, R&S and Chrome have just as many scrubs wether it be 2nd and 3rd year nobodies like magic had
or "free agent" rookie autos like some of the other products had. Is there, or will there be a product out this
year with a better list of graphs at the top of the list than magic had? Certainly not at this price point.

Kevin

 

[tribefan2427]

Don't like magic. to much junk. plus are the yamon figurs are sp. why of all players do you sp yamon figurs.

 

[predatorkj]

Has Magic boxes held their prices since it came out. I like Philadelphia better than Magic.

Eh...Philadelphia is way too bland.I am trying to complete the base set and I am having a hard time even justifying doing that.

 

[gt2590]

I really like the product since I collect college. I wouldn't buy a box though, it is more of a buy the singles type of product.

+1.

 

[schmidtfan20]

I guess the real question is:

Is Kenny Irons auto really worth a few hundred dollars?

 

[Slette]

I liked the idea, although on-card autos would have been better. Busted a box, and pulled Chris Simms and Sebastian Janikowski as two of my autos, which infuriated me. That being said, I was pleasantly surprised to find out they were both SPed, and sold them for a decent price. I think it was a fun way to try something different, and liked the college inclusion - any time I can get a Hawkeye uni in a set, I'll take it.

The Chad Greenway auto was SPed/100 copies, which kinda blew my mind, and a lot of the autos were junk. However, I saw a few nice cards pulled from there too - that Michigan alum triple auto being one of the nicest.

Product of the year? I'll probably reserve that for Topps Chrome so far, but I liked it a lot more than most people seemed to.