Psa 9 vs BGS 9. BGS more valuable? (Would u pay more)

[darocker80]

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... K:MEDWX:IT

psa 9 blue sold for 425.

EricinCT has a bgs 9 and i also (.5 from gem)

you think bgs would sell more and how much you think estimate (sv)?

 

[Lancemountain]

I would assume the bgs will sell for more.

Only way to tell is to list that puppy

 

[Jurgy25]

BGS hands down.

Has been said that PSA 10=BGS 9.5

 

[darocker80]

I have listed my puppy. haha gotten offers around the same as psa 9 ending price.

ericinct got 575 or 525 for his. not selling mine unless i get blown out of the water

 

[Lancemountain]

how many blues do you have?

 

[darocker80]

how many blues do you have?

1 :/

 

[Superfractor]

BGS 9, but I would prefer the PSA 9. Much more aesthetically pleasing than the BGS 9 silver foil.


If it was BGS 9.5+, I would go for that over any PSA holder (e.g.: 10).

 

[darocker80]

BGS 9, but I would prefer the PSA 9. Much more aesthetically pleasing than the BGS 9 silver foil.


If it was BGS 9.5+, I would go for that over any PSA holder (e.g.: 10).

you really like the psa holder more than the bgs?!?!

 

[Superfractor]

BGS 9, but I would prefer the PSA 9. Much more aesthetically pleasing than the BGS 9 silver foil.


If it was BGS 9.5+, I would go for that over any PSA holder (e.g.: 10).

you really like the psa holder more than the bgs?!?!

Only if the card grades BGS 9, or lower.

 

[Zithy]

I've had a few BGS 9's that cracked and turned into PSA 10s, one of which I specifically remember being all four 9 subgrades, so it wasn't as if it were .5 from gem. I highly doubt I'd have the same percent going from PSA 9s to BGS 9.5s.

 

[RiceLynnEvans75]

BGS hands down.

Has been said that PSA 10=BGS 9.5

Well, that would make sense since a PSA 10 and a BGS 9.5 are both the grade of GEM MINT.