PSA/DNA order in hand- let's play "what did they authenticate" and what was "Questionable?"

[MaineMule]

PSA/DNA order in hand- let's play "what did they authenticate" and what was "Questionable?"

Let's see what you think- which of these 7 seven, if any, were slabbed "Authentic" and which, if any were deemed "Questionable?"

Roy Campanella

Derek Jeter

Roger Maris

Walter O'Malley

Mike Piazza

Hilton Smith

Willie Wells

 

[AMAZIN HOF COLLECTOR]

Piazza & Jeter questionable?

 

[George_Calfas]

Campy and Piazza???

 

[MojoDan]

Campy and Piazza???

That's my guess

 

[TBTwinsFan]

Jeter and Campy

 

[MaineMule]

I'll let this float a little longer.

I must say PSA did a nice job on the turnaround for these.

 

[scotty216brs]

Campanella?

 

[gmarutiak]

I like this game!!! The only sigs I'm familiar with are Jeter, Piazza and Maris, and they all look good to my untrained eye. Not to be rude, but how the heck can anyone authenticate a post-accident Campanella?

 

[shepsspot]

All of them questionable.

 

[MaineMule]

All of them questionable.

...hmmmm cynical about authentication??

I like this game!!! The only sigs I'm familiar with are Jeter, Piazza and Maris, and they all look good to my untrained eye. Not to be rude, but how the heck can anyone authenticate a post-accident Campanella?

Glad you liked this ....I'll let this go overnight as I'd love to see other comments.........

 

[homerun28aa]

Jeter is legit looks smooth IMO, I'd guess Piazza is questionable...and I guess campy looks like a real easy fake well post accident

 

[csmtampa]

Questionable:

Campanella
Jeter
Maris

 

[Krom]

Maris

 

[JackLondon]

I'll say Maris and maybe Jeter are questionable.

 

[Pine Tar]

I say.......which ever ones you received back slabbed and which everone you didn't get back slabbed : lol:

But really campy is the one not slabbed

 

[Sjrmn91]

Piazza and Jeter

 

[MaineMule]

You all were basically on target- the Campy, Jeter and Piazza all came back "Questionable." I really think the Jeter looks to be the best of the 3. I asked PSA to re-look at them but they had sent out the order on the day the order "popped." I already have refunds from sellers lined up for Jeter and Piazza and I am awaiting correspondence for the Campy. That seller had "guaranteed" authenticity but it was 6 months or so ago so who knows if I will hear back.

Thanks for "playing" and your comments.

....and btw the Maris was the steal of the bunch- paid $50 plus $7 for PSA quick opinion then $12 for authentication. $69 slabbed!!!

 

[A_Pharis]

The price on that Maris.... unreal. Congrats.

 

[Mighty Bombjack]

Some great ***** Leaguers there, Scott. what does this put your HOF number at?

 

[MaineMule]

Some great ***** Leaguers there, Scott. what does this put your HOF number at?

...at 203 total....getting much harder to find pick-ups that do not break the bank, as I know you know