Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Red Sox, and Jason Bay break off talks

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

baseballguy350

New member
Joined
Dec 7, 2008
Messages
2,835
Reaction score
0
Location
Boston, MA / Longboat Key, FL
Didn't see this posted, and found it interesting.

I'm encouraged as a Sox fan that they are trying to get this done. It is not encouraging that they would even let him get a sniff of free agency though, as everyone knows regardless of what the Sox offer, the Yankees WILL offer $15 million more (although at least he isn't a Bora$$ agent). The longer this goes, the higher the probability (obviously) that Bay signs elsewhere. Maybe the Sox can sit down next to the World Series trophy from '09 that they are going to win :D and make the deal before the FA period starts.





TORONTO -- The Red Sox and All-Star left fielder Jason Bay failed to come to terms on a contract extension after the Red Sox made an "aggressive" offer about one week ago, general manager Theo Epstein said. The halting of negotiations means the Sox and Bay have probably ended any contract negotiations until after the season, when he is eligible to become a free agent.

"It's now clear that this round of talks won't result in a deal, either," Epstein said this afternoon. "As a result, we're going to table discussions again, which once again is a mutual decision, and pick them up most likely after the season."

Bay, whom the Red Sox traded for at last year's non-waiver deadline, is in the final year of a contract extension he signed with the Pittsburgh Pirates in November 2005. The Red Sox had negotiated with Bay during spring training, but the talks broke down when the sides could not agree on a fair-market value for outfielders.

But just because talks broke down for the second time this season doesn't mean Bay is eager to test free agency. Bay said that he'd still like to remain with the team, but didn't want the contract situation to become a distraction to anyone around the club.

"I'm not trying to set a precedent," Bay said. "Just looking for something that's fair. Whether that's changed over the last three months, you guys can determine that.

"It's the same situation we were in in spring training, where they were at a place where they were comfortable and we were at a place where we're comfortable and we didn't bridge the gap. That being said, doesn't really mean it's the end of the world, either. Just didn't really want it to become a distraction, not so much to myself but to the entire team. So we decided to kind of table that until later, which probably will be til the end of the season."

Bay and his agent, Joe Urbon, rejected the final contract offer made by the Sox about a week ago, and the talks finished up yesterday. Epstein said discussions had restarted in mid-June. He characterized them as amicable, and he believed the Sox had a chance to finalize a new extension before the All-Star break.

"I think we were really hopeful with the aggressive offer that we made that we could have reached a deal now," Epstein said. "But we have complete respect for Jason as a player and a person and for what free agency means to players. He's worked his whole career and had a really consistent career to get to a point where he can set his family up for life. We're not going to begrudge him. We're not going to hold anything against him because he makes a decision that he may want to wait and be able to consider every possible opportunity."

Asked if he was encouraged by how the talks went this time, Bay said, "Yeah. ... They have come a long way and, like I said, it's not really the end-all, be-all. Definitely more encouraged with the way things went this time, a lot more, actually, that hopefully we get something done."

Bay said the Sox had made "great strides and I appreciate it."

The sides can sit down again at the end of the season, after the World Series, before Bay would have to file for free agency. He's just looking for "something that makes sense for me," he said.

"I am in no position to say that I want to file for free agency and see what's out there," he said. "I'd still love to get something done here. I like it here. But that being said, we just basically at this point right now don't want it to be an ongoing distraction, like i said, for both of us coming to the field and answering contract questions.

"So we're kind of tabling it and there's a big window at the end of the year after the season. We can sit down and try to hammer something out again. But the way things have gone so far, like I said, very encouraged with that."

Epstein offered similar sentiments.

"I think he sat down with us in good faith. We approached him in good faith. And it just didn't work out at this point. We'll see what the future brings. We still want to retain him. I think he still wants to be here. It's just not going to happen now."
 

Jays_Cards

Active member
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
0
I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.
 

KC37

New member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
4,663
Reaction score
0
Location
Massachusetts
I'm not too put off by this. It was the All-Star break, they took a stab at it, and now that games are back on, they stop talking. Every report up here says it's amicable, but they don't want to distract themselves (either side) at this point in the year. I still think something gets done.
 

pghbuccos

New member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
20,965
Reaction score
0
Location
PixBurgh
both sides agreed to wait until after the season is over and Bay has said he wants to remain with Red Sox. they will have a deal signed before he even has a chance to become a free agent. I agree with Jays_Cards he certainly isn't worth $14-15 million but I would definitely say $10-12 million is fair.
 

Jays_Cards

Active member
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
0
pghbuccos said:
both sides agreed to wait until after the season is over and Bay has said he wants to remain with Red Sox. they will have a deal signed before he even has a chance to become a free agent. I agree with Jays_Cards he certainly isn't worth $14-15 million but I would definitely say $10-12 million is fair.

If I could lock him up for 3/$36M or 4/$45M, I would be all over it. Unfortunately, if he hits F/A, the Yankees ill probably throw 4/$60M out there because they are so ridiculous.
 

mr148927

Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2008
Messages
340
Reaction score
0
Location
boston
Jays_Cards said:
I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......
 

Jays_Cards

Active member
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
0
mr148927 said:
Jays_Cards said:
I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.
 

pghbuccos

New member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
20,965
Reaction score
0
Location
PixBurgh
both Bay and Theo have said the contract will not be outrageous due to the current economy.
 

ROLLTIDE4LIFE

New member
Joined
Sep 10, 2008
Messages
1,345
Reaction score
0
Jays_Cards said:
mr148927 said:
[quote="Jays_Cards":5a2z1uwm]I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......
[/quote:5a2z1uwm]

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.[/quote]

Actually one could easily argue that he is the worst of those 4 players pretty easily and convincingly
 

ballerskrip

New member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
11,531
Reaction score
0
Location
Chicago Area
ROLLTIDE4LIFE said:
Jays_Cards said:
mr148927 said:
[quote="Jays_Cards":11aunbmy]I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.[/quote]

Actually one could easily argue that he is the worst of those 4 players pretty easily and convincingly[/quote:11aunbmy]

Bobby Abreu is hands down the worst of the four..... Bay could be anywhere from 1-3 depending on the day!
 

Jays_Cards

Active member
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
0
ROLLTIDE4LIFE said:
Jays_Cards said:
mr148927 said:
[quote="Jays_Cards":mz84tn7d]I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.[/quote]

Actually one could easily argue that he is the worst of those 4 players pretty easily and convincingly[/quote:mz84tn7d]

You could make that argument, but you would not be right.
 

mr148927

Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2008
Messages
340
Reaction score
0
Location
boston
Jays_Cards said:
mr148927 said:
[quote="Jays_Cards":2d9p04x5]I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.[/quote:2d9p04x5]

I realize that the market was different then. However are you trying to tell me that Drew is worth the contract he signed? He surely is not, not even close.
 

Jays_Cards

Active member
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
0
mr148927 said:
Jays_Cards said:
mr148927 said:
[quote="Jays_Cards":11rmji2i]I am all for signing Bay, but the way he has hit lately, he is not worth $14-$15M per year if Adam Dunn is only making $10M per. He is in the .250s now with very little power as of late.

Bay has never negotiated in the middle of a season, that being said he wants to stay here. However he is worth more than 10-12M per year. I mean Bay wants a deal like JD Drew's 5/70M . Drew ( china doll)was, and is not worth that kind of money , but I think Bay is. Just my opine. I think Bay will end up with a 4/50-60M from the Sox. that puts him in the 13-15M annual average. Or worse case scenario 3/40-45M He is worth it I think. The Sox have the cash... sign him......

You cant compare him to Drew's deal simply because the economy was significantly different when Drew's deal was signed. Last offseason, the best corner outfielders (Ibanez, Dunn, Abreu) got between $8M-$10M per. Is Bay better than all of these players? Yes. Is he worth twice as much as these players? No he is not.

I realize that the market was different then. However are you trying to tell me that Drew is worth the contract he signed? He surely is not, not even close.[/quote:11rmji2i]

No he is not, but one bad contract does not justify another...
 

baseballguy350

New member
Joined
Dec 7, 2008
Messages
2,835
Reaction score
0
Location
Boston, MA / Longboat Key, FL
mr148927 said:
I realize that the market was different then. However are you trying to tell me that Drew is worth the contract he signed? He surely is not, not even close.

Actually, this is one thing that pisses me off about Red Sox Nation.... All the hate on JD Drew.
He has been paid $35 million. According to fangraphs.com, which many of you know as a respected statistical analysis site, he has been worth $33.3 million over this period in time. For a year by year breakdown, that is: 07 - Worth 5.5 mil, paid 14 mil. 08 - worth 18.6 mil, paid 14 mil. 09- worth 8.7 mil, paid 6 mil.

He is worth $32.8 million, while getting paid $34 million.

Take out the first half of 07, for an adjustment period to a new team and a new league, and I think many of you would eat your words as to how effective Drew has been.
 

Members online

Latest posts

Top