Replacement from Panini... yeesh.

[flightposite]

So I got sick of waiting for my Mendenhall National Treasures Auto Patch RC/99 and told them to replace it and got an email this morning, i'll be receiving...

Replaced:
08/12/2009 2:23 PM
by: Panini 2008 Playoff National Treasures
Champions Signature Prime Materials Card #7 (15 / 25) Danny White
Dallas Cowboys
QB

Makes me even more scared for my Matt Ryan Auto Patch from UD.

 

[Ryo1549]

that blows =(

 

[mikekarlovec]

that sucks man. i am sorry to hear about that

 

[Card Magnet]

WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE!?!?

That sounds like a FANTASTIC replacement! (Can you tell I'm a Cowboys fan and Steelers hater? :lol: )

I am sorry it wasn't a replacement you like.

 

[Weimer]

What the...

 

[ross9013]

Great slap in the face. ::facepalm::

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

It's Danny White.... come on.

 

[mstng99tim]

I'm not targeting you specifically, because I've always felt this way, but why don't people just wait for their redemptions? I know it's nice to get mail days, but more often than not you are going to get screwed over.

 

[bodiaz]

That is horrible! I would have kept the Mendenhall for sure!

 

[flightposite]

The reason I took the replacement was because I am getting rid of most of my collection and just wanted to cash it out, plus, it's already been months upon months.

What do you guys think, should I put up a fight with Panini and send it back? Or just take the hit and move it?

 

[Brad]

Send it back. A Member on another site I am on was sent a Bennie Wells Prestige auto /100 for his Early Doucet NT patch/auto /10. He sent it back and ended up getting a Larry Fitzgerald 2 clr jersey / auto /25.

 

[mstng99tim]

I would send it back if I were you.

 

[gt2590]

Danny White was my favorite player growing up. (Heck, the guy PUNTED too, for God's sake) Even I think that replacement sucks.

 

[masonphillip]

I would send it back if I were you.

Same here, that ain't even close.

Makes me all that much more appreciative of my recent replacement from Razor (Bryce Brown GU Patch).

 

[Card Magnet]

Return.

 

[vetsgt02]

So I got sick of waiting for my Mendenhall National Treasures Auto Patch RC/99 and told them to replace it and got an email this morning, i'll be receiving...

Replaced:
08/12/2009 2:23 PM
by: Panini 2008 Playoff National Treasures
Champions Signature Prime Materials Card #7 (15 / 25) Danny White
Dallas Cowboys
QB

Makes me even more scared for my Matt Ryan Auto Patch from UD.

They did the same crap to me so I called them and told them I did nto want the dang card and I wanted a replacement that had some thought put into it. After about 3-4 days of talking with them they sent me a Playoffs GU/Auto/25 of Larry Fitz. I am sure they will fix this for you if you let them know that you are VERY unhappy

 

[vetsgt02]

Send it back. A Member on another site I am on was sent a Bennie Wells Prestige auto /100 for his Early Doucet NT patch/auto /10. He sent it back and ended up getting a Larry Fitzgerald 2 clr jersey / auto /25.

Yep that was me

 

[SOONERCOWBOY]

They couldn't find a Ken Stabler card to send you. :lol:

 

[schmidtfan20]

you all need to get more. Have you seen what UD and Topps are giving out as replacments? Topps will give you
a 5 dollar auto for a hot rookie 40 dollar RC auto. UD will give you 5 20 dollar GU cards for a 120 dollar autograph.

Mendenhall hasn't done squat yet and could be very well be the best of the century. White was a winner with
perhaps the most collected team in the NFL. You should have no shame on this replacment even though the
Mendy is probably selling for big money as Pitt fans are thinking he is going to be the next Franco Harris.

Visit this thread again in December and see how is right!

Kevin

 

[flightposite]

you all need to get more. Have you seen what UD and Topps are giving out as replacments? Topps will give you
a 5 dollar auto for a hot rookie 40 dollar RC auto. UD will give you 5 20 dollar GU cards for a 120 dollar autograph.

Mendenhall hasn't done squat yet and could be very well be the best of the century. White was a winner with
perhaps the most collected team in the NFL. You should have no shame on this replacment even though the
Mendy is probably selling for big money as Pitt fans are thinking he is going to be the next Franco Harris.

Visit this thread again in December and see how is right!

Kevin

I have bookmarked it and will send you a PM to make sure you don't forget.

A great RC of a guy who may be very good for a very good team for a generic, issued every year, game used auto. Yep, you sure showed us all how little we know about football!