Seth Smith for ROY

[angelsrockies4ever]

Wow! He is amazing...

Just hit another homer.
9 for 17 with 3 homers in last five games.

I would still give it to Hanson, but I feel as if he is the best rookie hitter.

.317 14 homers .968 OPS.

Although I am biased, he has played so well this year.

 

[Mighty Bombjack]

No chance at ROY, but he is smoking the ball right now and has been clutch all season long.

 

[Sly]

No dice, he's not eligible.

While one of the qualifications is 130 At-Bats, another is no more than 45 days on an MLB roster (not counting September).

He'd had been on the roster for 57 games prior to September last year, which obviously is more than 45 days.