- Thread starter
- #1
pigskincardboard
New member
I don't really self-promote, other than the link in my signature, but I love me some vintage football cards. I'd like for anyone to chime in on these lists.
The first caveat is, I massively underrated players that're still playing (tomlinson and favre, excluded). I know very, very little about the high-end cards of the 90's -- so if you have a suggestion, I'm all ears.
http://www.pigskincardboard.com/top...ition/best-football-rookie-cards-of-all-time/
1. '58 Jim Brown
2. 76 Payton
3. 89 Sanders
4. Tomlinson
5. 90 Emmitt Smith
6. Earl Campbell 79 topps
7. 84 Eric Dickerson
8. '70 OJ Simpson
9. 94 Marshall Faulk
10. 66 Gale Sayers
11. 50 Marion Motley
12. 48 Steve Van Buren
13a. 59 Jim Taylor
13b. 57 Paul Hornung
14. 72 John Riggins
15. 83 Marcus Allen
16. 98 Priest Holmes
17. 89 Thurman Thomas
18. 95 Curtis Martin
19. 56 Lenny Moore
20. 07 Adrian Peterson
http://www.pigskincardboard.com/top...op-20-quarterback-football-cards-of-all-time/
1. 57 Unitas
2. 81 Montana
3. 50 Graham
4. 62 Tarkenton
5. 65 Namath
6. 57 Starr
7. 71 Bradshaw
8. 84 Marino
9. 72 Staubach
10. 48 Baugh
11. 63 Dawson
12. 75 Fouts
13. 84 Elway
14. 51 Van Brocklin
15. 48 Sid Luckman
16. 91 Brett Favre
17. 50 YA Tittle
18. 00 Brady
19. 73 Ken Anderson
20. 58 Sonny Jurgensen
21. 85 Warren Moon
Yes... I didn't feel bad cutting Manning, it was either him or Brady, but I had to get in Anderson, Jurgensen and Moon. When all is said and done, Manning and Brady are probably 1 and 2 ahead of Unitas.
We're very lucky, very very lucky.
The first caveat is, I massively underrated players that're still playing (tomlinson and favre, excluded). I know very, very little about the high-end cards of the 90's -- so if you have a suggestion, I'm all ears.
http://www.pigskincardboard.com/top...ition/best-football-rookie-cards-of-all-time/
1. '58 Jim Brown
2. 76 Payton
3. 89 Sanders
4. Tomlinson
5. 90 Emmitt Smith
6. Earl Campbell 79 topps
7. 84 Eric Dickerson
8. '70 OJ Simpson
9. 94 Marshall Faulk
10. 66 Gale Sayers
11. 50 Marion Motley
12. 48 Steve Van Buren
13a. 59 Jim Taylor
13b. 57 Paul Hornung
14. 72 John Riggins
15. 83 Marcus Allen
16. 98 Priest Holmes
17. 89 Thurman Thomas
18. 95 Curtis Martin
19. 56 Lenny Moore
20. 07 Adrian Peterson
http://www.pigskincardboard.com/top...op-20-quarterback-football-cards-of-all-time/
1. 57 Unitas
2. 81 Montana
3. 50 Graham
4. 62 Tarkenton
5. 65 Namath
6. 57 Starr
7. 71 Bradshaw
8. 84 Marino
9. 72 Staubach
10. 48 Baugh
11. 63 Dawson
12. 75 Fouts
13. 84 Elway
14. 51 Van Brocklin
15. 48 Sid Luckman
16. 91 Brett Favre
17. 50 YA Tittle
18. 00 Brady
19. 73 Ken Anderson
20. 58 Sonny Jurgensen
21. 85 Warren Moon
Yes... I didn't feel bad cutting Manning, it was either him or Brady, but I had to get in Anderson, Jurgensen and Moon. When all is said and done, Manning and Brady are probably 1 and 2 ahead of Unitas.
We're very lucky, very very lucky.
