Topps Redemption. Is this a fair trade?

[braves1047]

I had a redemption for a 2008 cosingers Garrett Olsen Brian Burres Autograph. Topps finally sent me a replacement. It is an uncirulated Adam Lind autograph. I have no idea what set it is out of. It just has a 2009 copyright date. I think Adam Lind is a good player but I liked the co-signers autographs just for the fact you get 2 autos on 1 card. Does this seem like a fair exchange or did they short me?
Here is an example of the card. I am not selling mine.

http://cgi.ebay.com/2009-Topps-Adam-Lin ... 1e5a72cc45

 

[ballcardzdotcom]

I had a redemption for a 2008 cosingers Garrett Olsen Brian Burres Autograph. Topps finally sent me a replacement. It is an uncirulated Adam Lind autograph. I have no idea what set it is out of. It just has a 2009 copyright date. I think Adam Lind is a good player but I liked the co-signers autographs just for the fact you get 2 autos on 1 card. Does this seem like a fair exchange or did they short me?
Here is an example of the card. I am not selling mine.

http://cgi.ebay.com/2009-Topps-Adam-Lin ... 1e5a72cc45

I think I'd at least ask for another dual autograph. While I do agree that Lind is a good player, he doesn't yet have the following that other superstars do. Maybe if you push you can get a dual with Adam Lind on it. However, I have found that Topps doesn't give a damn about what you want, only that you get something. Good luck!

Matt

 

[Pine Tar]

Here is mine I had a Allen & Ginter BB Alex Rios Framed Auto Redemption in for I think only Dec 2009
and I go this in the mail today they sent me this Clay Buchholz Auto

 

[goldenegg1]

I got the same crap Lind card for the same dual auto. They say they are of comparable value, but there is no value on a card they produce for replacements. Topps cs is by far the worst out there!

 

[Pinbreaker]

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

 

[Exposfan]

Pinbreaker- I redeemed 5 of that Triple Threads Ryan Braun, all five I received back were white "Patches". Congrats

 

[pigskincardboard]

If that said "Hebrew Hammer" it'd sell for crazy money.

 

[colts1888]

i too got the lind for the burris dual personally im pretty happy considering what a crap dual the burris olsen is and the fact that the lind is an uncirculated auto i think would sell for more down the line

 

[braves1047]

Thanks for every ones input. I know Topps cs is bad but i will call and see if I maybe able to get a duel with lind. I still think a duel auto should be replaced with a duel auto. Thats just my two cents. I am not hoping for much from Topps maybe I will get lucky

 

[MacK]

I'm not sure if a Burres/Olson would sell for .99.

The Lind surely would.

 

[rymflaherty]

Where are those uncirculated auto's even from?
Just curious cause I don;t remember any designs like that.

 

[moxacaine]

Where are those uncirculated auto's even from?
Just curious cause I don;t remember any designs like that.

pretty sure they used surplus stickers and made cards to use specifically as replacements.

 

[Kozma Collector]

I received an encapsulated Robinson Cano Auto as a replacement for Brendan Ryan & Chris Duncan Dual Auto Today. Same type of card as the Lind.

 

[MacK]

I received an encapsulated Robinson Cano Auto as a replacement for Brendan Ryan & Chris Duncan Dual Auto Today. Same type of card as the Lind.

I had that card too.

I got a Markakis/Roberts Dual Autograph from 07 Co-Signers.

 

[ajbraves25]

There are Lou Pineilla encased autos out there like the Lind. Like what was said before, Topps just made some cards to make up for not sending the cards out.

~AJ

 

[cgilmo]

Lind is worth both of those players combined

 

[TomMurry]

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

sweet XM patch there

 

[Rudzud]

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

Is that an XM radio patch?!?!

 

[Pinbreaker]

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

Is that an XM radio patch?!?!

Yes it is..