What ONE CARD would you trade your entire current collection for?

[mudflap02]

I was thinking about this today. It would be kind of neat to consolidate everything into one card.

The rules are simple. It has to be a card. And it can only be one. And you can't keep anything - everything you currently own goes out the door.

I would probably trade my Heritage sets for a nice high grade '52 Mantle. The value would probably be similar and it would be a whole lot easier to keep around.

 

[WNP22]

Do they have to be of similar value?

 

[VandyDan]

I could like, buy more in the future, right?

Probably the Price Super Auto. It was on the bay for a very high BIN, don't know if it sold or not. I think my whole collection is worth about that anyway, but still. Even then I don't know. I kinda like my PC, even if it is deficient in super high end.

 

[Lancemountain]

206 Wagner.

 

[uniquebaseballcards]

No way!

Good question BTW LOL.

 

[MisterT]

None. Its not about value to me. I like the variety, the history, the memory of where I got the card, etc. There are lots of "one" cards I would want...the high grade 52 Mantle, the Wagner, etc. etc. But no one card is worth my collection to ME. Dollar wise on eBay, sure. But not to me.

 

[SydBarrett]

33 Goudey Gehrig PSA 4+

 

[gracecollector]

1887 Old Judge Cap Anson in uniform. Would be nice to clear up the space!

 

[TBTwinsFan]

I'd trade every card I have (minus my perkins and vintage collections) for a Perkins superfractor.

 

[apbtpat]

206 Wagner!

 

[VizquelCollector.com]

Oooooh, good question!

It'd have to be something I could sell immediately. I wouldn't care to begin a new card collection, so essentially it'd be the amount enticing enough to abandon my collection and collecting cards altogether. Would want to recoup the approx $ I've spent plus "sell" my time investment... and I'm also creating a lifestyle change. It'd take me a while to come up with a number but it's definitely north of $25K.

 

[James52411]

I'd trade every card I have (minus my perkins and vintage collections) for a Perkins superfractor.

You haven't traded your entire collection.

 

[Slette]

2006 Elite Chad Greenway Black Status auto 1/1

The values don't come close to matching up, but I'd do it without thinking twice

 

[Tyler McEver]

I don't have a completed set but I would trade my cards in my collection for a Cam Newton 1/1 superfractor auto or a 6 way of HOFer's.

 

[TBTwinsFan]

You haven't traded your entire collection.

Yeah, true.

 

[Calripkenjrcollector]

No way!

Good question BTW LOL.

+1
You guys can have all the Wagner's, Ruth's and Mantle's. All the time, effort and memories I have in my collection is worth more than anything.

 

[roundtree34]

a high grade t206 cobb or a psa 10 nolan ryan

 

[notjomommasclint]

Bgs 9.5 x4 Michael Jordan 86-87 fleer. I'd even deliver.


I'm old Greg

 

[hofvintagecollector]

I'd trade my entire prospect collection for a the 2010 Chrome Matt Harvey superfractor autograph

 

[magicpapa]

+1
You guys can have all the Wagner's, Ruth's and Mantle's. All the time, effort and memories I have in my collection is worth more than anything.