Which Catcher Will put up the best numbers this season?

[hofautos]

WHo do you think??

 

[Pastretta]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

What a MOB scene

 

[hofautos]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

 

[GiantsSuperCollector]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

Man, you are the most negative person on these forums...It will be between Posey or Mauer.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

best numbers HOW?

as a CATCHER

or as a HITTER?

 

[ThoseBackPages]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

But, he has one thing that the other two will never have, unless they change teams

 

[Yankees1218]

Voted Mauer...

 

[GiantsSuperCollector]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

But, he has one thing that the other two will never have, unless they change teams

A great pitching staff, or the ring?

 

[hoopster3977]

If Carlos Santana returns 100% from that knee injury caused by some knucklehead Red Sox player, he'll challenge all comers.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

But, he has one thing that the other two will never have, unless they change teams

A great pitching staff, or the ring?

Ring

 

[Rickzcards]

Mauer if he stays healthy. Posey in another year or two.

 

[GiantsSuperCollector]

Posey will be the better run producer whereas Mauer will hit for a higher average and get on base more.

 

[hoopster3977]

Posey will be the better run producer whereas Mauer will hit for a higher average and get on base more.

Your manlove is incredible. ::facepalm::

 

[hofautos]

Mauer but I cannot wait to see what Posey puts on in a full season!

I think Posey had a fluke season, and pitchers will be more selective with him this year, and his rookie season will never be matched by him again.

Man, you are the most negative person on these forums...It will be between Posey or Mauer.

you are the biggest giants fan in these forums (not a bad thing, just a lot of bias)

I'm not negative, just keeping it real with POSEY. I think both McCann and Mauer will have better seasons. I didnt' say i thought Posey will have a bad season, I just don't think he will duplicate his rookie season...you have to admit that season was one of the best seasons by a catcher in the history of baseball....so how is that negative.

 

[GiantsSuperCollector]

Posey will be the better run producer whereas Mauer will hit for a higher average and get on base more.

Your manlove is incredible. ::facepalm::

Look at the stats last year...

 

[George_Calfas]

Posey will more than likely experience the "Sophomore Slump"

How about add "Other" to the votes.

 

[bozemanbreaker]

I voted Posey to skew the votes. Realistically, I think Mauer will put up bigger numbers. Santana should also be included as I think he could have a very productive year minus injury.

 

[aaron41984]

This is the year for MW to break out. He's been put on the back burner by most fans but the skill set is still there.

 

[blitzerlover]

Posey would be incredibly lucky to follow Mccann's career path.

 

[lisu]

It depends on your definition of better numbers. More HR's, more RBI's, or higher batting average?

McCann - i expect will have the most HR's.
Mauer - I expect will have the highest batting average
Posey - I expect will have the most RBI's if he continues to hit in the 4 hole for the Giants.

Mauer will have more RBI's than Posey if he plays an entire season without getting injured.