Which one of these Red Refractors do you like better?

[Zambrano38]

I am going to make an offer on one of these two and I was wondering which one you thought was nicer. Thanks!
4/5

1/5

 

[tommyfro21]

I'm curious how they both got 9.5's based on the centering.

 

[moxacaine]

both look exactly the same. suprised it got a 9.5, centering looks off L/R.

but if i had to pick one i would say the bottom one. it has a nicer auto.

 

[ballerskrip]

both look exactly the same. suprised it got a 9.5, centering looks off L/R.

but if i had to pick one i would say the bottom one. it has a nicer auto.

Agreed....

Not sure why they got 9.5's. I would pay only what a RAW card would get. Those might not make it through as a 9.5 when they are slabbed...

skrip

 

[moxacaine]

both look exactly the same. suprised it got a 9.5, centering looks off L/R.

but if i had to pick one i would say the bottom one. it has a nicer auto.

Agreed....

Not sure why they got 9.5's. I would pay only what a RAW card would get. Those might not make it through as a 9.5 when they are slabbed...

skrip

makes me wonder if they are both not a reseal. i wish there was a way to referece the RCR on becketts website.

 

[Quenepa22]

Bottom one

 

[trevordchi]

The Express roughed him up last night. Was a ton of fun to watch!

 

[Penno]

both look exactly the same. suprised it got a 9.5, centering looks off L/R.

but if i had to pick one i would say the bottom one. it has a nicer auto.

Agreed for that reason alone. The top one has light streak at the end, the bottom one is fuller.

 

[gregbara]

Centering still looks to be at least a 9, so they could be 9.5's, however, neither ones of those autos would get a 10, IMO.

 

[mredsox89]

I'm very wary of RCR cards unless I personally got them or they are being sold by a reputable seller. Along with the fact that they are not guaranteed to receive that grade, I probably wouldn't pay much more than what the raw go for