Who is worse, Mike Minor or Madison Bumgarner

[mwashuc06]

The tail of the tape for two soft tossing lefties.

 

[Jays_Cards]

Ill take Minor over Bumgarner.

 

[MAC16]

i will take minor.
both are getting shelled though.

 

[Seiya]

Bum is a Bum.

 

[darocker80]

hmm bumgarner has had two dominant years. He needs some rest, and if he is injured maybe put him on the DL, but he has at least proven that he can pitch successfully in the pros. Is he gonna be dominant in the MLB, maybe (needs much more work IMO), but because of his track record i would take him over minor right now.

 

[AKA Coastal]

I can't believe Bumgarner has fallen off so much. Are his cards taking a nose dive?

At least Minor still has been putting up some K's. Couple rough starts ,but I wouldn't be as concerned with him as much as Bumgarners velocity falling off.

 

[Superfractor]

I can't believe Bumgarner has fallen off so much. Are his cards taking a nose dive?

At least Minor still has been putting up some K's. Couple rough starts ,but I wouldn't be as concerned with him as much as Bumgarners velocity falling off.

What were his prices relative to pre-fall-out? I see for complete auctions:


Chrome Au BGS 9.5: 39.95
Xfractor Au: 60
Blue Au: 85