Who Is Your Top Giants Prospect?

[Jaypers]

I'm curious to see if this will be a landslide or not. If 'other', please explain.

 

[jbone17]

Bumgarner for sure. He has proved critics wrong the whole year and he has posted a 1.94 ERA this season. He is 10-2 with 4 ND in his last 4 starts. He is a 20 year old pitcher in AA and he is the best in the minors in my book.

 

[andyduke86]

Buster Posey.

I don't own cards of any of these guys.

 

[HoustonTeams4Me]

Honestly, I think this poll is the easiest of all of them thus far... Shake your Bum-Bum!

(BTW, I'm not even a fan of Bum so this isn't some kind of "favorite player", "I've got a stash of him", or "homer" type of response....I just see that this guy is something special & has been dominant with great stuff throughout his short career, & top it off with he's pretty young & in Double-A!!!)

 

[shephech]

In my honest opinion it's Bumgarner.... Could you please do a Blue Jays one soon? If you have not done so already.

Thanks.

Shep :ugeek:

 

[Jaypers]

In my honest opinion it's Bumgarner.... Could you please do a Blue Jays one soon? If you have not done so already.

Thanks.

Shep :ugeek:

I haven't yet, but that's gonna be interesting. When I think of their farm system, I can hear crickets chirping.

 

[shephech]

In my honest opinion it's Bumgarner.... Could you please do a Blue Jays one soon? If you have not done so already.

Thanks.

Shep :ugeek:

I haven't yet, but that's gonna be interesting. When I think of their farm system, I can hear crickets chirping.

Yeah ........

 

[Messier2]

Someone actually picked Nick Noonan?! I'd love to hear his reasoning to pick him over Posey and MadBum...

 

[shephech]

Someone actually picked Nick Noonan?! I'd love to hear his reasoning to pick him over Posey and MadBum...

Nick Noonan Super-Collector

Shep :ugeek:

 

[JacobAlastra]

Obviously its MadBum, but a few others should be recognized as well.I Think Brandon Crawford belongs on the list. Also look out, Brock Bond is the real deal at 2nd!!!! Another to watch for is Chris Dominguez, hes a beast.

 

[C.L.258]

i went with buster, but i didnt notice that bumgarner was on the list

 

[olerudfan]

I picked Ehire cause his name is cool
and figured everyone else would go
for some Bum pitcher.

 

[All The Hype]

I think Brandon Crawford should at least be on the list.


But Bumgarner takes this one by far. Posey is a very good prospect, but there's no way he overtakes Bumgarner.

 

[Jaypers]

Calling darocker.....calling darocker.....

Can't believe he hasn't seen this thread yet. I'm on pins and needles waiting to see him make his obligatory mention of Lincecum. :mrgreen:

 

[rookie380]

I'll take a Bum over a angel or a buster ANYDAY!

 

[sheetskout]

This is the most meaningless poll next to the one that I'm sure will be posted for the Nationals: Madison Bumgarner

 

[Jaypers]

This is the most meaningless poll next to the one that I'm sure will be posted for the Nationals: Madison Bumgarner

I did the Nats already and intentionally left Strasburg out of it. Thanks for voting in such a "meaningless" endeavor.

 

[johnny rook]

My vote goes to Bumgarner as well. Posey's year has been impressive but not good enough to displace Bumgarner as the system's #1. Although I think that Posey will make it to San Francisco first. Of all Giants prospects Thomas Neal has made the biggest jump in my eyes. He's been a run producing machine for San Jose. Angel Villalona and Nick Noonan are having disappointing seasons. A .700 OPS in the CAL League is not impressive. Even as a 19 and 20 years old respectively.

My Top Ten +6
Madison Bumgarner
Buster Posey
Thomas Neal
Zack Wheeler (he will sign)
Angel Villalona
Ehire Adrianza
Tommy Joseph
Rafael Rodriguez
Clayton Tanner
Waldis Joaquin
Brock Bond
Nick Noonan
Jason Stoffel
Roger Kieschnick
Henry Sosa
Matt Graham

 

[ubersweet987]

I voted Posey because I have seen videos of him and was very impressed but have not seen Madison Bumgarner pitch. Buster Posey looks like the real deal though, especially at a premium position.

Also, did you do the Indians top prospect poll yet JP?

 

[Jaypers]

Also, did you do the Indians top prospect poll yet JP?

No. I'll do that one next.