Who will be the top 3 rookies when this season is over

[kidman232]

I honestly really dont see this being a valuable draft class from a hobby stand point, but where does everyone else see the top tier (bv/cv wise) being at the end of the yr.

right now its probably

stafford
sanchez
crabtree

how does it look when the games have been played?

 

[arod305]

Curry
Sanchez
Crabtree

 

[TonyButlerStopSuckin]

Unfortunately there is pretty much no way that Curry even ends in the top 5 when it comes to when it comes to hobby love. I think that if Sanchez or Stafford get a significant amount of playing time they will both struggle and therefore prices will drop. I think a RB like Moreno or Wells will get the top spot followed by some combination for Crab, Sanchez or Stafford

 

[deceptikon1978]

I would say Crabtree, Moreno and then possibly Sanchez.

 

[kidman232]

im a big ohio state fan, but i dont see how beanie stays healthy for the whole season, nor does he have the break away speed for big plays in the nfl. he also shy's away from contact

 

[KandKCards]

Crabtree
Maclin
Sanchez....and I only say that because NY is so hungry for a decent QB that one solid game from him will send them into a frenzy.

 

[aw00d05]

Moreno
Harvin
Nicks

Stafford won't play that much, and Sanchez and Crabtree are overrated IMO.

 

[wheeler281]

Moreno
Crabtree
Macklin

Quote of the day below. I love it

NY is so hungry for a decent QB that one solid game from him will send them into a frenzy.

 

[seahawks4ever]

Unfortunately there is pretty much no way that Curry even ends in the top 5 when it comes to when it comes to hobby love. I think that if Sanchez or Stafford get a significant amount of playing time they will both struggle and therefore prices will drop. I think a RB like Moreno or Wells will get the top spot followed by some combination for Crab, Sanchez or Stafford

and as a Seahawk collector, I am totally OK with Curry getting no hobby love :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[KandKCards]

Moreno
Crabtree
Macklin

Quote of the day below. I love it

NY is so hungry for a decent QB that one solid game from him will send them into a frenzy.

Remember week 1 last year when Favre threw that lucky TD to Stuckey against the Fins? All of NY was convinced it was set to be a Giants-Jets super bowl :lol: :lol:

 

[ross9013]

Crabtree
Maclin
Sanchez....and I only say that because NY is so hungry for a decent QB that one solid game from him will send them into a frenzy.

What he said ^

 

[wheeler281]

Moreno
Crabtree
Macklin

Quote of the day below. I love it

NY is so hungry for a decent QB that one solid game from him will send them into a frenzy.

Remember week 1 last year when Favre threw that lucky TD to Stuckey against the Fins? All of NY was convinced it was set to be a Giants-Jets super bowl :lol: :lol:

OMG right! then it cooled then they win one game against the Titans and it is on again LOL

 

[Gellman]

I think it will be Harvin, Crabtree and Moreno. I wouldnt normally say Harvin, but it seems like Childress thinks he is the second coming, and put him in everywhere. Crabtree would be better, but like the Vikings, they have no QB. Moreno will do well in Denver, not even a question to me.

Hell, Pat White could have a great year, same with Donald Brown if Addai is hurt.

Stafford wont play until later in the season and will SUCK. Sanchez may start after 2-3 games, but will SUCK. QBs usually take a long time to develop especially on bad teams. The lions are a BAD team. Ryan was a huge exception.

 

[Ryo1549]

Crabtree (duh)
Lesean Mccoy
Hakeem Nicks


All are in great situations where they need to step up. Westbrook is already hurt and very rarely can make it through a whole season. I think he's primed for a HUGE year especially with the OL upgrades they made in Philly. He'd be my number one if it wasn't for Crabbers.

 

[G $MONEY$]

Why does no one mention Heyward-Bey? Offensive rookie of the year this year.

 

[ross9013]

Why does no one mention Heyward-Bey? Offensive rookie of the year this year.

Pshh Maclin is better than Heyward and actually has a QB that can throw.

 

[wheeler281]

Why does no one mention Heyward-Bey? Offensive rookie of the year this year.

Pshh Maclin is better than Heyward and actually has a QB that can throw.

Who is that

 

[ross9013]

Why does no one mention Heyward-Bey? Offensive rookie of the year this year.

Pshh Maclin is better than Heyward and actually has a QB that can throw.

Who is that

 

[G $MONEY$]

Why does no one mention Heyward-Bey? Offensive rookie of the year this year.

Pshh Maclin is better than Heyward and actually has a QB that can throw.

Ummm..... excuse me?

[youtube:2jce8fwx]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saLKcfFiCJ0[/youtube:2jce8fwx]

 

[rymflaherty]

Wow! No Donald Brown?

He'd top my list. I was skeptical of his talent until I watched him play, but i honestly think he ran like an NFL running back in college - find a small gap, one quick cut and go - plus good mixture of power and speed. And even though Uconn wasn't playing the toughest schedule - you have to remember they might have had the worst passing game in D1, so everyone knew he was getting the ball and playing against 8 or even 9 man fronts. So...think he'll do well with a Peyton Manning led offense