Whoo did i miss?

[beefycheddar]

Wasn't Paul O'Neill in 1985. I'd rank him up there with a lot of the names on the list.

1986 - Donruss RR, Fleer with Kal Daniels

Could add Lee Smith to 1982

Thanks, I could picture the blue fleer card, but got my years mixed up. Probably thinking of Vince Coleman in 1985.

 

[Y4NK335]

Carlos Lee - 1998

 

[timryan111]

Biggio?? 1989

 

[tonsofcommons]

1998- Troy Glaus
1999- Carlos Pena

 

[hofautos]

Carlos Lee - 1998

good one, thanks

 

[hofautos]

Biggio?? 1989

already have him 1988

 

[cartersprings]

Torii Hunter 1994

 

[hofautos]

1998- Troy Glaus
1999- Carlos Pena

pena has had a tremendous last 3 years...i will add him...

 

[ThoseBackPages]

Like him or not, Dwight Gooden belongs on this list (especially if Raines is on it)

Rock and Doc, remember?

 

[ThoseBackPages]

Delgado - 1992

 

[Y4NK335]

Carlos Lee - 1998

good one, thanks

I show it off when I can

 

[hofautos]

Carlos Lee - 1998

good one, thanks

I show it off when I can

Well, as long as we are showing off

 

[notjomommasclint]

1980 rickey
1981 raines
1982 ripken
1983 boggs,sandberg,gwynn
1984 mattingly,puckett,clemens,franco
1985 mcgwire,
1986 canseco,bonds,will,"joyner",mcgriff
1987 maddux,gallaraga,joyner,palmeiro
1988 smoltz, alomar,biggio,grace,glavine,edgar
1989 griffey,randy johnson,omar,schilling,sheffield
1990 bernie williams, sosa, frank thomas,walker,schilling,giambi,juangone
1991 thome,chipper,bagwell,pedro,ivan,nomar,mussina
1992 mariano,hoffman,piazza,delgado,manny,jeff kent
1993 jeter,helton,edmonds,pettitte,kendall,damon
1994 arod,derrek lee, dye,posada
1995 andruw,vladdy,carpenter,beltran,rolen
1996 ibanez
1997 ortiz,berkman,halladay,aramis,tejada,wagner
1998 rollins,ordonez,"lowell",carlos lee
1999 holliday,crawford,sabathia,hamilton,sorriano,mulder,hudson,dunn,beckett,pena

1981 fernando
1982 scoscia, kent hrbek
1984 darryl strawberry, joe carter
1985 dwight gooden, eric davis, kirby puuckett
1987 barry larkin

 

[Y4NK335]

Carlos Lee - 1998

good one, thanks

I show it off when I can

Well, as long as we are showing off

Sweet stuff! I have been considering sending mine in to be graded as well.

 

[cartersprings]

Albert Belle (1989), although not lasting as long as most, he did dominate throughout the 90's.

 

[wlalocal71]

1985 Orel Herschiser, 1990 Albert Belle, 1987 Matt Williams, 1991 Luis Gonzalez, there's more I'll think of later, I'm sure.

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

Shooty Babitt in 1982. (NOTE: Short MLB career ended in 1981)

 

[hofautos]

1980 rickey
1981 raines
1982 ripken
1983 boggs,sandberg,gwynn
1984 mattingly,puckett,clemens,franco
1985 mcgwire,
1986 canseco,bonds,will,"joyner",mcgriff
1987 maddux,gallaraga,joyner,palmeiro
1988 smoltz, alomar,biggio,grace,glavine,edgar
1989 griffey,randy johnson,omar,schilling,sheffield
1990 bernie williams, sosa, frank thomas,walker,schilling,giambi,juangone
1991 thome,chipper,bagwell,pedro,ivan,nomar,mussina
1992 mariano,hoffman,piazza,delgado,manny,jeff kent
1993 jeter,helton,edmonds,pettitte,kendall,damon
1994 arod,derrek lee, dye,posada
1995 andruw,vladdy,carpenter,beltran,rolen
1996 ibanez
1997 ortiz,berkman,halladay,aramis,tejada,wagner
1998 rollins,ordonez,"lowell",carlos lee
1999 holliday,crawford,sabathia,hamilton,sorriano,mulder,hudson,dunn,beckett,pena

1981 fernando
1982 scoscia, kent hrbek
1984 darryl strawberry, joe carter
1985 dwight gooden, eric davis, kirby puuckett
1987 barry larkin

have puckett in 1984, will add larkin

 

[hofautos]

1985 Orel Herschiser, 1990 Albert Belle, 1987 Matt Williams, 1991 Luis Gonzalez, there's more I'll think of later, I'm sure.

I had orel, but someone said if i have orel i needed to add eric davis, so i pulled orel.

Think i got the list to where i want it...belle should probably be on it, but he has been blacklisted from every other list :lol:

for retired players, for consideration, please list 2 retired players you think the player is better than, and i will reconsider adding them...but i think i got the "bottom" where I want it.

 

[wlalocal71]

Eric Davis over Orel, I'd disagree... Career numbers of .269/282/934 are nice, but Hershiser basically owned 1988, 23 wins, 15 complete games, 59 scoreless consecutive innings (still a record), NL CY Young, NLCS MVP, World Series MVP against the Bash Brothers, and 95 ALCS MVP with the Indians...

*edit* just saw your request for 2 people. I'd put Orel ahead of Joyner, Giambi, Mussina, Kendall (what), Lee, Dye, Carpenter, Ibanez, Aramis, Tejada and Magglio.

isnt schilling 89?

Aren't Gallaraga and Joyner '86? Semantics. and '85 makes me think of Gooden and Eric Davis before Orel