Why Doc Halladay makes sense for the Pinstripes

[phillyfan0417]

a package centered around Joba, Austin Jackson, Jesus Montero would be better than anything the Phillies could put together.

While I don't disagree, I still don't know if they would trade in the division.

There's still a good shot he's in pinstripes. They just aren't blue.

The phillies could put together a better package of prospects but everything I read says the Jays want ML ready prospects and in that case, the yanks are in a better position.

 

[sportscardtheory]

I think the Cardinals should make a push for Halladay AND Holliday. That would be a PR dream... and also upgrade them to near unstoppable.

 

[aarne13]

He's not going to be traded to any team in the AL east period.
The Cards have said that they are not a fit but it is possible that is just a negotiating ploy. I'd say that the Dodgers, Phillies and Cards are potential suitors, The Rockies, Rangers and Angels are long shots.