Your team's MODERN Mount Rushmore

[gogosox40]

White Sox would probably be Frank Thomas, Paul Konerko, Mark Buehrle and Harold Baines.

I was thinking along the same lines but I would possibly put Fisk in there in lieu of Baines.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I537 using Freedom Card Board mobile app

 

[Lancemountain]

Utley
Rollins
Howard
Hamels


Would make a fantastic statue

 

[tribefan26]

Griffey
Edgar
Johnson
Felix

Wow Ichiro doesn't make the top four?

 

[tribefan26]

Thome
Nagy
Ramirez
Belle

 

[Bogeysave82]

Bench (retired in 83)
Rose
Larkin
Jr. Griffey

Statues leading the path to the mountain would be
Sabo
Davis
Rijo
Casey
Votto
Concepcion
Perez
Browning

 

[maxe0213]

As a Yankee fan I'd take Bernie over pettite

 

[jbhofmann]

Pete Rose
Barry Larkin
Eric Davis
Marty Brennaman

 

[MansGame]

Thome
Nagy
Ramirez
Belle

I'd be more like:

Belle
Ramirez
Thome
Lofton


---
Buying Albert Belle cards! PM me!

 

[MaineMule]

Pedro
Big Papi
Clemens
Schilling

Hard to keep Boggs off this but 2 WS and 04 gives Curt the nod.......

 

[RStadlerASU22]

Old team I rooted for Giants : Clark , Williams , Bonds , Posey

Since AZ got the DBax : Johnson , Schilling , and that's it Goldy is sitting n waiting . Not sure between Webb , Williams , Grace , Finley , Luis I'd add. Most prob would say Gonzo, I just wasn't ever a huge fan

Ryan

 

[buck724]

Griffey
Edgar
Johnson
Felix

Nailed it. This would be my vote as well.

 

[Ghumbs]

Edit: ^^^ Sounds like we're in agreement, but there's a pretty strong case for Ichiro over Edgar. In my mind I enjoyed Edgar's XBHs more than Ichiro's barely singles.

Wow Ichiro doesn't make the top four?

I gotta be honest, he totally slipped my mind. He might be interchangeable with Edgar.

What do you other Ms fans think?

 

[Gwynn545]

Edit: ^^^ Sounds like we're in agreement, but there's a pretty strong case for Ichiro over Edgar. In my mind I enjoyed Edgar's XBHs more than Ichiro's barely singles.


I gotta be honest, he totally slipped my mind. He might be interchangeable with Edgar.

What do you other Ms fans think?

No way on Ichiro...compared to the other 4??? No way...I'd even consider Bone ahead of Ichiro as far as the "face" (these are faces, right?) of the franchise.

 

[Lancemountain]

not an M's fan but I thought your original 4 were right on. Nothing against Ichiro

 

[buck724]

Edit: ^^^ Sounds like we're in agreement, but there's a pretty strong case for Ichiro over Edgar. In my mind I enjoyed Edgar's XBHs more than Ichiro's barely singles.


I gotta be honest, he totally slipped my mind. He might be interchangeable with Edgar.

What do you other Ms fans think?

Nothing against Ichiro, he did great things here. But as far as my opinion goes...I agree with the argument of Edgar over Ichiro. His XBH's were more fun to watch, and he hit with average as well as power. I gotta give Edgar the nod over Ichiro.

 

[Juan Gris]

Pete Rose
Barry Larkin
Eric Davis
Marty Brennaman

Yes!

But for a "modern" Mount Rushmore you've got to take Rose off the list. Any of his 3 mediocre (and I'm being kind) seasons from 84-86 would have sent anyone else into retirement if they didn't have 4,000+ hits, acquired outside of our 30-year range, backing up their case.

 

[jbhofmann]

Yes!

But for a "modern" Mount Rushmore you've got to take Rose off the list. Any of his 3 mediocre (and I'm being kind) seasons from 84-86 would have sent anyone else into retirement if they didn't have 4,000+ hits, acquired outside of our 30-year range, backing up their case.

Pete is timeless.
Griffey, my all-time favorite player, was hard to watch on my favorite team.

If anything I'd probably throw Jose Rijo on there instead of Pete.

 

[tramers]

ask me after Pirates win

 

[CFD1415]

Cardinals: Carpenter, Pujols, Ozzie, Molina. For The Record I Didn't Put McGwire Due To PEDs

 

[WaxPax]

Strawberry Gooden Wright Reyes

You got one right...

Piazza
Franco
Wright
Hernandez...over Carter

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Freedom Card Board mobile app