Could Jeter be the first unanimous HOF inductee?

D-Lite · Jul 17, 2012

We have lots of HOF discussions here and the other night I was talking about Seaver and how close he came. In all the years of elections, no one has ever been unanimous and it seems mostly because of certain principles writers (claim to) have.

So my question to you is is Jeter that guy? My logic is we're talking about a player everyone respects, he's got the number and marquee position (regardless of opinion on defensive value), no question of PEDs in the PED era, etc. I just think he may be the perfect storm.

thefatguy · Jul 17, 2012

No

Nolan Ryan wasn't.
Freaking Nolan Ryan. 7 no hitter Nolan Ryan was not a unanimous selection.
300+ Wins, 5700+ K's, a guy who gave up less Career HR than Wins, was not a unanimous selection.

It won't happen.

Jared · Jul 17, 2012

I would say yes. If he cannot be a unanimous choice, then I'm not sure anyone will ever.

goldenegg1 · Jul 17, 2012

There will be at least one person to vote no.
I agree with the poster above, if Nolan Ryan wasn't, no one will.

phillyfan0417 · Jul 17, 2012

goldenegg1 said:
There will be at least one person to vote no.
I agree with the poster above, if Nolan Ryan wasn't, no one will.

There are so many players who would have earned it before Nolan Ryan...

But the answer is no, there are those who will never vote yes the first time.

D-Lite · Jul 17, 2012

phillyfan0417 said:
There are so many players who would have earned it before Nolan Ryan...

But the answer is no, there are those who will never vote yes the first time.

I think those are the people that should lose their votes. Just stupid logic.

thefatguy · Jul 17, 2012

I guarantee there is 1 writer in the 573 that casts 1 or 0 votes every year.

Babe Ruth wasn't unanimous, and was actually beaten by Ty Cobb in total votes.

It won't happen.

200lbhockeyplayer · Jul 17, 2012

Nolan Ryan is hardly the litmus test for anything.

Not sure where he'd rank as far as potential unanimous choices...but not in the top 20 or 30 I would imagine.

uniquebaseballcards · Jul 17, 2012

Only a "perfect" ball player, if one were to ever exist, should receive all votes.

carlitoson · Jul 17, 2012

I'm sure at least one voter from Boston (or Baltimore) will "abstain". LOL.
No.

thefatguy · Jul 17, 2012

uniquebaseballcards said:
Only a "perfect" ball player, if one were to ever exist, should receive all votes.

I did alot of baseball research in university. This was my absolute favorite quote about a baseball player.
Funny how something written about the game 145 years ago still pertains today.

The Model Base Ball Player- Henry Chadwick. Ball Players' Chronicle, October 31, 1867.
HIS PLAYING QUALIFICATIONS
The physical qualifications of our model player are as follows:
To be able to throw a ball with accuracy of aim a dozen or a hundred yards.
To be fearless in facing and stopping a swiftly batted or thrown ball.
To be able to catch a ball either on the "fly" or bound, either within an inch or two of the ground, or eight to ten feet from it, with either the right or left hand, or both.
To be able to hit a swiftly pitched ball or a bothering slow one, with equal skill, and also to command his bat so as to hit the ball either within six inches of the ground, or as high as his shoulder, and either towards the right, centre or left fields, as occasion may require.
To be able to occupy any position on the field creditably, but to excel in one position only. To be familiar, practically and theoretically, with every rule of the game and "point" of play.

thefatguy · Jul 17, 2012

uniquebaseballcards said:
Only a "perfect" ball player, if one were to ever exist, should receive all votes.

Oh you mean Bryce Harper.

sportscardtheory · Jul 17, 2012

He shouldn't be the first (others deserving of 100%), but he also won't be because of the way the voting is. He will be VERY high though.

sportscardtheory · Jul 17, 2012

200lbhockeyplayer said:
Nolan Ryan is hardly the litmus test for anything.

Not sure where he'd rank as far as potential unanimous choices...but not in the top 20 or 30 I would imagine.

Agreed. Nolan Ryan is a deserving first-ballot HOF living legend, but he's certainly not the pitcher most deserving of unanimous voting. I even think Randy Johnson was a better pitcher.

moxacaine · Jul 17, 2012

If guys like Ripken were not unanimous then Jeter wont be. Ripken was a class act on and off the field. One of the best ever at his position and was involved in many things in his community.

aluckypull · Jul 17, 2012

thefatguy said:
Oh you mean Bryce Harper.

:lol:

uniquebaseballcards · Jul 17, 2012

Jeter could always woo each voter by sending these out prior to the vote:

elmalo · Jul 17, 2012

uniquebaseballcards said:
Jeter could always woo each voter by sending these out prior to the vote:

Chromerookies has a gift bag just like that. I asked him where he got it, but he wouldnt tell me.

jcmint · Jul 17, 2012

I think Seaver had the highest % of votes. Jeter should have a very high % no one is ever gonna be 100% because of jealous nothing better to do loser voters. guys who couldnt play the game of this level vote on it. sigh

MansGame · Jul 17, 2012

Great poll

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Could Jeter be the first unanimous HOF inductee?

Will Jeter be a unanimous Hall of Fame inductee?

Yes

No, but will be highest % ever

No, but will be 1st ballot

No, won't make it on first ballot

New member

Active member

New member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

Super Moderator

Active member

Similar threads

Log in