Ryu to have surgery - and why redemptions are completely unfair

Topnotchsy · May 20, 2015

Just saw an article that Hyun-Jin Ryu will likely have shoulder surgery and be out all season.

For Dodgers fans it has to be a little upsetting, but the team does not seem to be missing him much.

For me it's just another example about how incredibly ridiculous the redemption process is.

I bought a large stack of Ryu RC auto card redemptions back in 2013. As he was a pretty highly touted young player, I paid quite a bit for them. Waiting on the cards I had to weather the 2014 season, hoping he pitched well enough to keep prices at a decent level. Meanwhile of course Topps produced newer Ryu autograph cards (and the ones I was waiting for, from Topps Chrome were sticker autos, so they could have made the cards had they chosen.

Now it's almost 2 years later and Ryu goes down with an injury. I'd requested a replacement via email a while back but never heard from Topps. Meanwhile the injury could easily knock the prices of his cards down, and of course that leaves me out to dry.

Lesson learned I guess.

@thankstopps

AnthonyCorona · May 20, 2015

Topnotchsy said:
Just saw an article that Hyun-Jin Ryu will likely have shoulder surgery and be out all season.

For Dodgers fans it has to be a little upsetting, but the team does not seem to be missing him much.

For me it's just another example about how incredibly ridiculous the redemption process is.

I bought a large stack of Ryu RC auto card redemptions back in 2013. As he was a pretty highly touted young player, I paid quite a bit for them. Waiting on the cards I had to weather the 2014 season, hoping he pitched well enough to keep prices at a decent level. Meanwhile of course Topps produced newer Ryu autograph cards (and the ones I was waiting for, from Topps Chrome were sticker autos, so they could have made the cards had they chosen.

Now it's almost 2 years later and Ryu goes down with an injury. I'd requested a replacement via email a while back but never heard from Topps. Meanwhile the injury could easily knock the prices of his cards down, and of course that leaves me out to dry.

Lesson learned I guess.

@thankstopps

That's awful. I have yet to explore the realm of redemptions because of all the horror stories. I can't say I hope he comes back strong because I like the Giants but good luck with a replacement

jbhofmann · May 20, 2015

Topnotchsy said:
Just saw an article that Hyun-Jin Ryu will likely have shoulder surgery and be out all season.

For Dodgers fans it has to be a little upsetting, but the team does not seem to be missing him much.

For me it's just another example about how incredibly ridiculous the redemption process is.

I bought a large stack of Ryu RC auto card redemptions back in 2013. As he was a pretty highly touted young player, I paid quite a bit for them. Waiting on the cards I had to weather the 2014 season, hoping he pitched well enough to keep prices at a decent level. Meanwhile of course Topps produced newer Ryu autograph cards (and the ones I was waiting for, from Topps Chrome were sticker autos, so they could have made the cards had they chosen.

Now it's almost 2 years later and Ryu goes down with an injury. I'd requested a replacement via email a while back but never heard from Topps. Meanwhile the injury could easily knock the prices of his cards down, and of course that leaves me out to dry.

Lesson learned I guess.

@thankstopps

mchenrycards · May 20, 2015

Isn't this a risk of prospecting?

phillyfan0417 · May 20, 2015

mchenrycards said:
Isn't this a risk of prospecting?

It may be the risk of prospecting cards that are redemptions...

Topnotchsy · May 20, 2015

mchenrycards said:
Isn't this a risk of prospecting?

There's a world of difference in taking a risk based on player performance and not being able to do anything with the cards for close to 2 years because they are pending. Ryu performed as expected last season and it would have been very easy to move them if I had them. Having them locked up for 18+ months is completely unfair.

gt2590 · May 20, 2015

Heck, nowadays, the return from TJ surgery is usually quicker than waiting for the redemptions to come back...

Johnny G · May 20, 2015

Will he sign after surgery while healing though?

Topnotchsy · May 20, 2015

Johnny G said:
Will he sign after surgery while healing though?

They have made new were cards with his signatures on it, it's not a question of whether he'll sign, it's a question of whether they care to make the cards.

Austin · May 20, 2015

jbhofmann said:

It's amazing that it took 25 or so years of throwing Hadoukens before Ryu's shoulder gave out. What a beast.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Ryu to have surgery - and why redemptions are completely unfair

Topnotchsy

Featured Contributor, The best players in history?

AnthonyCorona

Well-known member

jbhofmann

Active member

mchenrycards

Featured Contributor, Vintage Corner, Senior Membe

phillyfan0417

Well-known member

Topnotchsy

Featured Contributor, The best players in history?

gt2590

Super Moderator

Johnny G

New member

Topnotchsy

Featured Contributor, The best players in history?

Austin

Well-known member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts