Prospect disscusion from minorleagueball...take your pick..

dchurg · Oct 28, 2008

Take your pick for the start of the 2009 season.

ThoseBackPages · Oct 28, 2008

Maybs

trademhigh · Oct 28, 2008

ThoseBackPages said:
Maybs

+1. It's not too close in my opinion.

NerfXerks · Oct 28, 2008

Cameron Maybin hasn't done much to show me he's a big league caliber player, except those 32 at bats in September. Neither has Rasmus, but remember, power talks.

I guess Maybin is a better prospect at this point, but I'd rather invest in Rasmus.

trademhigh · Oct 28, 2008

NerfXerks said:
Cameron Maybin hasn't done much to show me he's a big league caliber player, except those 32 at bats in September. Neither has Rasmus, but remember, power talks.

I guess Maybin is a better prospect at this point, but I'd rather invest in Rasmus.

We aren't talking about investments. We are talking about who would you rather start for your MLB team in 09.

bballcardkid · Oct 28, 2008

I dont like either one as an investment. I was big on Maybin but gave up last year. I'm glad I sold when I did. If I had to choose though, I would pick Maybin.

NerfXerks · Oct 28, 2008

trademhigh said:
NerfXerks said:

Cameron Maybin hasn't done much to show me he's a big league caliber player, except those 32 at bats in September. Neither has Rasmus, but remember, power talks.

I guess Maybin is a better prospect at this point, but I'd rather invest in Rasmus.

Click to expand...

We aren't talking about investments. We are talking about who would you rather start for your MLB team in 09.

Oh, then easily Maybin. Not even close. Rasmus played in a hitter's league and played poorly in it. There's still time for him to come back, though.

dchurg · Oct 28, 2008

Rasmus had a bad year this year but was coming around when he got injured. Also if you take both players AA stats Rasmus out preformed maybin by a lot.

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS
128 472 93 130 37 3 29 72 70 108 .275 .381 .551 .932 18 3

108 390 73 108 15 8 13 49 60 124 .277 .375 .456 .831 21 7

NerfXerks · Oct 28, 2008

dchurg said:
Rasmus had a bad year this year but was coming around when he got injured. Also if you take both players AA stats Rasmus out preformed maybin by a lot.

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS
128 472 93 130 37 3 29 72 70 108 .275 .381 .551 .932 18 3

108 390 73 108 15 8 13 49 60 124 .277 .375 .456 .831 21 7

Texas League is a hitter's league. That being said, Rasmus was more impressive than Maybin a year ago.

dchurg · Oct 28, 2008

NerfXerks said:
dchurg said:

Rasmus had a bad year this year but was coming around when he got injured. Also if you take both players AA stats Rasmus out preformed maybin by a lot.

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS
128 472 93 130 37 3 29 72 70 108 .275 .381 .551 .932 18 3

108 390 73 108 15 8 13 49 60 124 .277 .375 .456 .831 21 7

Click to expand...

Texas League is a hitter's league. That being said, Rasmus was more impressive than Maybin a year ago.

Hitters league or not, 29 HR as an eighteen year old is impressive .

ThoseBackPages · Oct 28, 2008

dchurg said:
NerfXerks said:

dchurg said:

Rasmus had a bad year this year but was coming around when he got injured. Also if you take both players AA stats Rasmus out preformed maybin by a lot.

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS
128 472 93 130 37 3 29 72 70 108 .275 .381 .551 .932 18 3

108 390 73 108 15 8 13 49 60 124 .277 .375 .456 .831 21 7

Click to expand...

Texas League is a hitter's league. That being said, Rasmus was more impressive than Maybin a year ago.

Click to expand...

Hitters league or not, 29 HR as an eighteen year old is impressive .

who was 18 last year? lol

dchurg · Oct 28, 2008

ThoseBackPages said:
dchurg said:

NerfXerks said:

dchurg said:

Rasmus had a bad year this year but was coming around when he got injured. Also if you take both players AA stats Rasmus out preformed maybin by a lot.

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS
128 472 93 130 37 3 29 72 70 108 .275 .381 .551 .932 18 3

108 390 73 108 15 8 13 49 60 124 .277 .375 .456 .831 21 7

Click to expand...

Texas League is a hitter's league. That being said, Rasmus was more impressive than Maybin a year ago.

Click to expand...

Hitters league or not, 29 HR as an eighteen year old is impressive .

Click to expand...

who was 18 last year? lol

I dont know why I got confused there lol they were both 21 in AA :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Prospect disscusion from minorleagueball...take your pick..

Who would you rather have starting the 2009 season?

Colby Rasmus

Cameron Maybin

dchurg

New member

ThoseBackPages

New member

trademhigh

Active member

NerfXerks

New member

trademhigh

Active member

bballcardkid

New member

NerfXerks

New member

dchurg

New member

NerfXerks

New member

dchurg

New member

ThoseBackPages

New member

dchurg

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts