Jackie Robinson Cut Auto Help?

BGSRCGUY · Dec 23, 2008

Which Jackie Robinson Auto is more desirable?

A cut where he signs Jack R. Robinson or a Cut where he signs Jackie Robinson?

Thinking about buying and wanted to know if their was a difference in price or collectiblilty.

95vr4 · Dec 23, 2008

Mind to share which one are you eying on?

IndyManning18 · Dec 23, 2008

I would prefer "Jackie Robinson" myself.

Tom Oates · Dec 23, 2008

I would prefer "Jackie" myself but would definately be proud to own either...

Mighty Bombjack · Dec 23, 2008

There are a few body parts I might give for either one...

Seriously, as a HOF auto collector, I would care MUCH more about the quality of the sig and the size of the cut (and that it was slabbed by psa/dna or jsa).

All these things equal (along with price), I'd take Jackie.

shanks25 · Dec 23, 2008

I'll go against the flow and say I'd like to have a "Jack" cut. Don't know why but it seems a little bit more rare (not sure if it really is...)......kinda like a G.H. Ruth cut, rather than Babe........

pujolsthomefan33 · Dec 23, 2008

Either would be fantastic, but for resale value down the road, I think many would prefer jackie....also, is the Jack R. a cut check....and what is the other one on. Personally, I try to find Cuts that are not checks because a lot of times players sign a bit differently on checks than they would/did in their playing days--which also means that Robinson CUT AUTO may not have been signed as early as some of his other sigs.

TK

Bigfan5 · Dec 23, 2008

I prefer Jackie instead of Jack. What's the cost on the cut and have you looked into a fully signed piece like a check or other document to see if the price is similar? I got a HOF plaque card signed by him at close to what some of the cuts from UD and the like are selling for.

BGSRCGUY · Dec 23, 2008

Bigfan- I haven't looked at a full piece, I actually prefer the card as I can look at it from time to time, me leaving for Law School will not afford me to have much Memorabilia. Excited about the new Prime Cut patches? I saw one and started foaming.

Pujols- I was looking at stuff from UD, so yes the Jack R is usually a check. A Jackie 01 SPA psa 8 just ended really cheap and I didn't see it or else would have won it. Looks like the Jackie is the preferred response here and on a few other boards.

Shanks- I actually see a lot more Jack R Cuts than Jackie Signatures not sure which is more rare though.

Mighty- I missed out on a rather nice Jackie cut that had a huge signature. He wanted 1400 and we were off by about 50.

Tom- Thanks for your comment.

Indyman- Thanks for the help.

95vr4- There are only Jack R up on the bay right now but I found a Jackie for sale at via a local show.

Jastermereel · Dec 23, 2008

Not to spam, but if you change your mind I know somebody

with a great 1954 Dodgers Ball with a fantastic Jackie Robinson signature (JSA) for less than what you were wanting to drop on a cut.

BGSRCGUY · Dec 23, 2008

Jastermereel said:
Not to spam, but if you change your mind I know somebody with a great 1954 Dodgers Ball with a fantastic Jackie Robinson signature (JSA) for less than what you were wanting to drop on a cut.

Could you PM me a picture?

Jastermereel · Dec 23, 2008

ProspectorsAdvantage said:
Jastermereel said:

Not to spam, but if you change your mind I know somebody with a great 1954 Dodgers Ball with a fantastic Jackie Robinson signature (JSA) for less than what you were wanting to drop on a cut.

Click to expand...

Could you PM me a picture?

Yeah. It will have to be after Christmas though. I can't do it tonight, and no time tomorrow or Thursday.

I bought it about 5 months ago with the sole purpose of reselling it, but if something doesn't fit on my scanner then I'm horrible about getting pictures done. So it's just been sitting here.

It's sharp. The toning isn't bad at all and all the signatures look nice. According to Huggins & Scott the ball is an '8'. It has 23 signatures with a few of them being clubhouse, including Duke Snider. However there are no problems with the big $$ guys, JR, Campanella, & Hodges.

Anyway, I'll get some pictures taken on Friday and will send them.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Jackie Robinson Cut Auto Help?

BGSRCGUY

New member

95vr4

New member

IndyManning18

Active member

Tom Oates

Active member

Mighty Bombjack

Active member

shanks25

Active member

pujolsthomefan33

Active member

Bigfan5

Active member

BGSRCGUY

New member

Jastermereel

Active member

BGSRCGUY

New member

Jastermereel

Active member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts