Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Ok...so seriously, why do you collect?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

predatorkj

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
11,871
Reaction score
2
This isn't one of those "why do you collect the player you collect", or one of those "what got you started collecting" threads. I was asked this the other day and truthfully I get tired of it. But people who don't collect anything really want to know why I collect anything at all. I get asked such questions as what I plan to do with my collection, and what exactly do I "get out of it". Truthfully it can be hard to answer. I give the usual, I like collecting, it's in my blood, runs in my family, and I enjoy looking at what I have amassed. But when somebody asks you what you plan to do with it, and you tell them just pass it on or hold until I die, it kinda makes you yourself wonder exactly what you are doing and why are you doing it.

I absolutely love going through my cards and I like feeling like I've accomplished something when I complete a rainbow or a set. Or when I find that pesky little card that took 6 years to find. Or when I find something I've never seen before, nor knew existed. I guess my only real answer could be that I enjoy the experience. It's just like fishing. You don't keep everything you catch and you certainly can't catch every fish but just being able to catch any at all and have that experience is somehow enjoyable. And plus you have the added ability to find those deep sea monsters very few have ever seen(I think of deep sea fishing where a buddy of mine caught a 19 foot tiger shark which I didn't believe until I saw the picture).

But, on the other hand, we've all got either girlfriends, wives, kids, family, jobs, school, etc. Life is short and you have to enjoy what little free time you can in the maximal way. Balancing your hobby and your life can be hard because you always end up feeling one gets the short end of the stick but it's necessary. It really is. But what does that say about you, or rather, how do you feel about the fact that you spend your free time going through pieces of cardboard depicting professional athletes instead of say, taking your dog or kids to the park, going to the beach and just chilling out, taking a jog or a bike ride, going to the movies with a friend or significant other, reading a book or listening to a cd. There are a million things you could do with your time and many can be argued to be better health wise, or at least socially, for your health or overall well being.

I'd say collecting as a hobby has no real issues. But it, for me at least, has no real concrete goal. I know I'll never obtain every Bagwell card and even if I do, so what. What in the holy hell does that mean? Am I or have I somehow bettered myself? And then what? What does it mean? What do I do or would I do once I reached that plateau? I'd probably focus on other hobby pursuits but have I achieved anything by having all those cards? Have I filled some gap in my life and if so, what does that say about me? Or better yet, what if the gap still doesn't feel closed?

Something tells me I'm aiming way too deep by thinking this hard about it. This hobby for me is one with endless goals that most likely couldn't or shouldn't be achieved. And it's also one where there really should be no plan. It doesn't fit the mold the rest of your life follows. There is no major plan. There is no major strategy. There is no major obtainable goal. Even if one is met, it's trivial at best. It's just you, pissing away a few bucks here and there, on tangible assets that could(in some cases couldn't) be liquidated for monetary gains. It's you pissing away an hour here or an hour there. It's basically just you shaving some time off your life here on earth, having fun with no real reasoning behind it. Not worrying about following a model or recipe. Just having fun. And if you really think about it, don't we all do that in one way or another at times. And sadly, a lot of times, it's on things that would make card collecting seem fruitful and a good idea in comparison. I've certainly spent my time and money on far less fruitful pursuits than cards.

Thoughts?
 

Gwynn545

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 29, 2008
Messages
5,526
Reaction score
45
Location
North Seattle
Uuugghh...now I feel like selling my Gwynns and quitting the hobby...Thanks a lot, Pred, way to make me think...
 

predatorkj

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
11,871
Reaction score
2
Uuugghh...now I feel like selling my Gwynns and quitting the hobby...Thanks a lot, Pred, way to make me think...

I don't think you should feel that way. The point is, why does there have to be a goal or a reason in mind? Any more than there is a goal or a reason in mind when playing a video game or watching a movie or any other entertainment related action you take?
 

TBTwinsFan

New member
Joined
Nov 8, 2009
Messages
24,583
Reaction score
0
Location
Southwestern Minnesota
I have no idea. Boredom I guess. I could complain about it, or make my own fun.

Although, I've come to realize that everything I bought is complete junk that I can't even give away, and most of it has been overpaid for. It's all heading to the thrift store.
 

PadresFan86

New member
Joined
Nov 11, 2011
Messages
2,554
Reaction score
0
Location
California
I'm starting to sell a lot of my stuff. Tired of this hobby. It's only going into the dumps.
 

PadresFan86

New member
Joined
Nov 11, 2011
Messages
2,554
Reaction score
0
Location
California
Just read your whole post. I stopped collecting a few months ago. Saved an a**load of money and went on two vacations. Going on my third next weekend. Couldn't be happier to actually get out and enjoy life instead of cutting up bubble mailers, sorting, logging, toploading etc...Maybe I'm just burnt out.
 

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
1,894
Reaction score
325
Location
Great White North
Why did I collect? Because at the time, I thought it made me feel closer to the game. For nearly a decade, I had a strong emphasis on southpaw pitchers, and I really enjoyed doing the research on those players, along with the thrill of adding a new autograph to my collection. After awhile, though, I simply ran out of steam with the whole thing. I came to realize that I was able to enjoy watching/following/reading about baseball past and present without feeling compelled to acquire a card or autograph to enhance that enjoyment.

Having said that, I still peruse auction houses and Ebay to see what's out there. However, I no longer feel the need to collect anything just for the sake of collecting it. Although I did have some regret with the amount of time and money spent on the hobby over the years, I was fortunate enough not to have it adversely affect my real life.

As of now, I own exactly 2 pieces of sports related memorabilia, but there's no guarantee how long I'll have them. Both are unique in their own way, but if/when the time comes to part with them, I know that someone else will enjoy them.

I now appreciate sports more than ever for what they are without the crutch of purchasing a collectible to validate my enjoyment.

Edit: Why, pray tell, do I frequent a sports memorabilia forum then? For the contests, of course! Many decent folks around here, so hosting little games brings me more enjoyment than collecting has in many years.
 
Last edited:

JackLondon

New member
Joined
Aug 23, 2008
Messages
10,799
Reaction score
0
Location
California
Interesting!

I find that I have just about zero interest in baseball cards nowadays, except for buying an occasional nostalgic item, here and there. I have a small PC that could fit in a 1000-count box and a couple of binders. I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that I have zero interest in the sport of baseball or any other sport anymore (except for the Olympics; 16 days every two years is about right for me). Last season, I probably watched about 5-6 innings of baseball and am fine with that. The sport hasn't changed, but I have.

That being said, I now focus on my book collection (signed and non-signed).

Why did I collect baseball cards? Honestly, I would have to say that it was due to a false need to have fluid goals in life, ones that I could quickly abandon when I needed to do that. I would have to agree with the assessment that collecting anything can lead to anti-social behavior. Yes, we can make acquaintances and friends through the hobby, but we can also seal ourselves off from family and friends in the process. Our cards (or books, or whatever) don't expect anything from us, they don't judge us, and they are patient with us. I readily admit to an awareness of those things when I collect.

Why do I collect books? I would say that it is my "thing," something that is related to my chosen profession and that gives me a feeling that I am a certain type of person. I go through phases of active book collecting and then will go weeks without doing so. The material possession angle tends to make me feel weighted down at times, however. With some of my other collections (sports cards, DVDs, CDs, modern Star Wars toys/items) I have purged a ton from the house. A good litmus test for me has been to sell a few items from each "permanent collection." If I don't feel regret, then the collection doesn't mean enough to me to keep. Amazing how easy it has been to sell off certain things!

Books are a different story. (pun!) I am now more selective about what I buy, and I regularly go through my cases and donate to the FOTL. The books I do buy serve a practical purpose. I read 3-4 hours a day. The books I buy rarely sit on the shelf unopened.

I am not ancient, but I am not too young, either (will be 46 this summer). Recent health problems have convinced me that it is foolish to accumulate so much crap, along with it being financially wasteful.

Whenever I shuffle off this mortal coil, I hope to not leave a ton of crap behind for my family and friends to feel burdened by. I have spent a fair amount of time making extensive lists of people to receive specific items. If they want it, great. If not, they can dump it.
 

uniquebaseballcards

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
6,783
Reaction score
0
I enjoy the look and feel of cards, its connection to the game/nostalgia and the utter simplicity of cardboard.

Trying to over-think a simple collecting hobby such as ours makes no sense. However one needs to be mindful of the people in our hobby who'd take advantage of that naivete in a heartbeat.

I've noticed to many collectors (or is it "collectors" with quotes?) here the hobby involves a ton of work... which is terrible... as a collecting hobby isn't about work.

EDIT: I'd agree life balance is good in everything, not just cards!
 
Last edited:

predatorkj

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
11,871
Reaction score
2
I enjoy the look and feel of cards, its connection to the game/nostalgia and the utter simplicity of cardboard.

Trying to over-think a simple collecting hobby such as ours makes no sense. However one needs to be mindful of the people in our hobby who'd take advantage of that naivete in a heartbeat.

I've noticed to many collectors (or is it "collectors" with quotes?) here the hobby involves a ton of work... which is terrible... as a collecting hobby isn't about work.

EDIT: Life balance is good in everything, not just cards!


I get where you are going with that but even as a true collector, it sure does take some work. You have to work to become knowledgeable about your hobby or to be involved in it. Obviously there are people who don't wish to get that involved and it's really more about just picking up a pack here or there. But really, without collectors, where would this hobby be? I can't count the number of times I've run into dealers who knew way less than I did about any particular release even though they've been selling long enough to have actually sold cases of said release. The hobby and the information it holds lives and dies by us. Which is another reason I said that with everything become dealer centric...it's not good for the health of the hobby. But that's another story for another thread.

I also agree with Jack London which is why I say it can be "work". But I do like the aspect he mentioned of being able to drop the hobby if needed. I never felt that way about comics. But I do about cards.

As others(like notjomommasclint) have suggested, yes, many of us would like to pass our colelction on. But...if you really sit down and think about it, is that why any of us really collect? Is that your true goal in mind? Doubtful.
 

nosterbor

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
6,409
Reaction score
691
Location
Sunny Florida
Just read your whole post. I stopped collecting a few months ago. Saved an a**load of money and went on two vacations. Going on my third next weekend. Couldn't be happier to actually get out and enjoy life instead of cutting up bubble mailers, sorting, logging, toploading etc...Maybe I'm just burnt out.
So....what do you have to show what you spent on your vacations? I tee shirt that states I was here,a bunch of photos no one but you could even enjoy , memories that only you could care about in a fleeting moment. A stain on you shoes from spending a lot of money on booze and getting s-hit faced and puking. I was also like that 35 years ago until I got back into collecting cards. Save yourself call 1-800-422-2737 that's 1-800 IBY-CARDS. Phone lines are open 24hrs a day. So please call now.
 

Mighty Bombjack

Active member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
6,115
Reaction score
12
Nice thread. I think most collectors go through a cycle of existential crises; so much so that I would call it a real and measurable part of the hobby. How many "I'm quitting the hobby" threads have we all seen on boards over the years? How many "I'm back after X years" threads? And how many people do these things without need for the dramatics?

I thin that my reasons are very similar to those elucidated by uniquebaseballcards in the first line of his post. My father bought me cards when I got good grades in middle school. I dropped collecting in high school and college to focus on females and mind-altering substances (and to a lesser extent, school itself). Then I went to work at Topps and got back into the hobby for a couple of years. Then I went to Europe for 4 years and forgot it, then came back and sold/traded almost everything I had in order to build a collection of HOF autographs. I love them and hope my sons do too, but I will have no problems selling them if there is no interest of if the money is needed for any reason.

The interesting question is the "why" of collecting in general (could be cards, books, stamps, video games, anything that has a list that is getting checked off or added to). I think there is something inherently competitive and sort of modernly hunter/gatherer about the whole thing. I mean, when your worry in the day is making sure you know when the next big auction is coming online, your life is relatively pretty damn good. Right here and now, we don't have to compete for life's essentials, so we are chasing replacement "necessities" as part of our evolutionary path.

Tell that to the next yahoo who asks why you collect.
 

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
1,894
Reaction score
325
Location
Great White North
Nice thread. I think most collectors go through a cycle of existential crises; so much so that I would call it a real and measurable part of the hobby. How many "I'm quitting the hobby" threads have we all seen on boards over the years? How many "I'm back after X years" threads? And how many people do these things without need for the dramatics?

I thin that my reasons are very similar to those elucidated by uniquebaseballcards in the first line of his post. My father bought me cards when I got good grades in middle school. I dropped collecting in high school and college to focus on females and mind-altering substances (and to a lesser extent, school itself). Then I went to work at Topps and got back into the hobby for a couple of years. Then I went to Europe for 4 years and forgot it, then came back and sold/traded almost everything I had in order to build a collection of HOF autographs. I love them and hope my sons do too, but I will have no problems selling them if there is no interest of if the money is needed for any reason.

The interesting question is the "why" of collecting in general (could be cards, books, stamps, video games, anything that has a list that is getting checked off or added to). I think there is something inherently competitive and sort of modernly hunter/gatherer about the whole thing. I mean, when your worry in the day is making sure you know when the next big auction is coming online, your life is relatively pretty damn good. Right here and now, we don't have to compete for life's essentials, so we are chasing replacement "necessities" as part of our evolutionary path.

Tell that to the next yahoo who asks why you collect.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs in a nutshell:

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_need

We should reconstruct the pyramid as it pertains to the hobby.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Top