50/50 Mystery Lineup Challenge: Starting Rotation

[alexs64]

Starting Pitcher 1 - 2- 24 Wins 13 HOF 26 Walter Johnson
Starting Pitcher 2 -1-13 32 Wins HOF 64 Cy Young
Starting Pitcher 3 - 3-14 12 Win HOF 24 Grover Alexander
Starting Pitcher 4 - 4-15 24 Wins HOF 48 Christy Mathewson
Starting Pitcher 5 - 5-50 14 Win HOF 28 Warren Spahn



26
64
24
48
28

Score = 190?

Please double check mine. Thanks!

 

[swish54_99]

Starting Pitcher 1 25-39 Tommy John 10 Wins = 10pts
Starting Pitcher 2 1-47 Cy Young 36 (his career high!) Wins x2 HOF = 72 pts
Starting Pitcher 3 6-15 Jim Galvin 37 Wins x2 HOF = 74 pts
Starting Pitcher 4 45-49 Vic Willis 21 Wins x2 HOF = 42 pts
Starting Pitcher 5 1-10 Cy Young 26 Wins x2 HOF = 52 pts

Total = 250 points

This is fun! Thanks Tommy John lol.

 

[swish54_99]

Starting Pitcher 1 - 2- 24 Wins 13 HOF 26 Walter Johnson
Starting Pitcher 2 -1-13 32 Wins HOF 64 Cy Young
Starting Pitcher 3 - 3-14 12 Win HOF 24 Grover Alexander
Starting Pitcher 4 - 4-15 24 Wins HOF 48 Christy Mathewson
Starting Pitcher 5 - 5-50 14 Win HOF 28 Warren Spahn
Closer -7-10 21 Win HOF 42 Kid Nichols


26
64
24
48
28
42

Score = 232?

Please double check mine. Thanks!

Not supposed to do the closer yet.

 

[Topnotchsy]

Have to type on my phone so will try to edit with the rest of the details later:

1. 31x2 = 62
2. 20x2 = 40
3. 19x1 = 19
4. 4x1 = 4
5. 6x2 = 12

Total = 137

 

[GAbballplayer148]

Got 2 great players in Keefe and clarkson but couldnt hit right on their wins.

Greg maddux- 16
Tim keefe - 17(x2) - 34
John clarkson - 16(x2) - 32
Nolan ryan - 11(x3) - 22
Neikro 1 15(x2) -30

Total - 134

 

[MaineMule]

Rotation Wins x 2 if applicable
Starting Pitcher 1 - 5, 11 HOF W. Spahn 17 34
Starting Pitcher 2 - 8, 14 NO G. Maddux 19 19
Starting Pitcher 3 - 1, 10 HOF Cy Young 26 52
Starting Pitcher 4 - 2, 16 HOF W. Johnson 15 30
Starting Pitcher 5 - 7, 22 HOF K. Nichols 30 60

Total 195

 

[robertwolf1]

Rotation
Starting Pitcher 1- K. Nichols #7-13 season 21 wins*2=42
Starting Pitcher 2- R.Clemens #9-15 season 20 wins= 20
Starting Pitcher 3- S.Carlton #11-17 season 13 wins*2=26
Starting Pitcher 4- J.Moyer #34-36 season 11 wins
Starting Pitcher 5- R.Faber #41-42 season 24 wins*2=48

TOTAL =147

 

[alexs64]

Just to be sure, no closer yet correct?

 

[jdbrak]

Starting Pitcher 1... 31.36: Ruffing - 20 x 2
Starting Pitcher 2... 12.15: Clarkson - 53 x 2
Starting Pitcher 3... 11.13: Carlton - 23x2
Starting Pitcher 4... 4.09: Mathewson 37 x 2
Starting Pitcher 5... 1.02: Young - 27 x2

320 - ha

 

[MaineMule]

Starting Pitcher 1... 31.36: Ruffing - 20 x 2
Starting Pitcher 2... 12.15: Clarkson - 53 x 2
Starting Pitcher 3... 11.13: Carlton - 23x2
Starting Pitcher 4... 4.09: Mathewson 37 x 2
Starting Pitcher 5... 1.02: Young - 27 x2

320 - ha

Clarkson was a BIG score- I actually had to look that one up.......

 

[Hendersonfan]

SP1 10/31 Tim Keefe 17 x2 HOF=34
SP2 11/23 Steve Carlton 6 x2HOF=12
SP3 12/26 John Clarkson 10 x2 HOF=20
Sp4 3/11 Grover Alexander 15x2HOF =30
SP5 8/24 Gregg Maddox 2 = 2

Total score = 98

I missed Keefe’s 41 win season by 1 :benson: Clarkson’s 53 win season by 1:benson:, and Alexander’s 27 win season by 1:benson:…I managed to get Carlton’s next to last year:benson:, and Maddox’s first season:benson:….What potential this had… UGH , and yes it was worth 5 Benson's...LOL

I missed Clarkson's 53 season by 2 and instead got his rookie year with 1 win. That could have added another 104! Not even going to look at the rest of mine!

 

[metallicalex777]

SP1 15/34 - Don Sutton (HOF): 21x2 = 42
SP2 2/17 - Walter Johnson (HOF): 17x2 = 34
SP3 7/25 - Kid Nichols (HOF): 21x2 = 42
SP4 28/32 - Fergie Jenkins (HOF): 10x2 = 20
SP5 44/49 - Bob Gibson (HOF): 12x2 = 24

Starting Pitcher Total: 162

 

[MansGame]

Starting Rotation
Starting Pitcher 1 - 1-27 = C Young, 26 wins x2 = 52
Starting Pitcher 2 - 7-28 = K Nichols, 21 wins x2 = 42
Starting Pitcher 3 - 8-32 = G Maddux, 16 wins x1 = 16
Starting Pitcher 4 - 12-45 = J Clarkson, 33 wins x2 = 66
Starting Pitcher 5 - 18-50 = T Seaver, 14 wins x2 = 28

Total 5 Starting Pitchers = 204

 

[jdbrak]

hope this bodes well... 53 wins is crazy

 

[jbmm161]

Starting Pitcher #1 - CY YOUNG 1.15 26 WINS X 2 = 52
Starting Pitcher #2 - EPPA RIXEY 37.34 21 WINS X 2 = 42
Starting Pitcher #3 - WARREN SPAHN 5.19 23 WINS X 2 = 46
Starting Pitcher #4 - KID NICHOLS 7.21 26 WINS X 2 = 52
Starting Pitcher #5 - ROGER CLEMENS 9.23 7 WINS X 1 = 7

Total 199 WINS


Did pretty well I think other than Roger Clemens who killed me with 7, I picked based thinking it had something to do with top players in a category and then got bored and started to picking based on jersey numbers of my favorites at their positions.

 

[cjedmonton]

Nice turnout, everyone. We're only missing 5 folks. The next round will be posted early Friday morning before I head out.

Here's the current leaderboard:



If you aren't near the lead right now, don't fret. When I made this game, I incorporated a few twists to keep things interesting. Not only should this level the playing field, but it'll also prevent folks from working ahead with scoring their team.

I also want to announce several consolation prizes, in addition to the top 5 overall scores.

Top Battery (highest combined score from SP1 & C)
Top Double Play (highest combined score of SS & 2B)
Top Corner (highest combined score of 1B & 3B)
Top Outfield (highest combined score of LF,CF,RF)
Top Individual Score (highest score from any of the 15 positions)

 

[Archie Graham]

Starting Pitcher 1 22-44: Randy Johnson- 8 wins
Starting Pitcher 2 7-14: Kid Nichols - 10 wins x 2 HOF
Starting Pitcher 3 29-39: Tony Mullane- 1 win
Starting Pitcher 4 14-15: Nolan Ryan - 11 wins x 2 HOF
Starting Pitcher 5 48-50: Amos Rusie- 0 wins

Total: 51
Got a 0 win season... That about wraps up my feelings on my starters..

 

[steve-a-reno]

Big thanks to metalicalexxx for helping me out on this. My score stinks. LOL

SP1 31/45 - Red Ruffing (HOF): 0x2 = 0 :sad:
SP2 21/32 - Tom Glavine (not HOF): 15x1 = 15
SP3 41/29 - Red Faber (HOF): 21x2 = 42
SP4 34/47 - Jamie Moyer (not HOF): 11x1 = 11 (someone please double check due to multiple years on different teams in the same year)
SP5 15/14 - Don Sutton (HOF): 12x2 = 24

Total Starting Pitcher Score: 92

 

[metallicalex777]

Big thanks to metalicalexxx for helping me out on this. My score stinks. LOL

SP1 31/45 - Red Ruffing (HOF): 0x2 = 0 :sad:
SP2 21/32 - Tom Glavine (not HOF): 15x1 = 15
SP3 41/29 - Red Faber (HOF): 21x2 = 42
SP4 34/47 - Jamie Moyer (not HOF): 11x1 = 11 (someone please double check due to multiple years on different teams in the same year)
SP5 15/14 - Don Sutton (HOF): 12x2 = 24

Total Starting Pitcher Score: 92

It does stink...but you are almost at half more points than Archie Graham above you

No offense Archie!!!

 

[Archie Graham]

None taken... I thought it could only get better... Sadly it was a train wreck I had to look at until the end.