After nearly a 2 year layoff I'm back with a contest : )

[G $MONEY$]

Ill guess 48 and welcome back!!!!

 

[TRmatt20]

49.5
Thanks for the contest

 

[tennisprobry]

If your score of 80 wins I get to retire : )

welcome to the site and I dig the ryans in the give away


My guess is 80

 

[richezOne]

Welcome back and Thanks for the contest!

1. psa 6
2. psa 6.5
3. psa 6
4. psa 6
5. psa 7
6. psa 7.5
7. psa 6
8. psa 8

=53

 

[wideright]

Thanks for the contest!

1- PSA7
4- PSA6.5
2- PSA6
1- PSA5.5

Total=44.5

 

[tennisprobry]

Just so it is clear if you just have a total number (like if you said the total score would be 52) then you aren't able to qualify for beating the other person in case of a tiebreaker. To be able to win the tie-breaker you need to give me a grade for each of the 8 cards.

Like this.
1 = 7
2 = 6.5
3 = 6
4= 5.5
5= 7
6=6.5
7=7.5
8=8
Total Score of 54

If you just gave a total score and if you don't tie with anyone else then you are fine. I just wanted to point this out as some people did the full grading for each card and some just did the total of all.

Thanks, Bryan

 

[tennisprobry]

We need a few more guesses for this. I got an email saying PSA received the cards on Tuesday so we might get lucky and have the results back soon!

 

[tennisprobry]

After nearly a 2 year layoff I'm back with a contest : ) *UP

They switched my grading order to two different orders as they wanted to be able to charge me more for my PeeWee Reese as it books for $1,000 And after that they screwed me and gave it a PSA5. Not at all happy with that. Was hoping for a 6 or 6.5. I know there are little ink issues but the centering, edges and surface are really nice so I am not at all happy with this first grade. I am hoping to have the other grades back tomorrow night and then we will see who wins the cards.

Thanks, Bryan

 

[hofmichael]

Re: After nearly a 2 year layoff I'm back with a contest : ) *UP

They switched my grading order to two different orders as they wanted to be able to charge me more for my PeeWee Reese as it books for $1,000 And after that they screwed me and gave it a PSA5. Not at all happy with that. Was hoping for a 6 or 6.5. I know there are little ink issues but the centering, edges and surface are really nice so I am not at all happy with this first grade. I am hoping to have the other grades back tomorrow night and then we will see who wins the cards.

Thanks, Bryan

They are not off with the grade of 5 on the Reese.But I do agree that on another day it could have been a 6.Nothing to be pissed at because it is a great card regardless of the grade.
Mike

 

[tennisprobry]

I think it is a solid 6. I have this card in a 6 that I bought off ebay. Mine is obviously nicer. I can't get a good enough scan to point the difference out on here but if you hold them next to each other there is a huge difference. I know the other 6 could just be overgraded, but I have the Mantle in a 5 and Musial in a 6 from this set and the Reese I just sent in is the nicest of all of them. End of rant...

 

[TGutta]

Haha just saw the post deadline. Good luck with some nice grades!

 

[hofmichael]

I think it is a solid 6. I have this card in a 6 that I bought off ebay. Mine is obviously nicer. I can't get a good enough scan to point the difference out on here but if you hold them next to each other there is a huge difference. I know the other 6 could just be overgraded, but I have the Mantle in a 5 and Musial in a 6 from this set and the Reese I just sent in is the nicest of all of them. End of rant...

I understand where you are coming from but the top left corner is what is keeping out of a 6 holder.

 

[tennisprobry]

The ink in the corner?

 

[jmagic87]

1 PSA7
2 PSA7
3 PSA7.5
4 PSA6
5 PSA8
6 PSA6
7 PSA 7
8 PSA6.5

That comes to 56.

 

[tennisprobry]

Results are posted on the first page. Thanks to all that participated!